TL;DR
This paper reports a high-precision measurement of the proton's electric-to-magnetic form factor ratio at low momentum transfer. The results confirm a significant deviation from unity, suggesting different spatial distributions for the proton's charge and magnetization, and provide updated values for the proton's charge and magnetic radii.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Understanding the internal structure of the proton is a fundamental goal in nuclear physics. This structure is described by its electromagnetic form factors, which relate to the distribution of charge and magnetization within the proton. For decades, these form factors were primarily studied using unpolarized electron-proton scattering. However, recent experiments using polarized beams and targets revealed a discrepancy: the ratio of the electric to magnetic form factor, $\mu_p G_E / G_M$, was found to drop significantly with increasing momentum transfer ($Q^2$) at high $Q^2$, a trend not seen in older unpolarized measurements. This discrepancy is now understood to be largely due to two-photon exchange (TPE) effects, which affect unpolarized scattering more than polarized measurements.
This paper focuses on the low $Q^2$ regime, where the proton's structure is believed to be dominated by its "pion cloud." While previous experiments had probed this region, this work aimed for unprecedented precision to precisely map the behavior of $\mu_p G_E / G_M$ and its implications for the proton's charge and magnetic radii. Specifically, it addresses the question of whether the deviation from unity observed at high $Q^2$ extends to very low $Q^2$, and whether there are any subtle structures in this ratio at low $Q^2$.
Methods
The experiment was conducted at Jefferson Lab (JLab) in Hall A, utilizing a high-intensity polarized electron beam and a recoil polarimetry technique. The core of the measurement involved scattering polarized electrons off a liquid hydrogen target. The key innovation here is the recoil polarimetry, which directly measures the polarization of the scattered proton. This method is less susceptible to the two-photon exchange (TPE) effects that complicate unpolarized scattering measurements, especially at higher $Q^2$.
The experiment measured the transverse to longitudinal polarization transfer of the recoil proton. This ratio, $R = P_t / P_l$, is directly related to the proton's electric and magnetic form factors by the equation:
$R = \mu_p G_E / G_M = - \frac{E_e + E_e'}{2M_p} \tan(\theta_e/2) \frac{P_t}{P_l}$
where $E_e$ and $E_e'$ are the incident and scattered electron energies, $M_p$ is the proton mass, $\theta_e$ is the electron scattering angle, and $P_t$ and $P_l$ are the transverse and longitudinal components of the proton's polarization.
The scattered protons were detected by the Left High Resolution Spectrometer (LHRS), and the polarization was measured using a focal plane polarimeter (FPP). The experiment employed a sophisticated beam helicity-switching scheme to cancel out systematic uncertainties.
Datasets
The primary dataset used in this paper is the experimental data collected at Jefferson Lab for the $\mu_p G_E / G_M$ ratio at $Q^2$ values ranging from 0.3 to 0.7 (GeV/c)$^2$. This new dataset is then compared with and incorporated into global fits that include previously published data from other experiments, such as those from Bates [13] and JLab [14], as well as older, lower-precision data.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The deviation from unity in $\mu_p G_E / G_M$ is a low-$Q^2$ phenomenon: The data strongly indicate that the ratio $\mu_p G_E / G_M$ is significantly below 1 even at the lowest $Q^2$ measured (0.3 GeV/c)$^2$, and this trend continues across the entire measured range. This suggests that the spatial distributions of the proton's charge and magnetization are different, even at the relatively large scales probed at low $Q^2$.
- No evidence of structure at low $Q^2$: Despite the significant deviation from unity, the measurements show no indication of any subtle structures or bumps in the $\mu_p G_E / G_M$ ratio within the explored $Q^2$ range. This implies a smooth, monotonic fall-off.
- Pion cloud's importance confirmed: The observed behavior at low $Q^2$ is consistent with theoretical models that emphasize the role of the "pion cloud" in the proton's structure, which describes the virtual emission and reabsorption of pions by the quarks.
- Consistent radii, different distributions: The extracted proton electric and magnetic RMS radii are found to be consistent. However, the detailed behavior of the form factors even at low $Q^2$ implies that the underlying charge and magnetization distributions have different shapes, even if their overall extents (radii) are similar.
- Discrepancy with muonic hydrogen: The extracted proton charge radius is in excellent agreement with electron-proton scattering and atomic hydrogen measurements, but shows a significant (7.7$\sigma$) difference from the value obtained from muonic hydrogen Lamb shift measurements. This suggests a potential missing correction in either electron or muon probes, or a more exotic explanation.
Key Results
- High-precision measurement of $\mu_p G_E / G_M$: The experiment achieved a total uncertainty of approximately 1% for the ratio $\mu_p G_E / G_M$ in the $Q^2$ range of 0.3-0.7 (GeV/c)$^2$.
- Updated global fit: The inclusion of these new data in a global fit of proton form factors resulted in an electric form factor approximately 2% smaller and a magnetic form factor approximately 1% larger than previous global fits.
- Proton radii extractions:
- Proton electric RMS radius: $\langle r_E^2 \rangle^{1/2} = 0.875 \pm 0.010$ fm (experimental uncertainty) $\pm 0.006$ fm (fit uncertainty).
- Proton magnetic RMS radius: $\langle r_M^2 \rangle^{1/2} = 0.867 \pm 0.009$ fm (experimental uncertainty) $\pm 0.018$ fm (fit uncertainty).
- Charge radius agreement: The extracted proton charge radius is in excellent agreement with other electron-based measurements, yielding $r_E^2 = 0.8772 \pm 0.0046$ fm from electron-proton interactions.
Limitations and Future Work
- Systematic uncertainties: While the statistical precision is high, the overall uncertainty is dominated by systematic uncertainties, particularly those related to the proton's spin precession in the spectrometer's magnetic fields.
- Muonic hydrogen discrepancy: The significant difference between the extracted proton charge radius from electron-based measurements and the muonic hydrogen result remains a puzzle. Further investigation into potential missing corrections in QED or more exotic explanations is needed.
- Theoretical model comparisons: While some theoretical models show qualitative agreement, none precisely match the new data. This suggests that further refinement of theoretical descriptions of the proton's structure, particularly concerning the pion cloud and non-valence contributions, is required.
- Future measurements: The paper implicitly suggests the need for continued high-precision measurements across a wider range of $Q^2$ and potentially with different techniques to further elucidate the proton's structure and resolve discrepancies.
Summary updated