TL;DR
This paper presents a novel gated-PQAR circuit for InGaAs/InP single-photon avalanche diodes (SPADs) that significantly reduces afterpulsing. By employing low-parasitic chip-to-chip wire bonding, they achieve a remarkable 0.3% afterpulsing probability at 13% PDE, a crucial step for advancing quantum communication and other sensitive photon-counting applications.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Single-photon avalanche diodes (SPADs) are essential for detecting faint light signals in applications like quantum communication, biological imaging, and laser ranging. InGaAs/InP SPADs are particularly attractive for their high photon detection efficiency (PDE) in the near-infrared (NIR) spectrum. However, a major performance bottleneck for these devices is "afterpulsing." Afterpulsing occurs when charge carriers, trapped during a primary avalanche event, are released later and trigger a secondary avalanche, leading to false detections. This significantly degrades the accuracy and reliability of photon counting. While material improvements can help, this paper focuses on circuit-level solutions to mitigate afterpulsing in existing SPAD technology.
Methods
The authors introduce an "improved gated-PQAR" (passive quenching with active reset) circuit. The core innovation lies in the physical implementation: instead of using discrete components, they directly mount the SPAD and associated GaAs FETs on a sapphire carrier and use low-parasitic chip-to-chip wire bonding. This technique drastically reduces stray capacitance (C<sub>stray</sub>) associated with the SPAD anode.
The circuit operates by periodically biasing the SPAD with an "excess bias" (V<sub>ex</sub>) above its breakdown voltage, defining detection windows. A quenching transistor (M1) is used to quickly turn off the avalanche. A sensing transistor (M2) amplifies the avalanche signal, providing a clean output for a counter. The key advantage of this gated-PQAR approach is its ability to combine the simplicity of passive quenching with the fast recharge capabilities of active quenching.
To characterize afterpulsing, they employ a "double-pulse measurement technique." This involves sending two gate pulses with a variable delay (the "hold-off time") between them. The first pulse triggers a guaranteed avalanche. If a second avalanche is detected after the hold-off time, it's attributed to afterpulsing. Dark count probability (DCP) is also measured to subtract non-afterpulse dark counts.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The experiments utilize a specific 25-µm-diameter planar InGaAs/InP-based SACM APD grown by metal-organic chemical vapor deposition (MOCVD).
Key Insights and Ideas
- Wire Bonding Matters: The most significant finding is that reducing parasitic capacitance through chip-to-chip wire bonding dramatically reduces avalanche charge (Q<sub>A</sub>) and, consequently, afterpulsing. This suggests that packaging and interconnects are critical performance factors, not just the semiconductor material itself.
- Trade-offs are Quantifiable: The paper clearly demonstrates the trade-offs between PDE, DCP, and afterpulsing probability as a function of excess bias and pulse width. This allows for informed selection of operating parameters based on application requirements.
- Effective Gate Width is Key: Shorter pulse widths, while potentially reducing afterpulsing, can also lead to a shorter "effective gate width." The authors show that even with a reduced effective gate width, a better trade-off can be achieved if it remains "tolerable" for the application.
- Gated-PQAR Balances Simplicity and Performance: The gated-PQAR circuit offers a practical solution by integrating passive quenching benefits with active reset, avoiding the complexity of purely active quenching circuits when device capacitance is low.
Key Results
- Reduced Afterpulsing: At 230K, the improved gated-PQAR circuit achieved 0.3% afterpulsing probability for a 10 ns hold-off time, with 13% PDE, 2×10<sup>-6</sup> DCP, and an effective gate width of 0.4 ns.
- High PDE Achieved: For the same 10 ns hold-off time, they also demonstrated 30% PDE with 1×10<sup>-5</sup> DCP and 6% afterpulsing probability, achieved with a narrower pulse width (0.7 ns effective gate width).
- Avalanche Charge Reduction: The chip-to-chip wire bonding implementation showed an approximate 16-fold reduction in avalanche charge (Q<sub>A</sub>) compared to a discrete component implementation.
- Afterpulsing Trend: Afterpulsing probability was observed to decrease roughly as the inverse of the hold-off time, with a slope of approximately -1 on a log-log plot.
Limitations and Future Work
- Temperature Dependence: While data is presented at 230K, the paper also shows results for other temperatures (e.g., Figure 6), indicating that performance varies with temperature. Further optimization across a wider temperature range might be necessary for some applications.
- Material Specificity: The results are specific to the tested InGaAs/InP SPAD. While the circuit design is generalizable, the exact performance metrics would depend on the specific SPAD characteristics.
- Future Work: The paper implicitly suggests that further optimization of the wire bonding and circuit design could lead to even lower afterpulsing and higher PDE. Exploring different materials or device structures in conjunction with this circuit could also be a future direction.
Summary updated