High-order extended coprime array design for direction of arrival estimation

Junpeng Shi, Fangqing Wen, Yongxiang Liu, Tianpeng Liu, Zhen LiuJournal of Systems Engineering and Electronics 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Nonuniform linear arrays, such as coprime array and nested array, have received great attentions because of the increased degrees of freedom (DOFs) and weakened mutual coupling. In this paper, inspired by the existing coprime array, we propose a high-order extended coprime array (HoECA) for improved direction of arrival (DOA) estimation. We first derive the closed-form expressions for the range of consecutive lags. Then, by changing the inter-element spacing of a uniform linear array (ULA), three cases are proposed and discussed. It is indicated that the HoECA can obtain the largest number of consecutive lags when the spacing takes the maximum value. Finally, by comparing it with the other sparse arrays, the optimized HoECA enjoys a larger number of consecutive lags with mitigating mutual coupling. Simulation results are shown to evaluate the superiority of HoECA over the others in terms of DOF, mutual coupling leakage and estimation accuracy.

Introduction

Direction of Arrival (DOA) estimation is a cornerstone of array signal processing, vital for radar, sonar, and wireless communication. While Uniform Linear Arrays (ULAs) are standard, they are limited by the number of physical sensors ($N$) and suffer from mutual coupling when sensors are packed tightly. Sparse arrays like nested and coprime arrays overcome these limits by creating a virtual "difference coarray" with $O(N^2)$ degrees of freedom (DOFs). However, many existing sparse arrays still face challenges with "holes" in their virtual arrays or significant mutual coupling. This paper introduces the High-order Extended Coprime Array (HoECA) to address these limitations.

The HoECA Architecture

The proposed HoECA enhances the Relocating Extended Coprime Array (RECA) by adding a strategic fourth subarray. As shown in Figure 1, the HoECA consists of four distinct components: a first ULA with $N$ sensors and spacing $M$, a second ULA with $M$ sensors and spacing $N$, a third subarray designed to fill specific coarray holes, and a fourth subarray with $M$ sensors and a flexible inter-element spacing $\gamma$.

The physical configuration of the proposed HoECA, highlighting the four distinct subarrays and their inter-element spacings.

By optimizing the spacing $\gamma$, the researchers identified three distinct cases. They mathematically proved that setting $\gamma = N$ (Case 3) maximizes the number of consecutive lags in the virtual array, effectively filling more "holes" than previous designs and providing a massive boost in DOFs.

Performance and Results

The HoECA was evaluated against state-of-the-art benchmarks including RECA, Thinned Coprime Array (TCA), and Coprime Array with Compressed Inter-element Spacing (CACIS) using Monte Carlo simulations.

A key metric is the Root Mean Square Error (RMSE) of the DOA estimation. As illustrated in Figure 3, the HoECA consistently achieves lower RMSE across a wide range of snapshot counts compared to its competitors. This superior accuracy stems from its increased number of consecutive virtual sensors. For instance, with 17 physical sensors, HoECA provides 149 consecutive lags, significantly higher than RECA (141) or CACIS (89).

RMSE performance comparison against benchmarks as a function of the number of snapshots, showing HoECA's superior accuracy.

Furthermore, the HoECA maintains low mutual coupling resilience. It demonstrated a coupling leakage of 0.1295, which is significantly lower than CACIS (0.3486), proving it successfully balances high DOFs with reduced inter-sensor interference.

Conclusion

The High-order Extended Coprime Array (HoECA) represents a significant advancement in sparse array design. By strategically adding and optimizing a fourth subarray, it achieves higher DOFs and better DOA estimation accuracy than existing coprime variants while mitigating the performance-degrading effects of mutual coupling. Future research may extend these principles to 2D array geometries for azimuth and elevation estimation in real-world environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

Nonuniform linear arrays, such as coprime array and nested array, have received great attentions because of the increased degrees of freedom (DOFs) and weakened mutual coupling. In this paper, inspired by the existing coprime array, we propose a high-order extended coprime array (HoECA) for improved direction of arrival (DOA) estimation. We first derive the closed-form expressions for the range of consecutive lags. Then, by changing the inter-element spacing of a uniform linear array (ULA), three cases are proposed and discussed. It is indicated that the HoECA can obtain the largest number of consecutive lags when the spacing takes the maximum value. Finally, by comparing it with the other sparse arrays, the optimized HoECA enjoys a larger number of consecutive lags with mitigating mutual coupling. Simulation results are shown to evaluate the superiority of HoECA over the others in terms of DOF, mutual coupling leakage and estimation accuracy.
BibTeX
@article{shi2021high,
  author = {Junpeng Shi and Fangqing Wen and Yongxiang Liu and Tianpeng Liu and Zhen Liu},
  title = {{High-order extended coprime array design for direction of arrival estimation}},
  journal = {Journal of Systems Engineering and Electronics},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.23919/jsee.2021.000064},
}
Figure