High-Mass Starless Clumps: Dynamical State and Correlation Between Physical Parameters

Bo Huang, Ke Wang, J. M. Girart, Wenyu Jiao, Qianru He, En‐Wei LiangarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

High-mass starless clumps (HMSCs) represent the earliest observable stages of massive star formation. This study analyzes a sample of 207 HMSCs across the inner Galactic plane using $^{13}$CO(2-1) spectral line data from the SEDIGISM survey. The investigation focuses on the dynamical state of these regions, characterizing their turbulence, gravitational stability, and the potential role of magnetic fields. We find that HMSCs are highly turbulent, supersonic environments, with approximately half of the sample being gravitationally bound and requiring significant magnetic field support to maintain stability.

Introduction

Massive stars (over 8 $M_\odot$) are fundamental drivers of galactic evolution, yet their formation process remains a subject of intense debate. Two primary models—core accretion and competitive accretion—offer different perspectives on whether massive stars form from stable, massive cores or through the accumulation of gas in crowded environments. To distinguish between these theories, astronomers study High-Mass Starless Clumps (HMSCs). These dense regions of gas and dust possess the mass necessary to form massive stars but have not yet begun the process, offering a window into the initial conditions of star birth.

Methods and Datasets

The research utilizes high-resolution spectral line data from the SEDIGISM survey, specifically the $^{13}$CO(2-1) transition, to probe the internal kinematics of the clumps. The sample was derived from an initial catalog of 463 HMSCs identified by Yuan et al. (2017) using ATLASGAL 870 $\mu$m continuum data, eventually narrowing to 207 sources with high-quality spectral detections.

Linewidths were measured using Gaussian fitting with the Levenberg-Marquardt algorithm. The dynamical state was assessed through virial analysis, comparing kinetic energy to gravitational potential energy to calculate the virial parameter ($\alpha_{vir}$). For clumps found to be gravitationally bound ($\alpha_{vir} \lesssim 2$), the researchers estimated the theoretical magnetic field strength ($B$) required to provide stability against collapse. Additionally, dust temperatures and bolometric luminosities were integrated from Hi-GAL (Herschel) data to explore correlations between physical parameters.

Results and Discussion

Turbulence and Stability

The analysis reveals that HMSCs are far from quiescent. The internal gas is highly supersonic, with a median Mach number ($\mathcal{M}_S$) of approximately 8.2. This intense turbulence serves as the primary internal pressure resisting gravity.

Distributions of linewidth, Mach number, virial mass, virial parameter, and required magnetic field strength for the HMSC sample.

Roughly 44% to 55% of the clumps are identified as gravitationally bound. Without additional support, these clumps would be expected to undergo immediate collapse. The study suggests that magnetic fields play a crucial role in providing this missing stability. The median magnetic field strength required for equilibrium is estimated at 0.33–0.37 mG, which aligns with observations in similar star-forming regions.

Scaling Relations and Evolutionary Indicators

A significant finding is the breakdown of Larson’s Law—the standard scaling relationship between cloud size and internal velocity dispersion—within these dense clumps. This suggests that at the high densities characteristic of HMSCs, gravity or large-scale inflowing gas dominates over simple turbulent cascades.

Correlation between the estimated magnetic field strength (B) and volume density (ρ) as well as column density (NH2).

The study also identified a strong correlation between the required magnetic field strength and volume density, following the power law $B \propto \rho^{0.5}$. This relationship supports models where magnetic fields are "frozen" into the gas as it contracts. Furthermore, the ratio of bolometric luminosity to clump mass ($L_{bol}/M_{cl}$) was found to be a reliable proxy for dust temperature, scaling as $T_{dust}^6$, which suggests that temperature can serve as an effective "clock" for these early evolutionary stages.

Conclusion

This study provides a comprehensive statistical overview of the dynamical state of HMSCs in the inner Galaxy. While these clumps are highly turbulent and often gravitationally bound, the current resolution limits our understanding of their internal structure. Future high-resolution observations with facilities like ALMA will be essential to resolve the individual cores within these clumps and determine whether they fragment into many small stars or a few massive ones.

Summary updated

Abstract

In order to study the initial conditions of massive star formation, we have previously built a sample of 463 high-mass starless clumps (HMSCs) across the inner Galactic plane covered by multiple continuum surveys. Here, we use $^{13}$ CO(2-1) line data from the SEDIGISM survey, which covers 78$^{\circ}$ in longitude ($-60^{\circ}
BibTeX
@misc{huang2023high,
  author = {Bo Huang and Ke Wang and J. M. Girart and Wenyu Jiao and Qianru He and En‐Wei Liang},
  title = {{High-Mass Starless Clumps: Dynamical State and Correlation Between Physical Parameters}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2303.07501},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2303.07501},
}
Figure