High Genetic Diversity of HIV-1 and Active Transmission Clusters among Male-to-Male Sexual Contacts (MMSCs) in Zhuhai, China

Yi Zhou, Mingting Cui, Zhongsi Hong, Shaoli Huang, Shuntai Zhou, Hang Lyu, Jiarun Li, Yixiong Lin, Huitao Huang, Weiming Tang, Caijun Sun, Wenyan HuangViruses 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the genetic diversity and transmission patterns of HIV-1 among male-to-male sexual contacts (MMSCs) in Zhuhai, China. By combining phylogenetic analysis with recent infection testing, researchers identified active transmission clusters, including a notable cluster driven by the CRF79_0107 variant, highlighting the need for targeted public health interventions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

HIV/AIDS remains a significant global health challenge, with certain key populations, like MMSCs, disproportionately affected due to higher risk behaviors and societal vulnerabilities. Understanding the genetic diversity of HIV-1 and identifying recent infections are crucial for effective HIV epidemiology monitoring and for curbing transmission. Specifically, pinpointing active transmission clusters, especially those involving recently infected individuals, allows for the prioritization of prevention efforts. The emergence of novel HIV-1 circulating recombinant forms (CRFs) and unique recombinant forms (URFs) in China adds complexity to prevention and control strategies. This paper addresses the need for a detailed molecular epidemiological analysis of HIV-1 in a specific high-prevalence urban setting (Zhuhai) among MMSCs, focusing on identifying transmission networks and recent infections to inform targeted interventions.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • HIV-1 Sequencing: The HIV polymerase (pol) gene fragments were amplified using nested PCR from plasma samples of newly diagnosed HIV-positive MMSCs. These sequences were then analyzed using Sanger sequencing.
  • Recent Infection Testing: A Recent Infection Testing Algorithm (RITA) was utilized. This algorithm combined a limiting antigen avidity enzyme immunoassay (LAg-EIA) with clinical data (CD4+ T cell count and viral load) to classify infections as recent or long-term.
  • Phylogenetic and Clustering Analysis: HIV-1 sequences were aligned and subjected to phylogenetic analysis using the maximum likelihood method. Genetic transmission networks were constructed using the Tamura-Nei93 model at different genetic distance thresholds (0.5% and 1.5%) to identify clusters of related infections. This allowed for the visualization of transmission pathways and the identification of active transmission clusters.
  • Statistical Analysis: Descriptive statistics were used to characterize the study population. Logistic regression models were employed to identify factors associated with recent HIV infection and high linkage within transmission networks.

Datasets

The study utilized blood samples from 190 HIV-positive MMSCs in Zhuhai, China, who were newly diagnosed and had not yet started antiviral treatment. These samples were collected between January 2020 and June 2022. Additionally, publicly available HIV-1 sequences of the CRF79_0107 variant were downloaded from the Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL) database to understand its broader epidemic context.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • High Genetic Diversity: The study confirms significant genetic diversity of HIV-1 in Zhuhai, with multiple subtypes and CRFs circulating among MMSCs. This diversity poses challenges for vaccine development and treatment strategies.
  • Active Transmission Clusters: The identification of transmission clusters, particularly at a 1.5% genetic distance threshold, highlights ongoing HIV transmission within the MMSC population.
  • CRF79_0107 as a Driver of Transmission: A particularly concerning finding is the identification of a large active transmission cluster (n=10) infected with the CRF79_0107 variant. This variant, though less prevalent in previous studies, appears to be driving recent infections in this cohort.
  • RITA's Utility: The study demonstrates the effectiveness of the RITA approach in identifying recent infections, which are crucial for pinpointing individuals who are most likely to be actively transmitting the virus and thus require immediate intervention.
  • Clustering as a Risk Factor for Recent Infection: Multivariable logistic regression revealed that individuals within transmission clusters were significantly more likely to be recently infected, underscoring the importance of cluster detection for targeted prevention.

Key Results

  • Recent Infections: 19.5% (37/190) of participants were identified as recently infected.
  • Dominant Subtypes: CRF07_BC was the most prevalent subtype (48.4%), followed by CRF55_01B (17.9%) and CRF01_AE (16.3%).
  • CRF79_0107 Prevalence: CRF79_0107 accounted for 10% (19/190) of the study population.
  • Transmission Clusters: At a 1.5% distance threshold, 15 clusters were identified, with 25.8% (49/190) of participants belonging to a cluster.
  • Active Transmission Clusters: Within these clusters, 38.8% (19/49) were recent infections, indicating active transmission.
  • Largest Cluster: The largest identified cluster (n=10) was infected with CRF79_0107, with a significant proportion of recent infections.
  • Clustering and Recent Infection: Participants in transmission clusters were significantly more likely to be recently infected (adjusted OR: 3.64).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Convenience Sampling: The study samples were collected through convenience sampling, which may not be fully representative of the entire MMSC population in Zhuhai, potentially introducing sampling bias.
  • Incomplete Sequences: The use of partial genetic sequences (pol gene) for phylogenetic analysis might be suboptimal for areas with high HIV genetic variation, potentially affecting the accuracy of cluster identification.
  • Small Sample Size for Baseline Comparison: The study noted no significant differences between recent and long-term infection groups at baseline, suggesting the sample size might be too small for robust statistical comparisons.
  • Exclusion Criteria for RITA: The LAg-Avidity assay has exclusion criteria (e.g., individuals on ART, elite controllers), which might affect the accuracy of incidence estimates in certain populations.

Future work could involve expanding the study to include complete HIV genomes for more precise phylogenetic analysis, conducting larger, population-based studies with random sampling, and integrating more comprehensive epidemiological and behavioral data to better understand transmission dynamics and inform more effective prevention strategies. The study also highlights the need for continued surveillance of emerging HIV variants like CRF79_0107.

Summary updated

Abstract

Monitoring genetic diversity and recent HIV infections (RHIs) is critical for understanding HIV epidemiology. Here, we report HIV-1 genetic diversity and RHIs in blood samples from 190 HIV-positive MMSCs in Zhuhai, China. MMSCs with newly reported HIV were enrolled from January 2020 to June 2022. A nested PCR was performed to amplify the HIV polymerase gene fragments at HXB2 positions 2604-3606. We constructed genetic transmission network at both 0.5% and 1.5% distance thresholds using the Tamura-Nei93 model. RHIs were identified using a recent infection testing algorithm (RITA) combining limiting antigen avidity enzyme immunoassay (LAg-EIA) assay with clinical data. The results revealed that 19.5% (37/190) were RHIs and 48.4% (92/190) were CRF07_BC. Two clusters were identified at a 0.5% distance threshold. Among them, one was infected with CRF07_BC for the long term, and the other was infected with CRF55_01B recently. We identified a total of 15 clusters at a 1.5% distance threshold. Among them, nine were infected with CRF07_BC subtype, and RHIs were found in 38.8% (19/49) distributed in eight genetic clusters. We identified a large active transmission cluster (<i>n</i> = 10) infected with a genetic variant, CRF79_0107. The multivariable logistic regression model showed that clusters were more likely to be RHIs (adjusted OR: 3.64, 95% CI: 1.51~9.01). The RHI algorithm can help to identify recent or ongoing transmission clusters where the prevention tools are mostly needed. Prompt public health measures are needed to contain the further spread of active transmission clusters.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhou2023high,
  author = {Yi Zhou and Mingting Cui and Zhongsi Hong and Shaoli Huang and Shuntai Zhou and Hang Lyu and Jiarun Li and Yixiong Lin and Huitao Huang and Weiming Tang and Caijun Sun and Wenyan Huang},
  title = {{High Genetic Diversity of HIV-1 and Active Transmission Clusters among Male-to-Male Sexual Contacts (MMSCs) in Zhuhai, China}},
  booktitle = {Viruses},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/v15091947},
}
Figure