High-frequency amplitude-modulated sinusoidal stimulation induces desynchronized yet controllable neural firing

Beatrice Barra, Ritesh Kumar, Chaitanya Gopinath, Ehsan Mirzakhalili, Scott F. Lempka, Robert A. Gaunt, Lee E. FisherbioRxiv 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel electrical stimulation waveform called Fast Amplitude-Modulated Sinusoidal (FAMS) stimulation. FAMS aims to create more natural neural responses by desynchronizing neural firing, which could lead to more realistic sensory feedback for prosthetic limbs and other neuroprosthetic applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Restoring sensory feedback for individuals with limb amputations is a critical goal in neuroprosthetics. Current methods often use rectangular electrical pulses to stimulate peripheral nerves, which can lead to unnatural sensations and rapid muscle fatigue. This is thought to be due to the synchronous and periodic nature of the neural activity evoked by these pulses. The authors aim to overcome this by developing a stimulation method that mimics natural neural firing patterns, which are typically asynchronous and irregular.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Computational Modeling: They developed a biophysically realistic computational model of myelinated axons to simulate neural responses to different stimulation waveforms. This model allowed them to investigate the effects of various stimulation parameters on neural firing patterns.
  • Sinusoidal Waveform Design: They explored the use of sinusoidal waveforms, hypothesizing that their smoother charge injection profile would lead to desynchronized firing. They then designed the FAMS waveform, which combines a high-frequency carrier sinusoid with low-frequency amplitude modulation.
  • In Vivo Experiments: They implemented the FAMS waveform in a feline model by stimulating the sciatic nerve and recording neural activity from dorsal root ganglia. This allowed them to compare FAMS-evoked activity with that evoked by traditional rectangular pulses.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on computational simulations and in vivo electrophysiological recordings.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Sinusoidal Stimulation for Desynchronization: The study highlights that sinusoidal waveforms, unlike rectangular pulses, can inherently lead to more asynchronous and irregular neural firing.
  • Frequency Dependence: The frequency of sinusoidal stimulation significantly impacts neural firing patterns, with lower frequencies promoting population desynchronization and higher frequencies inducing more irregular firing within individual neurons.
  • FAMS Waveform Synergy: The FAMS waveform cleverly combines the benefits of low and high-frequency sinusoidal stimulation, achieving both population desynchronization and individual neuron irregularity while mitigating issues like excessive charge injection or conduction block.
  • Ion Channel Rectification: The non-linear dynamics of ion channels play a crucial role in rectifying and filtering the FAMS waveform, leading to neuron-specific responses and contributing to asynchronous firing.
  • Controllable Firing: Despite inducing irregular firing, FAMS allows for precise control over overall firing rates and response timing by adjusting simple parameters like amplitude, carrier frequency, and beat frequency.

Key Results

  • Computational Model: Sinusoidal stimulation in the model resulted in more variable spike timings compared to rectangular pulses.
  • FAMS Efficacy: In silico and in vivo experiments showed that FAMS stimulation evoked significantly more asynchronous neural activity than rectangular pulses.
  • In Vivo Desynchronization: FAMS achieved substantially higher desynchronization in feline DRG recordings compared to rectangular pulses (e.g., +154% in one animal).
  • Quasi-Stochastic Firing: FAMS stimulation led to inter-spike interval distributions that closely approximated an exponential decay, indicating quasi-stochastic firing behavior in individual neurons.
  • Controllable Firing Rates: FAMS allowed for smooth and controllable firing rate profiles, with parameters like amplitude directly influencing firing rate and response latency.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Safety: The safety of sinusoidal waveforms, particularly regarding electrode and tissue damage, requires further investigation, similar to studies on rectangular pulses.
  • Technological Shift: Current implantable stimulators are primarily designed for rectangular pulses. A paradigm shift to sinusoidal waveforms would necessitate new stimulation technologies capable of delivering continuous waveforms with fine temporal resolution.
  • Perceptual and Fatigue Studies: The study did not directly assess how FAMS stimulation is perceived by humans or its impact on fatigue in functional electrical stimulation (FES). Future work should investigate the viability of FAMS for specific applications by thoroughly characterizing its effects on sensory percepts, paresthesia, and muscle contractions.
  • Model Validation: While the computational model accurately captured firing dynamics, further validation with a wider range of neuron types and conditions would be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

Regaining sensory feedback is pivotal for people living with limb amputation. Electrical stimulation of sensory fibers in peripheral nerves has been shown to restore focal percepts in the missing limb. However, conventional rectangular current pulses induce sensations often described as unnatural. This is likely due to the synchronous and periodic nature of activity evoked by these pulses. Here we introduce a fast-oscillating amplitude-modulated sinusoidal (FAMS) stimulation waveform that desynchronizes evoked neural activity. We used a computational model to show that sinusoidal waveforms evoke asynchronous and irregular firing and that firing patterns are frequency dependent. We designed the FAMS waveform to leverage both low- and high-frequency effects and found that membrane non-linearities enhance neuron-specific differences when exposed to FAMS. We implemented this waveform in a feline model of peripheral nerve stimulation and demonstrated that FAMS-evoked activity is more asynchronous than activity evoked by rectangular pulses, while being easily controllable with simple stimulation parameters. These results represent an important step towards biomimetic stimulation strategies useful for clinical applications to restore sensory feedback.
BibTeX
@misc{barra2024high,
  author = {Beatrice Barra and Ritesh Kumar and Chaitanya Gopinath and Ehsan Mirzakhalili and Scott F. Lempka and Robert A. Gaunt and Lee E. Fisher},
  title = {{High-frequency amplitude-modulated sinusoidal stimulation induces desynchronized yet controllable neural firing}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1101/2024.02.14.580219},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure