High-efficiency monitoring of respiratory viruses in a single exhaled breath

Quanjun Liu, Weihao Li, Han Gao, Michael Cheng, Chaoyi Yin, Manman Lv, Yaling Han, Haoran Yu, Weiming Lin, Yan Huang, Q Zhang, Dianhuai Meng, T R Weng, Zuhong LuResearch Square 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a "Phase-change Drywall Cyclone Sampler" (PDC-sampler) that can detect respiratory viruses like SARS-CoV-2 and H1N1 from just a single exhaled breath. By integrating condensation with a specialized cyclone separator, the device captures viral particles in tiny, highly concentrated liquid volumes, achieving a detection limit of just 5–9 copies per breath—significantly lower than the typical infectious dose.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Current gold-standard diagnostics for respiratory viruses rely on invasive and uncomfortable methods like throat or nasal swabs. While exhaled breath (EB) is a promising non-invasive alternative, it presents a "needle in a haystack" problem: viral loads in breath are extremely low ($10^3$ to $10^7$ copies per breath), and the most infectious particles are often tiny aerosols ($< 5 \mu m$) that are difficult to trap.

Existing breath samplers often suffer from two main flaws: they either fail to capture these small aerosols efficiently, or they require large amounts of "buffer" liquid to wash the samples out, which dilutes the virus so much that it becomes nearly impossible to detect without long collection times.

Methods

The authors introduced the PDC-sampler, a device that combines two clever engineering principles:

  1. Phase-change Condensation: The device uses a condensation module pre-cooled to $-15^\circ C$. As a person breathes into the inlet, the moisture in their breath rapidly condenses into tiny droplets, "wrapping" around the viral particles.
  2. Drywall Cyclone Separation: These droplets enter a cyclone chamber where centrifugal forces, gravity, and surface tension cause them to spiral down the walls. Crucially, this is a "drywall" system—it requires no added liquid, meaning the resulting sample is just 8–10 $\mu L$ of highly concentrated "breath juice."

To push the detection limits even further, the team coupled the sampler with a microfluidic electrophoretic enrichment chip. This chip uses electrical fields to pull negatively charged viral particles into an even smaller volume before analysis via RT-qPCR or droplet digital PCR (ddPCR).

Datasets

The study validated the system using:

  • Simulated EB: Bioaerosol generators were used to create "artificial breath" containing inactivated SARS-CoV-2 and H1N1 (Influenza A) at various concentrations.
  • Human Volunteers: A clinical study involving healthy individuals and patients confirmed to have COVID-19 or H1N1 at a hospital fever clinic.
  • Benchmarks: The system's performance was directly compared against traditional throat swabs and a commercial bioaerosol sampler (ASE-200p).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Zero Dilution is Key: By using the breath's own moisture as the collection medium, the researchers avoided the dilution issues that plague "wet-wall" cyclone samplers. This allows for high-sensitivity detection from a single breath rather than minutes of breathing.
  • Capturing the "Transmitters": The device is exceptionally good at capturing small aerosols. It achieved $>60\%$ efficiency for $0.5 \mu m$ particles and nearly $100\%$ for $2 \mu m$ particles—the exact size range most responsible for long-range viral transmission.
  • Better than Swabs?: In real-world testing, the PDC-sampler's results were comparable to or even better than throat swabs. In some cases, patients who tested negative via throat swab were "weakly positive" via the breath sampler, suggesting it might catch infections earlier or more reliably.

Key Results

  • Extreme Sensitivity: When combined with ddPCR, the detection limit dropped to 5–9 copies per single exhaled breath. For context, the minimum concentration required for infection is estimated at $\sim 10^2$ copies.
  • Speed: The system can collect a usable sample from a single breath (SEB) or a 1-minute session ($\sim 20$ breaths).
  • Clinical Accuracy: In a case study of a COVID-19 patient, the sampler tracked the viral load over three days, matching the trends seen in antigen tests and swabs perfectly. For H1N1 patients, the breath samples consistently showed higher viral concentrations than traditional swabs.

Limitations and Future Work

While the results are impressive, the authors note a few hurdles for mass deployment:

  • Environmental Sensitivity: The "drywall" condensation method relies on breath moisture. Extreme ambient humidity or temperature might affect collection efficiency, requiring further "all-weather" testing.
  • System Integration: Currently, the enrichment chip and the sampler are separate components. The authors aim to integrate these into a single, fully automated "plug-and-play" device.
  • Throughput: The enrichment speed of the microfluidic chip currently lags behind the collection speed of the sampler, creating a minor bottleneck in the workflow.

By solving the collection efficiency problem, this work paves the way for "breathalyzer" style kiosks in airports or hospitals that could screen for multiple respiratory threats in seconds.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Exhaled breath (EB), as a non-invasive biological sample, has garnered attention for diagnosis and monitoring respiratory diseases. However, efficiently collecting EB viruses for downstream detection remains a key challenge. This study introduced a novel Phase-change Drywall Cyclone Sampler (PDC-sampler), which was designed and optimized through airflow control to integrate condensation with drywall cyclone gas-liquid separation. The PDC-sampler efficiently collects viral particles from EB (8-10 μL per single EB (SEB)) without requiring a sampling liquid solution. When combined with the gold-standard reverse transcription-quantitative polymerase chain reaction (RT-qPCR), it enabled routine positive detection in infected individuals (≥ 10 <sup>3</sup> copies/SEB). By coupling with the low-cost microfluidic electrophoretic virus enrichment chip or the high-cost and highly sensitive droplet digital PCR (ddPCR), the detection limit of EB viruses was reduced to 5-9 copies/SEB, which is an order of magnitude lower than the minimum viral concentration required for infection (~ 10 <sup>2</sup> copies/SEB). Notably, tests on coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) and influenza-infected volunteers demonstrated performance comparable to or better than throat swabs, validating the PDC-sampler’s effectiveness in real-world applications. This study provides an efficient, automated, and non-invasive solution for the early diagnosis, transmission mechanism study, and large-scale screening and monitoring of respiratory diseases.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2024high,
  author = {Quanjun Liu and Weihao Li and Han Gao and Michael Cheng and Chaoyi Yin and Manman Lv and Yaling Han and Haoran Yu and Weiming Lin and Yan Huang and Q Zhang and Dianhuai Meng and T R Weng and Zuhong Lu},
  title = {{High-efficiency monitoring of respiratory viruses in a single exhaled breath}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-5708899/v1},
}

Loading related content...

Figure