High CO2 Reduces Spoilage Caused by Botrytis cinerea in Strawberry Without Impairing Fruit Quality

Hua Li, Yuwei Yin, Fahrizal Yusuf Affandi, Caihong Zhong, R.e. Schouten, Ernst J. WolteringFrontiers in Plant Science 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study demonstrates that high CO2 concentrations (20-30 kPa) combined with reduced oxygen (10 kPa) effectively suppress Botrytis cinerea spoilage in strawberries without negatively impacting fruit quality. Interestingly, a stepwise increase in CO2 did not offer additional benefits over static high CO2 application, suggesting that "Arabella" strawberries are remarkably tolerant to elevated CO2.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Strawberries are highly perishable, limiting their shelf life and market reach. Botrytis cinerea, a common fungal pathogen, significantly contributes to postharvest losses. While controlled atmosphere (CA) storage, particularly high CO2, is known to inhibit fungal growth and extend shelf life, it can also lead to undesirable outcomes like fruit softening, discoloration, and off-flavors. Previous research suggested that a stepwise increase in CO2 might mitigate these negative effects. This paper investigates whether high CO2, applied either statically or stepwise, can effectively reduce Botrytis cinerea spoilage in strawberries without compromising their quality, and if there's a cultivar-specific tolerance to these conditions.

Methods

The study employed a two-part experimental design.

Experiment I (Sonsation cultivar): This experiment focused on identifying optimal CA conditions for reducing spoilage. Various combinations of O2 (5-10 kPa) and CO2 (10-20 kPa) were tested under static CA conditions at 5°C. Fruit spoilage, weight loss, firmness, and soluble solids (Brix) were assessed during storage and a subsequent shelf-life period.

Experiment II (Arabella cultivar): Building on Experiment I, this phase investigated the effects of higher CO2 concentrations (up to 30 kPa) and the impact of stepwise vs. static application. Treatments included static 10 kPa O2 with 0, 20, or 30 kPa CO2, and stepwise increases of CO2 to 20 or 30 kPa over four days, all at 5°C. A control group with ambient atmosphere (21 kPa O2, 0 kPa CO2) was also included. Key measurements included respiration rate, spoilage incidence, firmness, weight loss, pH, organic acids, sugars, ascorbic acid, and anthocyanins.

Standard analytical techniques were used for biochemical analyses, including HPLC for sugars, organic acids, and antioxidants. Firmness was measured using specialized testing machines.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized fresh strawberry fruit of two cultivars, "Sonsation" and "Arabella," harvested from commercial greenhouses and fields.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • High CO2 is a potent spoilage inhibitor: The most striking finding is the significant reduction in Botrytis cinerea spoilage with elevated CO2 levels (20-30 kPa) when combined with reduced O2 (10 kPa). This effect was consistent across both tested cultivars.
  • "Arabella" cultivar shows remarkable CO2 tolerance: Unlike some previous reports suggesting negative impacts of high CO2, "Arabella" strawberries maintained good quality (firmness, color, antioxidants) even under 30 kPa CO2. This suggests cultivar-specific tolerance is a crucial factor.
  • Stepwise CO2 offers no added benefit: Contrary to expectations from some studies on other fruits, a gradual increase in CO2 concentration did not provide any superior quality retention compared to maintaining a static high CO2 level. This simplifies storage protocols.
  • CO2 suppresses respiration and maintains pH: High CO2 significantly reduced fruit respiration rates and helped maintain a higher pH, contributing to better overall quality retention.
  • Sugar metabolism shifts under high CO2: While total sugar levels remained relatively stable, high CO2 promoted the conversion of sucrose into glucose and fructose, indicating a metabolic shift.
  • Firmness is preserved, not enhanced: High CO2 treatments prevented the typical loss of firmness observed in control fruits, but did not lead to increased firmness.

Key Results

  • Spoilage Reduction: In Experiment I, 10 kPa O2 with 20 kPa CO2 significantly reduced spoilage in "Sonsation" strawberries compared to the control. In Experiment II, 20 and 30 kPa CO2 with 10 kPa O2 greatly suppressed spoilage in "Arabella" strawberries during storage and shelf life. For instance, after 3 days of shelf life, fruit stored under CA30 (static 10 kPa O2 + 30 kPa CO2) had the lowest spoilage incidence (32%).
  • Quality Maintenance: High CO2 treatments (20 and 30 kPa) maintained fruit firmness and did not negatively affect ascorbic acid or anthocyanin levels in "Arabella" strawberries.
  • Respiration: Respiration rates were significantly lower in fruit stored under elevated CO2 (20 and 30 kPa) compared to control and CA0 (10 kPa O2, 0 kPa CO2) conditions.
  • Sugar Conversion: High CO2 treatments led to a more pronounced conversion of sucrose into glucose and fructose.
  • No Fermentation: The study found no evidence of fermentation in "Arabella" strawberries treated with up to 30 kPa CO2, suggesting a high tolerance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cultivar Specificity: While "Arabella" showed high tolerance, the findings might not be universally applicable to all strawberry cultivars. Further research on a wider range of cultivars is warranted.
  • Stepwise Application: The study found no benefit from stepwise CO2 application in strawberries. Future work could explore if different stepwise strategies or durations might yield different results for other fruit types or under different storage conditions.
  • Long-term Storage: The study focused on storage up to 11 days followed by a short shelf life. Investigating the effects of these high CO2 treatments on even longer storage durations would be valuable.
  • Sensory Evaluation: While biochemical markers were assessed, a comprehensive sensory evaluation (taste, aroma) would provide a more complete picture of fruit quality.

The authors suggest that "Arabella" strawberry fruit are highly tolerant to elevated CO2 and can be stored under 30 kPa CO2 to prolong shelf life, indicating a promising avenue for commercial application.

Summary updated

Abstract

High CO<sub>2</sub> (> 20 kPa) conditions are beneficial for suppressing spoilage caused by <i>Botrytis cinerea</i> in strawberry fruit; however, these conditions are often accompanied by discoloration, off-flavors, and faster softening. Stepwise increments of CO<sub>2</sub> concentrations have been proposed to alleviate injuries in fruits caused by high CO<sub>2</sub>. In this study, we investigated whether stepwise increments of CO<sub>2</sub>, up to 30 kPa and under a reduced O<sub>2</sub> concentration, are beneficial for reducing fungal spoilage without inducing CO<sub>2</sub> injury symptoms in strawberry fruit. Based on recommended settings (5-10 kPa O<sub>2</sub> with 15-20 kPa CO<sub>2</sub>), we first selected optimal O<sub>2</sub> and CO<sub>2</sub> concentrations that best-reduced spoilage caused by <i>B. cinerea</i> in red ripe "Sonsation" strawberry fruit. We found that higher O<sub>2</sub> (10 kPa) and CO<sub>2</sub> (20 kPa) concentrations were most beneficial for prolonging strawberry fruit shelf life. Subsequently, we studied the performance of red ripe "Arabella" strawberry fruit stored at 5°C under different controlled atmosphere (CA) conditions (10 kPa O<sub>2</sub> with either 0, 20, or 30 kPa CO<sub>2</sub>). The CO<sub>2</sub> concentrations were achieved either within 8 h or in a stepwise manner within the first 4 days of storage. As a control, 21 kPa O<sub>2</sub> and 0 kPa CO<sub>2</sub> were used. Following storage for up to 11 days, the spoilage incidence was assessed at 12°C for 5 days. The application of high CO<sub>2</sub> (20 and 30 kPa) combined with 10 kPa O<sub>2</sub> greatly suppressed fruit spoilage during storage and subsequent shelf life. High CO<sub>2</sub> suppressed respiration as well as maintained a higher pH and firmness in treated fruit. The level of total sugars did not change, but during storage, a substantial part of sucrose was converted into glucose and fructose, especially under high CO<sub>2</sub> conditions. High CO<sub>2</sub> did not affect ascorbic acid and anthocyanin levels. The stepwise increments of CO<sub>2</sub> did not result in beneficial effects compared to the static application of high CO<sub>2</sub>. Our results show that "Arabella" strawberry fruit are highly tolerant to elevated CO<sub>2</sub> and can be stored under 30 kPa CO<sub>2</sub> to prolong the shelf life.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2022high,
  author = {Hua Li and Yuwei Yin and Fahrizal Yusuf Affandi and Caihong Zhong and R.E. Schouten and Ernst J. Woltering},
  title = {{High CO2 Reduces Spoilage Caused by Botrytis cinerea in Strawberry Without Impairing Fruit Quality}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Plant Science},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fpls.2022.842317},
}

Loading related content...

Figure