Higgs Physics at LEP2

Marcela Carena, P. Ohmann, J.j. van der Bij, E. Gross, R. Keränen, Michel Rausch de Traubenberg, T. Riemann, S. Katsanevas, P. Janot, F.a. Berends, T. Binoth, G. Crosetti, T. Wlodek, A. Ballestrero, G. Wolf, D.y. Bardin, Ronald Kleiss, A. Sopczak, J. Marco, C. De Saint Jean, R. Silvestre, M. Dubinin, O. J. P. Éboli, G. Mikenberg, E. Duchovni, Bernd A. Kniehl, A. Djouadi, R. Pittau, V. Driesen, F. Piccinini, S. W. Ham, J.-p. Ernenwein, Michael Spira, Michael Krämer, Tilman Plehn, P. Bambade, S. Hoorelbeke, C. Hajdu, H. Genten, R. Folman, D. Vilanova, P.m. Zerwas, E. Lund, W. Hollik, Ulrich Ellwanger, C. Mariotti, Ralf Hempfling, André H. Hoang, S. J. de Jong, J. R. Espinosa, S. Shichanin, R. Ehret, Elena Accomando, O. Nicrosini, R. Contri, J. Cuevas, Howard E. Haber, B. R. Kim, Shinji Yamashita, J. W. F. Valle, G. Burkart, M. Felcini, A. Dabelstein, C.a. Savoy, R. Faccini, Sam King, Wolfgang Kilian, G. Montagna, F. de Campos, F. Di Lodovico, M. R. Monge, J. Kalinowski, M. Quirós, Fabio Zwirner, K. Hultqvist, Carlos E. M. Wagner, P. L. White, M. Shimojima, Janusz Rosiek, P. Bagnaia, A. Leike, P. Lutz, W. De Boer, U. Jost, S. K. Oh, Giampiero Passarino, J G Guy, Ruhlmann-Kleider, Wlodek, T., Wolf, G., Yamashita, S., Zwirner, F.arXiv 1996 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

In this report, we review the prospects for Higgs physics at the Large Electron-Positron Collider (LEP2). The theoretical aspects and phenomenology of Higgs particles are discussed within the Standard Model (SM) and the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM). Experimental search techniques are described, and discovery limits for Higgs bosons in the LEP2 energy range are summarized. Additionally, we investigate the opportunities for detecting Higgs particles in non-minimal extensions of the SM and the MSSM.

Introduction

In the mid-1990s, the Higgs boson remained the most significant "missing piece" of the Standard Model (SM). As the particle responsible for electroweak symmetry breaking and the generation of mass for all other fundamental particles, its discovery was the primary objective of high-energy physics. While the first phase of the LEP collider (LEP1) successfully explored the Z boson pole, it did not find the Higgs, establishing a lower mass limit of approximately 65 GeV. This 1996 report serves as the definitive technical roadmap for the LEP2 upgrade, evaluating the collider's potential to either discover the Higgs boson or significantly constrain its theoretical "hiding space."

Theoretical Framework and Search Mechanisms

The search for the Higgs at LEP2 primarily relies on the Higgs-strahlung process ($e^+e^- \to ZH$), where an electron-positron pair annihilates into a virtual Z boson that subsequently radiates a Higgs boson. A secondary production mechanism, WW fusion, also contributes to the signal at higher energies.

One of the report's central insights is that discovery potential is primarily driven by center-of-mass energy ($\sqrt{s}$) rather than just integrated luminosity. Because the Higgs is produced in association with a Z boson, the kinematic reach is strictly bounded by the relation $m_H < \sqrt{s} - m_Z$. Consequently, every additional GeV of beam energy significantly expands the discovery horizon.

The Supersymmetric Higgs Sector

Beyond the Standard Model, the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM) predicts a more complex Higgs sector consisting of five physical states: two neutral CP-even bosons ($h, H$), one CP-odd boson ($A$), and two charged bosons ($H^\pm$).

The report highlights a crucial "seesaw" relationship between the $h$ and $A$ bosons in the MSSM. If the production of one is suppressed, the other is typically enhanced. This complementarity ensures that LEP2 can probe a vast portion of the MSSM parameter space, particularly the "infrared fixed point" scenario where the top quark mass and Higgs mass are tightly correlated.

Methodology and Simulation

To quantify the discovery reach, the authors integrated theoretical calculations with detailed experimental simulations from the four LEP collaborations (ALEPH, DELPHI, L3, and OPAL). Key components of the analysis included:

  • Radiative Corrections: In the MSSM, the Higgs mass is heavily influenced by quantum loops, particularly from the top quark and its supersymmetric partner, the "stop" squark. The authors used Renormalization Group (RG) methods to calculate these shifts.
  • Monte Carlo Simulations: Using tools like PYTHIA and HZHA, the researchers simulated signal events against the "noise" of background processes, such as $W^+W^-$ and $ZZ$ production.
  • Experimental Constraints: The simulations incorporated real-world performance metrics, such as b-tagging efficiency (identifying bottom quarks from Higgs decays) and the then-recent measurement of the top quark mass ($M_t \approx 175$ GeV).

Key Results and Discovery Limits

The report established rigorous thresholds for a "5-sigma discovery" and a "95% Confidence Level exclusion."

  • Standard Model Reach: At a center-of-mass energy of 192 GeV, LEP2 was projected to discover an SM Higgs boson with a mass up to 95 GeV.
  • Exclusion Limits: If no signal were found, the combined data could rule out an SM Higgs up to 98 GeV (at 192 GeV) or 112 GeV (at 205 GeV).
  • Invisible Decays: The authors explored "nightmare scenarios" where the Higgs decays into invisible particles (like neutralinos). They demonstrated that the Higgs could still be identified by observing the Z boson recoiling against missing energy.

Limitations and Historical Context

The authors acknowledged a "110 GeV wall"—a hard physical limit for LEP2. If the Higgs mass exceeded this threshold, the search would necessarily pass to the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). Furthermore, while the MSSM analysis was thorough, more exotic "Non-Minimal" models (like the NMSSM) could potentially hide a Higgs boson through more complex decay chains.

Historical Note: LEP2 eventually reached a maximum energy of 209 GeV. In its final year of operation (2000), it observed a tantalizing 2.3-sigma excess at 115 GeV. While this was insufficient to claim a discovery, it provided a crucial hint for the future. The Higgs boson was eventually discovered by the LHC in 2012 at a mass of 125 GeV—just slightly beyond the maximum reach predicted in this 1996 report.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this report we review the prospects for Higgs physics at LEP2. The theoretical aspects and the phenomenology of Higgs particles are discussed within the Standard Model (SM) and the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM). The experimental search techniques are described and the discovery limits for Higgs bosons in the LEP2 energy range are summarized. In addition, opportunities of detecting Higgs particles in non-minimal extensions of the SM and the MSSM are investigated.
BibTeX
@misc{carena1996higgs,
  author = {Marcela Carena and P. Ohmann and J.J. van der Bij and E. Gross and R. Keränen and Michel Rausch de Traubenberg and T. Riemann and S. Katsanevas and P. Janot and F.A. Berends and T. Binoth and G. Crosetti and T. Wlodek and A. Ballestrero and G. Wolf and D.Y. Bardin and Ronald Kleiss and A. Sopczak and J. Marco and C. De Saint Jean and R. Silvestre and M. Dubinin and O. J. P. Éboli and G. Mikenberg and E. Duchovni and Bernd A. Kniehl and A. Djouadi and R. Pittau and V. Driesen and F. Piccinini and S. W. Ham and J.-P. Ernenwein and Michael Spira and Michael Krämer and Tilman Plehn and P. Bambade and S. Hoorelbeke and C. Hajdu and H. Genten and R. Folman and D. Vilanova and P.M. Zerwas and E. Lund and W. Hollik and Ulrich Ellwanger and C. Mariotti and Ralf Hempfling and André H. Hoang and S. J. de Jong and J. R. Espinosa and S. Shichanin and R. Ehret and Elena Accomando and O. Nicrosini and R. Contri and J. Cuevas and Howard E. Haber and B. R. Kim and Shinji Yamashita and J. W. F. Valle and G. Burkart and M. Felcini and A. Dabelstein and C.A. Savoy and R. Faccini and Sam King and Wolfgang Kilian and G. Montagna and F. de Campos and F. Di Lodovico and M. R. Monge and Lund Lund and J. Kalinowski and M. Quirós and Fabio Zwirner and K. Hultqvist and Carlos E. M. Wagner and P. L. White and M. Shimojima and Janusz Rosiek and P. Bagnaia and A. Leike and P. Lutz and W. De Boer and U. Jost and S. K. Oh and Giampiero Passarino and J G Guy and Ruhlmann-Kleider and Wlodek, T. and Wolf, G. and Yamashita, S. and Zwirner, F.},
  title = {{Higgs Physics at LEP2}},
  year = {1996},
  eprint = {hep-ph/9602250},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/9602250},
}
Figure