Hierarchical Partitioning Forecaster

Christopher MatternarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

In machine learning, a persistent gap exists between deep learning models, which offer high predictive capacity but few theoretical guarantees, and online learning algorithms, which provide rigorous regret bounds but often lack the power to handle complex data. This paper introduces the Hierarchical Partitioning Forecaster (HPF), a framework that bridges this divide. By combining hierarchical space partitioning with local online learning, HPF achieves $O(\log T)$ regret guarantees while remaining competitive with state-of-the-art deep learning models in practical applications like precipitation nowcasting.

Introduction

The current landscape of machine learning research is often bifurcated. Experimental research focuses on increasing model capacity through deeper architectures and more parameters, yielding impressive results on complex datasets but offering little certainty regarding out-of-distribution behavior. Conversely, theoretical research prioritizes "regret guarantees"—mathematical bounds ensuring a model's cumulative loss is not significantly worse than the best fixed predictor in a class—but these models often struggle with the raw predictive demands of modern tasks.

The Hierarchical Partitioning Forecaster (HPF), proposed by Christopher Mattern, seeks to reconcile these two worlds. By exploiting structured, hierarchical specialization, the HPF provides a high-capacity model that is mathematically guaranteed to perform nearly as well as the optimal partition chosen in hindsight.

Methodology: The HPF Framework

The HPF operates on three core principles that distinguish it from traditional global optimization models like neural networks.

1. Hierarchical Space Partitioning

The algorithm divides the feature space into a tree-like structure of sub-spaces or segments. This recursive partitioning allows the model to specialize its predictions based on the specific region of the input space.

![A hierarchical partition of the interval 0, 1) represented as a tree structure. Source, p. 4

As shown in the figure above, the feature space (represented here as the interval [0, 1)) is subdivided into increasingly granular segments. Each node in this tree represents a specific sub-region where a local learner can operate.

2. Local Online Learning

Unlike deep learning models that rely on global backpropagation, each segment in the HPF hierarchy maintains its own "local" learner. These learners update independently using only the data points that fall within their specific sub-space. This localized approach allows for rapid, "on-the-fly" updates and avoids the computational overhead of global gradient descent.

3. Recursive Blending and Switching

To generate a final prediction, the HPF recursively combines the outputs of these specialized forecasters. It employs a "Switching" mechanism—an ensembling technique that dynamically decides whether to trust a broad, general forecaster at a higher level of the tree or a highly specialized one at a deeper level. This allows the model to adapt its complexity to the available data in real-time.

Theoretical Foundations

A key contribution of this work is the provision of individual-sequence regret guarantees, a feature notably absent in previous high-capacity models like Gated Linear Networks (GLNs). By structuring the partition as a tree, the authors apply techniques from Context Tree Weighting to bound the cumulative error.

The paper proves a logarithmic regret bound of $O(k \log T)$, where $T$ is the sequence length and $k$ represents the complexity of the best partition. This implies that the performance gap between the HPF and an "idealized" Constant Partitioning Forecaster (CPF)—an imaginary competitor that knows the perfect partition in hindsight—grows extremely slowly over time.

Empirical Evaluation: Precipitation Nowcasting

The authors tested the Linear HPF (LHPF) variant on the NIMROD dataset, a challenging real-world task involving radar-based precipitation measurements over the UK. The data consists of high-resolution grayscale video sequences (1536 x 1280 pixels).

The task was to predict rainfall at specific locations for horizons ranging from 5 to 60 minutes. LHPF was benchmarked against:

  • Persistence: A naive baseline.
  • PySTEPS: A simulation-based meteorological model.
  • Deep Learning: State-of-the-art GANs and UNets.

Key Results

  • Performance: For short-term horizons (up to 20 minutes), LHPF performed comparably to GANs and UNets in terms of Mean Squared Error (MSE).
  • Efficiency: LHPF utilizes orders of magnitude fewer parameters than its deep learning counterparts and executes significantly faster due to its local update rule.
  • Theoretical Validation: The empirical results supported the predicted logarithmic regret, demonstrating the model's stability over long sequences.

Discussion and Limitations

While the HPF shows great promise, it faces challenges common to MSE-optimized models, such as "blurry" predictions that can lower scores on spatial accuracy metrics like the Critical Success Index (CSI). Additionally, performance tends to degrade faster than deep learning models for horizons beyond 20 minutes, suggesting that linear base learners may be too simple to capture long-term atmospheric dynamics.

Conclusion

The Hierarchical Partitioning Forecaster represents a significant step toward unifying theoretical rigor with practical performance. By replacing global backpropagation with structured hierarchical learning, it offers a path toward high-capacity models that are both efficient and mathematically sound. Future research will focus on incorporating more complex local learners and exploring "shifting regret" to adapt to non-stationary environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this work we consider a new family of algorithms for sequential prediction, Hierarchical Partitioning Forecasters (HPFs). Our goal is to provide appealing theoretical - regret guarantees on a powerful model class - and practical - empirical performance comparable to deep networks - properties at the same time. We built upon three principles: hierarchically partitioning the feature space into sub-spaces, blending forecasters specialized to each sub-space and learning HPFs via local online learning applied to these individual forecasters. Following these principles allows us to obtain regret guarantees, where Constant Partitioning Forecasters (CPFs) serve as competitor. A CPF partitions the feature space into sub-spaces and predicts with a fixed forecaster per sub-space. Fixing a hierarchical partition $\mathcal H$ and considering any CPF with a partition that can be constructed using elements of $\mathcal H$ we provide two guarantees: first, a generic one that unveils how local online learning determines regret of learning the entire HPF online; second, a concrete instance that considers HPF with linear forecasters (LHPF) and exp-concave losses where we obtain $O(k \log T)$ regret for sequences of length $T$ where $k$ is a measure of complexity for the competing CPF. Finally, we provide experiments that compare LHPF to various baselines, including state of the art deep learning models, in precipitation nowcasting. Our results indicate that LHPF is competitive in various settings.
BibTeX
@misc{mattern2023hierarchical,
  author = {Christopher Mattern},
  title = {{Hierarchical Partitioning Forecaster}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2305.13063},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13063},
}
Figure