Hierarchical Optimization of Landing Performance for Lander with Adaptive Landing Gear

Ding Zongmao, Hongyu Wu, Chunjie Wang, Jianzhong DingChinese 2019 · DOI

Abstract

A parameterized dynamics analysis model of legged lander with adaptive landing gear was established. Based on the analysis model, the landing performances under various landing conditions were analyzed by the optimized Latin hypercube experimental design method. In order to improve the landing performances, a hierarchical optimization method was proposed considering the uncertainty of landing conditions. The optimization problem was divided into a higher level (the “leader”) and several lower levels (the “follower”). The followers took conditioning factors as design variables to find out the worst landing conditions, while the leader took buffer parameters as design variables to better the landing performance under worst conditions. Response surface models were established to reflect the complicated relationships between sensitive conditioning factors, buffer parameters, and landing performance indexes. After selecting the optimum buffer parameters, the dynamic model was simulated again. Results show that nozzle performance against damage improved by 5.24%, acceleration overload was reduced by 5.74%, and the primary strut performance improved by 21.10%.

Introduction

Landing a spacecraft on extraterrestrial terrain is a high-stakes balancing act. Traditional "passive" landing gears utilize one-time-use materials like aluminum honeycomb to absorb energy. While reliable, these systems are static—they cannot adjust to specific terrain or impact velocities, forcing engineers to over-design them with massive safety margins, which adds unnecessary weight.

Adaptive landing gears, particularly those using magnetorheological (MR) dampers that change fluid viscosity in response to magnetic fields, offer a promising solution. However, they introduce the challenge of uncertainty. Optimizing damper settings is difficult when the "worst-case" landing scenario (slope, friction, velocity) changes every time a design parameter is tweaked. Most existing research optimizes for a single "typical" condition, which can lead to instability if the actual landing environment differs even slightly. This paper proposes a hierarchical "leader-follower" optimization framework to enhance the performance of spacecraft landing gear equipped with adaptive MR dampers.

Methods and Modeling

The researchers developed a two-stage Hierarchical Optimization method to tackle environmental uncertainty. They first built a parameterized model of a four-legged lander in ADAMS. In this configuration, the primary struts utilize MR dampers with a "jump control" strategy, while the secondary struts employ traditional honeycomb materials.

Figure 1: Configuration of the lander model used for dynamic analysis.

The optimization framework is structured as follows:

  • Followers (The Environment): These sub-problems take a set of buffer parameters and identify the worst possible landing conditions (e.g., specific combinations of impact angle, slope, and friction) that minimize performance.
  • Leader (The Design): This higher-level optimization takes the worst-case scenarios found by the followers and adjusts the buffer parameters (stiffness, damping limits) to improve the lander's overall performance.

To ensure computational efficiency, the authors used Response Surface Models (RSM). Running thousands of full dynamic simulations is prohibitively slow; RSMs act as mathematical shortcuts that approximate the complex relationships between landing factors and performance indexes, allowing for rapid iteration. The study utilized Optimized Latin Hypercube Sampling to select 36 initial landing conditions for sensitivity analysis and 44 sample points to train the RSMs, achieving high fitting accuracy ($R^2 > 0.97$).

Key Insights and Results

A critical insight from this study is that the "worst condition" is a moving target. As the landing gear's stiffness is optimized, the specific slope or velocity that poses the greatest risk of failure changes. The hierarchical approach ensures the design remains robust against this shifting worst-case scenario.

Figure 2: Main structures of the lander, including the nozzle and strut components targeted for optimization.

Sensitivity mapping through Pareto diagrams revealed that vertical velocity ($v_x$) has a massive impact on nozzle safety and acceleration but surprisingly little influence on the "stability distance" (the risk of tipping over). This allowed for a simplified stability model. The multi-objective optimization also highlighted the classic engineering trade-off: reducing G-force on instruments often requires a longer buffer stroke, which can increase weight.

The hierarchical optimization yielded a set of optimum buffer parameters that significantly outperformed the initial design across the test conditions:

  • Nozzle Safety: The minimum distance between the engine nozzle and the ground improved by 5.24%.
  • G-Load Reduction: Maximum acceleration overload was reduced by 5.74%, protecting sensitive onboard electronics.
  • Buffer Efficiency: The performance of the primary strut improved by 21.10%.
  • Stability: All optimized configurations maintained a positive stability distance, ensuring the lander would not tip over even in harsh conditions.

Conclusion

While the hierarchical framework proves effective in simulation, several areas remain for future research. The current model simplifies MR fluid dynamics and assumes near-instantaneous feedback for the "jump control" strategy. Future work will focus on validating these adaptive strategies with physical prototypes in vacuum or low-gravity test environments to account for real-world control latency and fluid response times.

Summary updated

Abstract

A parameterized dynamics analysis model of legged lander with adaptive landing gear was established. Based on the analysis model, the landing performances under various landing conditions were analyzed by the optimized Latin hypercube experimental design method. In order to improve the landing performances, a hierarchical optimization method was proposed considering the uncertainty of landing conditions. The optimization problem was divided into a higher level (hereafter the “leader”) and several lower levels (hereafter the “follower”). The followers took conditioning factors as design variables to find out the worst landing conditions, while the leader took buffer parameters as design variables to better the landing performance under worst conditions. First of all, sensitivity analysis of landing conditioning factors was carried out according to the results of experimental design. After the sensitive factors were screened out, the response surface models were established to reflect the complicated relationships between sensitive conditioning factors, buffer parameters and landing performance indexes. Finally, the response surface model was used for hierarchical optimization iteration to improve the computational efficiency. After selecting the optimum buffer parameters from the solution set, the dynamic model with the optimum parameters was simulated again under the same landing conditions as the simulation before. After optimization, nozzle performance against damage is improved by 5.24%, the acceleration overload is reduced by 5.74%, and the primary strut improves its performance by 21.10%.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zongmao2019hierarchical,
  author = {Ding Zongmao and Hongyu Wu and Chunjie Wang and Jianzhong Ding},
  title = {{Hierarchical Optimization of Landing Performance for Lander with Adaptive Landing Gear}},
  booktitle = {Chinese},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1186/s10033-019-0331-0},
}
Figure