Hierarchical ground-state crystals underlying Hertzian quasicrystals

Yao Li, Yiwei Wang, Yi Geng, Wenyu Liu, Fangfu Ye, Jeff Z. Y. ChenNature Communications 2025 · DOI

Abstract: As a simple physics model for crystal and quasicrystal formation, the Hertzian potential describes the interaction between two soft-core colloidal particles. However, explaining why quasicrystals emerge in such a minimal model remains a theoretical challenge. Here, using analytically exact approaches, we reveal multiple layers of hierarchical crystal patterns that serve as the energy ground states underlying quasicrystals found by computer simulations. Our findings offer a new perspective on quasicrystal formation.

Introduction: The Mystery of Soft-Core Complexity

In condensed matter physics, the Hertzian potential serves as a minimalist model for describing the interactions between soft, deformable particles, such as certain colloids or polymers. Despite the simplicity of the interaction, this model is known to produce remarkably complex structures, most notably dodecagonal quasicrystals (DDQC). These materials exhibit long-range order and 12-fold rotational symmetry but lack the translational periodicity characteristic of standard crystals.

For years, the emergence of such complex, non-repeating structures from a simple potential was a theoretical puzzle. While computer simulations frequently identified quasicrystals as the stable state at specific densities, it remained unclear whether these were true ground states at absolute zero ($T = 0$) or if a more stable, hidden crystalline order existed. This research addresses this fundamental question by investigating the energetic stability of hierarchical crystal patterns.

Methodology

To move beyond the limitations of standard simulations, the researchers employed a multi-pronged approach combining analytical theory with computational validation:

  1. Analytically Exact Energy Calculations: The team calculated the exact potential energy of various candidate crystal structures. They focused on hierarchical tilings—complex patterns constructed from simpler geometric units like pentagons, triangles, and hexagons.
  2. Molecular Dynamics (MD) and Simulated Annealing: Using the LAMMPS package, the researchers simulated thousands of particles. By slowly "cooling" the system through simulated annealing, they observed which structures the system naturally settled into as thermal fluctuations were minimized.
  3. Symmetry and Pattern Analysis: The team performed a comprehensive symmetry analysis, comparing the diffraction patterns of the observed quasicrystals with those of the newly discovered hierarchical crystals to establish mathematical links between them.
Symmetry and lattice properties of basic reference tilings used as building blocks for more complex structures.

Discovery of Hierarchical Ground States

The study identifies five new crystalline phases that are energetically preferred over the quasicrystal state at absolute zero: Cairo, Chengtu, PenHex-Str, Agra, and PenTri-Rec. These are not simple periodic grids but are hierarchical in nature. For instance, the "Agra" lattice is a complex superposition of "Cairo" and "PenHex-Str" units. Interestingly, several of these patterns mirror historical architectural tilings found in Cairo, Egypt; Chengtu, China; and Agra, India.

Structural properties and symmetries of the discovered hierarchical tilings compared to the dodecagonal quasicrystal (DDQC).

Analytical calculations demonstrated that these five pentagon-based crystals possess lower system energy than the previously proposed DDQC state at $T=0$. This finding necessitated a revision of the Hertzian phase diagram, filling regions previously attributed to quasicrystals with these newly discovered crystalline phases.

A key insight of the paper is the concept of the "entropy trap." While quasicrystals appear stable in simulations at low but non-zero temperatures, they are actually entropy-stabilized. The inherent disorder within the quasicrystal provides a higher entropy that makes it appear as the preferred state. However, as $T \to 0$, the system's drive to minimize energy forces it toward one of the hierarchical crystals.

Furthermore, the researchers uncovered a profound mathematical connection: the 12-fold rotational symmetry of the DDQC is the least common multiple of the symmetries of the underlying hierarchical crystals (which exhibit 2, 3, and 4-fold symmetries). This suggests that the quasicrystal is a high-temperature manifestation of these competing crystalline ground states.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

This work redefines our understanding of the Hertzian model's ground state, showing that what appeared to be a quasicrystal is actually underpinned by a series of complex hierarchical crystals. Future research will explore whether this phenomenon is universal across other soft-core potentials, such as the Gaussian core model. Additionally, the discovery opens the door for the intentional synthesis of these architectural tilings in the lab using tunable soft-matter systems like DNA-coated colloids. Understanding the kinetics of how systems navigate these complex energy landscapes remains a vital next step in the study of self-assembling materials.

Summary updated

Abstract

As a simple physics model for crystal and quasicrystal formation, the Hertzian potential describes the interaction between two soft-core colloidal particles. However, explaining why quasicrystals emerge in such a minimal model remains a theoretical challenge. Here, using analytically exact approaches, we reveal multiple layers of hierarchical crystal patterns that serve as the energy ground states underlying quasicrystals found by computer simulations. Our findings offer a new perspective on quasicrystal formation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2025hierarchical,
  author = {Yao Li and Yiwei Wang and Yi Geng and Wenyu Liu and Fangfu Ye and Jeff Z. Y. Chen},
  title = {{Hierarchical ground-state crystals underlying Hertzian quasicrystals}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-025-66158-0},
}
Figure