Hierarchical control strategy for planar bipedal walking robots based on reduced order model

Minh Nhat VuarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Author: Vu Nhat Minh (KIST/UST)

Abstract

Controlling humanoid robots involves managing high-dimensional degrees of freedom (DoFs), which often leads to significant computational overhead. This research proposes a hierarchical control strategy that utilizes a simplified "template" model—the Bipedal Trunk Spring-Loaded Inverted Pendulum (BTSLIP)—to guide complex, multi-link robots. By introducing a novel Force Direction Controller (FDC), the study demonstrates that robots can maintain stable upright postures and navigate rough terrain or external disturbances more reliably than previous state-of-the-art methods like the Virtual Pivot Point (VPP).

Introduction

Humanoid locomotion is a complex challenge due to the high number of actuators and the inherent instability of bipedal structures. To simplify this, researchers often employ "reduced-order models"—physics-based skeletons that capture essential dynamics without the computational cost of full-body modeling.

A common approach is the Virtual Pivot Point (VPP) method, which redirects ground reaction forces (GRF) toward a point above the robot's center of mass to maintain balance. However, this research identifies a critical limitation: in specific body configurations, the VPP method can generate an "upsetting moment" that destabilizes the robot. This paper seeks to address these vulnerabilities through a more robust, hierarchical control architecture.

Methodology

The proposed control strategy is divided into two distinct layers:

Layer 1: The Planner (BTSLIP Model)

The high-level planner uses the Bipedal Trunk Spring-Loaded Inverted Pendulum (BTSLIP) model, which treats the robot's legs as virtual springs and the body as a rigid mass with a trunk.

The core innovation here is the Force Direction Controller (FDC). Unlike the static target of the VPP, the FDC uses a PD-like control law to dynamically adjust the angle of the GRF based on the trunk's instantaneous pitch and velocity. This ensures that the force always provides a "righting moment," effectively keeping the torso vertical regardless of the robot's configuration.

Layer 2: The Executor

This layer translates abstract forces from the BTSLIP model into specific joint torques for articulated robots:

  • 5-Link Model: Utilizes Operational Space Control (OSC) and Jacobian Transpose methods to map desired foot forces to joint movements.
  • 7-Link Model: Incorporates ankles and flat feet, managed by a Finite State Machine (FSM) to handle transitions such as heel-strike and ankle push-off.

Simulation and Results

The framework was validated using high-fidelity physics simulations in MATLAB and the Open Dynamics Engine (ODE). Key findings include:

  • Disturbance Rejection: The controller successfully recovered from external force impulses of up to 300N, demonstrating superior stability compared to traditional methods.
  • Blind Terrain Adaptation: The 7-link robot successfully traversed rough terrain with height variations up to 5cm (approximately 20% of leg length) without prior knowledge of the ground geometry.
  • Emergent Dynamics: The robot's walking speed stabilized naturally through the interaction of springy leg dynamics and the Velocity-Based Leg Adjustment (VBLA) algorithm. Furthermore, the system naturally produced the "double-peak" GRF pattern characteristic of human gait.
  • Computational Efficiency: The FDC achieved stability comparable to complex optimization-based methods (like DLQR) but with significantly lower overhead, making it ideal for real-time hardware applications.

Conclusion and Future Work

This hierarchical approach provides a computationally efficient and robust solution for planar bipedal walking. By focusing on the direction of ground reaction forces rather than a fixed virtual point, the system achieves high levels of adaptability to unknown terrain.

Future research will focus on extending this state-based control to 3D humanoid models to address lateral balance and implementing the strategy on physical hardware to account for real-world sensor noise and motor limitations.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this work, the hierarchical control strategy of template-based control for a bipedal robot is described. The axial force of a compliant leg is redirected to a point, called the virtual pivot point (VPP), of a 2D biped robot, which is located above the CoM of the model, to generate a restoring moment for the trunk motion. The resulting behavior of the model would resemble a virtual pendulum rotating around this VPP, thus aiming for an upright trunk during walking. Inspired by this analysis, we propose a new force redirecting method as a controller for robot walking. Then, these key features of the BTSLIP model with a simple force direction controller are mapped into the overall input torques of an articulated body robot via a task space controller. We consider a full dynamic simulation of a 2D articulated body robot to validate the performance of the proposed method under the random initial conditions and the presence of force disturbances and moderately rough surfaces. Moreover, with our control strategy, the robot achieves a stable walking motion while keeping its upper body upright without using optimization methods. We hypothesize by taking the advantage of the properties of mechanical templates, also called the reduced-order model, this could enable stable gait for the full model robot without the need for precise path planning.
BibTeX
@misc{vu2023hierarchical,
  author = {Minh Nhat Vu},
  title = {{Hierarchical control strategy for planar bipedal walking robots based on reduced order model}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2303.12180},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2303.12180},
}
Figure