Heveas problem: The Fountain

Adnan Balci, Maria Bruna, Chris Budd, Dongdo He, Poul G. Hjorth, Grzegorz Krzyżanowski, Krystian Kubala, Christian Lund, Berit Martensen, Gitte Schmidt, Monika Sikora, Damian SmugMunich 2013

Abstract: This report is the result of work conducted during the 94th European Study Group with Industry in Sønderborg. It investigates the fluid dynamics of a compact, 3D-printed device designed to convert a standard turbulent faucet stream into a smooth, laminar drinking fountain jet.

Introduction

The Danish company Heveas ApS proposed a design challenge: creating a centimeter-scale device that, when held under a vertical water faucet, generates a smaller, upward-pointing jet suitable for drinking. While the concept is straightforward, the physics of converting high-velocity, turbulent tap water into a stable, "glass-like" laminar stream without excessive splashing is complex. This paper evaluates two primary modeling approaches—kinematic redirection and pressure-driven reservoirs—to determine the optimal geometry for such a device.

Modeling and Design Approaches

The research team, comprising mathematicians and engineers, explored two distinct theoretical frameworks to understand the device's behavior:

Kinematic Redirection Model

This model treats the device as a curved pipe that redirects the water's momentum. It focuses on using internal geometry, such as baffles or surface roughness, to increase the "wetted perimeter." By reducing the hydraulic diameter, the model aims to lower the Reynolds number and encourage laminar flow. However, this approach proves sensitive; if the pipe fills completely, it loses its free-surface advantages and efficiency drops.

Pressure-Driven Reservoir Model

Alternatively, the "pressure model" assumes the incoming jet hits a reservoir, creating stagnation pressure ($P_{jet} = \frac{1}{2}\rho v_{jet}^2$). This internal pressure then drives the fountain through a small exit hole. This model proved significantly more robust in simulations, as the pressurized chamber naturally stabilizes the output jet regardless of minor fluctuations in input positioning.

Cross-sectional view of the device geometry illustrating the three functional zones: Entry, Transition, and Acceleration.

Laminarization via Geometry

To achieve a drinkable stream, the device must suppress turbulence without losing the energy required for fountain height. The study suggests that reducing the hydraulic diameter is the most effective method. By adding internal baffles (fins) or increasing surface roughness, the device introduces enough friction to kill turbulence while maintaining sufficient velocity.

Proposed internal cross-sections featuring baffles (left) and surface roughness (right) to reduce hydraulic diameter and promote laminar flow.

Simulations and Prototyping

The team utilized COMSOL Multiphysics for 2D and 3D steady-state analysis of the pressure model. Parameters such as inlet/outlet angles and hole sizes were varied to find the "Goldilocks" zone. Prototyping was handled via MATLAB-generated STL files, which were then 3D-printed using ABS plastic.

Experimental observations and simulations identified an optimal exit hole radius ($r_2$) of approximately 1mm. If the hole is too small, viscosity and surface tension choke the flow; if too large, internal pressure drops, resulting in a turbulent, low-height jet.

Key Results

  • Fountain Height: The pressure model successfully predicted and achieved stable jets approximately 10cm high, which is ideal for user comfort.
  • Velocity: An exit velocity of roughly 1.4 m/s was identified as the target for a clean, non-splashing stream.
  • Robustness: The height of the fountain was found to be relatively insensitive to small changes in hole size once within the optimal range, confirming the stability of the pressure-driven design.

Conclusion and Future Work

The pressure-driven reservoir model offers a superior foundation for a robust drinking fountain device. While the current designs successfully laminarize the jet, "entry splash" remains a challenge. Because the device receives more water than it can output, excess water must escape the entry point. Future iterations will focus on sharpening entry walls to mitigate splashing and refining the exterior ergonomics for better user handling. Additionally, accounting for air entrainment (bubbles) in the initial faucet stream could further improve the accuracy of the computational models.

Summary updated

Abstract

Report is the result of the working during 94th European Study Group with Industry in Sonderborg.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{balci2013heveas,
  author = {Adnan Balci and Maria Bruna and Chris Budd and Dongdo He and Poul G. Hjorth and Grzegorz Krzyżanowski and Krystian Kubala and Christian Lund and Berit Martensen and Gitte Schmidt and Monika Sikora and Damian Smug},
  title = {{Heveas problem: The Fountain}},
  booktitle = {Munich},
  year = {2013},
}
Figure