Heuristic Online Goal Recognition in Continuous Domains

Mor Vered, Gal A. KaminkaIJCAI 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of inferring an agent's goal in real-time within continuous environments, like robot navigation. They introduce a novel heuristic-driven algorithm that significantly speeds up goal recognition by intelligently deciding when to re-plan and when to prune unlikely goals, outperforming previous methods in both efficiency and accuracy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Goal recognition, the task of figuring out what an agent wants to achieve based on its actions, is crucial for intelligent systems to cooperate and predict behavior. Traditional methods often rely on pre-computed libraries of plans, which are inflexible and don't scale well to complex, continuous environments like 3D spaces where robots move. A more recent approach, "Plan Recognition by Planning" (PRP), avoids these libraries by using off-the-shelf planners to generate potential plans on the fly. However, the original PRP formulation is computationally expensive for online (real-time) recognition and struggles with continuous domains. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing an efficient, online goal recognition algorithm specifically for continuous spaces, improving upon existing PRP methods.

Methods

The core of the paper is a new online goal recognition algorithm that builds upon the PRP framework but introduces two key heuristic decision points to improve efficiency:

  • RECOMPUTE: This heuristic intelligently decides whether a new observation necessitates recomputing a plan for a goal. Instead of re-planning for every observation, it uses a heuristic to estimate if the new observation significantly alters the likelihood of the current top-ranked goal. This avoids unnecessary computationally expensive planning calls.
  • PRUNE: This heuristic allows the algorithm to eliminate unlikely goal candidates from consideration. Inspired by human cognitive biases, it identifies goals whose associated plans are deviating significantly from the observed trajectory, effectively reducing the search space and subsequent planning load.

The algorithm is designed to work with existing continuous-space planners without modification. It formulates the problem by comparing the cost of an "ideal plan" (from start to goal) with the cost of a plan that incorporates the observed actions. The new algorithm aims to minimize the number of planner calls by strategically applying the RECOMPUTE and PRUNE heuristics.

Datasets

The paper evaluates its approach on two main scenarios:

  • 3D Navigational Environment: This involves a standard motion planning benchmark using the TRRT planner within a simulated 3D environment. The experiments involved generating hundreds of goal recognition problems by creating observed paths between various points.
  • Simulated ROS-enabled Robots: The algorithm was also implemented and tested in a simulated cooperative robotic soccer task using ROS and the move_base planner. This scenario demonstrates the practical applicability of the approach in a multi-agent robotics context.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Heuristics are Key for Efficiency: The most significant insight is that intelligent heuristics for deciding when to re-plan and which goals to consider are crucial for making online goal recognition practical in continuous domains. Simply re-planning for every observation is too slow.
  • Pruning is Powerful but Risky: The PRUNE heuristic offers substantial efficiency gains by reducing the number of goals to consider. However, the authors acknowledge that an incorrect pruning decision can lead to unsoundness (failing to find the correct goal).
  • Balancing Efficiency and Accuracy: The paper demonstrates a trade-off. The "No Recompute" approach is extremely fast but has very low accuracy. Conversely, the full "Baseline" approach is more accurate but much slower. The proposed heuristics strike a balance, significantly improving both efficiency and accuracy.
  • Continuous Domains Present Unique Challenges: The paper highlights that adapting PRP to continuous spaces requires different approaches than discrete domains, particularly in how observations and plans are integrated.

Key Results

  • Significant Speedup: The combined PRUNE and RECOMPUTE heuristics reduced planner calls by 63.3% and run-time by 65.25% compared to the baseline approach in scattered goal scenarios.
  • Improved Accuracy: Convergence to the correct hypothesis increased by over 20% when using the heuristics, and the percentage of times the correct goal was ranked first also saw a substantial improvement.
  • Robustness to Clustered Goals: While clustered goals made pruning less effective, the heuristic approach still outperformed the baseline, though the efficiency gains were less pronounced.
  • Robotics Application: In the simulated robot soccer task, the goal recognition approach significantly improved performance compared to a "zero knowledge" approach, while being more adaptable than a "full knowledge" approach.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Pruning Risk: The paper acknowledges that the PRUNE heuristic, while effective, carries a risk of permanently eliminating the correct goal if the heuristic is too aggressive or the agent's behavior is unexpected.
  • Heuristic Design: The effectiveness of the algorithm relies heavily on the quality of the RECOMPUTE and PRUNE heuristics. Designing optimal heuristics for various domains remains an area for further research.
  • Human-like Rationality: The PRUNE heuristic is inspired by human biases. Future work could explore more sophisticated models of agent rationality and how they influence goal recognition.
  • Domain-Specific Heuristics: While the paper proposes general heuristics, tailoring them to specific domain characteristics could yield even better performance.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{vered2017heuristic,
  author = {Mor Vered and Gal A. Kaminka},
  title = {{Heuristic Online Goal Recognition in Continuous Domains}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.24963/ijcai.2017/621},
}
Figure