Heterogeneous Impact of the Minimum Wage: Implications for Changes in Between- and Within-Group Inequality

Tatsushi Oka, Ken YamadaSSRN 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how changes in the real value of the minimum wage have impacted wage inequality in the US, specifically looking at differences between groups (e.g., by education, gender) and within groups (e.g., among workers with similar education). Using advanced quantile regression techniques, the authors find that minimum wage changes have significantly altered wage structures, contributing to observed patterns of both between- and within-group inequality.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The impact of minimum wage policies on wage inequality is a long-standing debate. While intended to lift the wages of low-paid workers, concerns exist about unintended consequences. Previous research has often focused on the average effects or specific discontinuities in the wage distribution. However, a crucial gap remained in understanding how minimum wage changes affect the entire wage structure and contribute to the widening or narrowing of wage gaps between different demographic groups (education, experience, gender) and within these groups. This paper aims to quantify the role of the minimum wage in explaining observed trends in both between- and within-group wage inequality in the US over several decades.

Methods

The authors employ a sophisticated econometric framework based on quantile regression. This approach is key because it allows them to analyze the impact of the minimum wage not just on the average wage (mean), but on different points of the wage distribution (quantiles). This is crucial for understanding heterogeneous effects.

Key methodological contributions include:

  • Panel Quantile Regression: They model the log of real hourly wages as a function of observed characteristics (education, experience, gender) and the minimum wage, allowing coefficients to vary across quantiles and over time/states.
  • Censored Quantile Regression: To address issues of left-censoring (wages at or below the minimum wage) and right-censoring (top-coded wages in the data), they adopt a semiparametric approach that doesn't require strong distributional assumptions.
  • Quantile Imputation: For missing wage data, they use a censored quantile regression model to impute wages, accounting for potential selection bias.
  • Decomposition of Inequality: They develop a framework to measure the contribution of the minimum wage to changes in both between-group inequality (e.g., wage gap between college and high school graduates) and within-group inequality (e.g., wage gap between the 90th and 10th percentile of wages for a specific group).

Datasets

The study uses repeated cross-sectional data from the Current Population Survey (CPS) Merged Outgoing Rotation Group for the period 1979-2012. This is a standard and widely used dataset for labor market analysis in the US. The authors construct variables and restrict their sample in a manner consistent with previous influential studies (e.g., Autor et al., 2016) to ensure comparability.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Minimum Wage Reshapes the Entire Wage Structure: The impact of the minimum wage isn't confined to the very bottom of the wage distribution. It significantly affects the relationship between wages and observable characteristics like education, experience, and gender across various quantiles.
  • Heterogeneity is Key: The effect of the minimum wage is not uniform. It disproportionately impacts lower-skilled workers (lower quantiles of the wage distribution) and its influence wanes for higher-skilled workers.
  • Minimum Wage as a Driver of Inequality Trends: The study provides quantitative evidence that changes in the real minimum wage play a significant role in explaining observed trends in both between-group (e.g., educational wage differentials) and within-group wage inequality, particularly for certain demographic groups and time periods.
  • Within-Group Inequality is Heavily Influenced: The authors find that the minimum wage accounts for a substantial portion of the changes in within-group wage differentials, especially for workers with less experience.

Key Results

  • Intercept and Slope Effects: An increase in the minimum wage leads to higher wages for the lowest-paid workers (intercept effect) but weakens the relationship between wages and education, experience, and gender (slope effects). This effect is strongest at the lowest quantiles and diminishes as you move up the wage distribution.
  • Between-Group Inequality:
    • Education: The minimum wage contributes to a reduction in educational wage differentials, particularly at lower quantiles. This effect is more pronounced for more-experienced and female workers.
  • Experience: Similar to education, the minimum wage reduces experience wage differentials, especially for less-educated and female workers.
  • Gender: The minimum wage contributes to a reduction in the gender wage differential, particularly at lower quantiles, and this effect is stronger for less-educated and less-experienced workers.
  • Within-Group Inequality: The minimum wage significantly contributes to reductions in within-group wage differentials (e.g., 90/10, 50/10, 50/20) for workers with lower levels of education and experience. This impact is more substantial for less-educated, less-experienced, and female workers.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Exogeneity Assumption: The study assumes the minimum wage is exogenous. While common in the literature, they acknowledge the possibility that changes in the minimum wage might be driven by unobserved state characteristics, which could bias results. Future work could explore this further.
  • Employment Effects: The paper acknowledges the debate on the employment effects of the minimum wage. While they control for potential bias by imputing wages of non-employed individuals, a deeper integration of employment effects could be a future direction.
  • Data Limitations: The use of CPS data, while standard, has inherent limitations (e.g., top-coding). The authors address these through their chosen methodologies.

The paper concludes that the minimum wage is a significant factor in understanding the dynamics of wage inequality in the US, necessitating its inclusion in economic models that interpret wage structure changes.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{oka2019heterogeneous,
  author = {Tatsushi Oka and Ken Yamada},
  title = {{Heterogeneous Impact of the Minimum Wage: Implications for Changes in Between- and Within-Group Inequality}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.2139/ssrn.3350843},
  howpublished = {SSRN},
}
Figure