Heterogeneity of Attitudes toward Robots in Healthcare among the Chinese Public: A Latent Profile Analysis

Xuanyi Bi, Yu Gao, Erhong Sun, Yan Yan, Yimin Zhou, Xuchun YeInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that Chinese public attitudes towards healthcare robots are not monolithic, identifying three distinct profiles: optimistic, neutral, and ambivalent. Notably, the ambivalent group, while wary of robot interaction and social influence, shows a positive inclination towards emotional engagement with robots, highlighting a crucial area for future design.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As global populations age and healthcare demands rise, robots are increasingly seen as a solution for both functional assistance and social support. However, the successful integration of these technologies hinges on user acceptance, which is heavily influenced by attitudes. Previous research has yielded conflicting findings on public sentiment towards robots, making it difficult to generalize. This paper addresses this ambiguity by investigating the heterogeneity of attitudes towards healthcare robots specifically within the Chinese public, aiming to identify distinct subgroups and understand their characteristics. This is crucial for tailoring robot design and deployment to meet diverse user needs and expectations.

Methods

The researchers employed Latent Profile Analysis (LPA), a person-centered statistical approach, to identify distinct subgroups (profiles) within their sample based on their responses to a questionnaire about attitudes towards robots. LPA allows for the categorization of individuals into clusters with similar response patterns, moving beyond simple averages. The study used the 14-item Negative Attitudes toward Robots Scale (NARS) to measure these attitudes across three domains: interaction, social influence, and emotional interaction. After identifying the optimal number of profiles (three in this case), multivariable regression analysis was used to examine how demographic characteristics predicted membership in these profiles.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset collected from 428 participants in Mainland China via an online survey. This dataset was specifically gathered for this research and is not a pre-existing benchmark.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Dichotomies: Public attitudes towards healthcare robots are not simply "for" or "against." The identification of three distinct profiles (optimistic, neutral, ambivalent) underscores this complexity.
  • The Ambivalent Paradox: The "ambivalent" profile is particularly interesting. These individuals express negative views on robot interaction and social influence but show a positive leaning towards emotional interactions with robots. This suggests a nuanced desire for robots that can provide companionship and emotional support, even if functional or social integration is a concern.
  • Social Influence is a Universal Concern: Across all identified profiles, participants reported negative attitudes towards the social influence of healthcare robots. This points to a widespread concern about the potential societal impacts of widespread robot adoption in healthcare.
  • Demographics Matter: Attitudes are not random. Age, education level, income, and prior experience with technology (computers, wearables) significantly predict which attitude profile an individual falls into.

Key Results

  • Three Profiles Identified:
    • Optimistic Attitudes Profile (36.9%): Lowest scores on the NARS, indicating the most positive attitudes.
  • Neutral Attitudes Profile (47.2%): Moderate scores across all NARS items, reflecting a neutral stance. This group was the largest.
  • Ambivalent Attitudes Profile (15.9%): Highest scores on interaction and social influence, but significantly lower scores on emotional interaction, indicating a complex mix of concerns and desires.
  • Demographic Predictors:
    • Neutral Profile: More likely to have lower monthly incomes, lower education levels, and less experience with robot-related news.
  • Ambivalent Profile: More likely to be younger, have lower education levels, and lack experience with wearable devices.
  • Negative Social Influence: All respondents showed negative attitudes towards the social influence of healthcare robots, with specific concerns around dependency and robots developing into "living beings."

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cross-Sectional Design: The study captured a snapshot of attitudes at one point in time. Attitudes can evolve with experience, and a longitudinal study (e.g., using Latent Transition Analysis) is needed to track these changes.
  • Online Survey Limitations: The reliance on an online survey may introduce sample bias, potentially excluding individuals without internet access or those less familiar with online platforms. Future research could use mixed methods (online and paper questionnaires) and larger, more diverse samples.
  • First Impression: The study surveyed initial impressions of robots. Future work should explore how actual interaction with robots influences these attitudes.
  • Generalizability: While valuable for the Chinese public, findings should be re-examined in other cultural contexts and with specific healthcare user groups (e.g., patients, caregivers) to enhance generalizability.
  • Implications for Design: The authors emphasize the need for user-centered design, actively involving end-users to understand their nuanced needs, particularly regarding emotional interaction and social influence, to create more acceptable healthcare robots.

Summary updated

Abstract

Attitudes are deemed critical psychological variables that can determine end users' acceptance and adoption of robots. This study explored the heterogeneity of the Chinese public's attitudes toward robots in healthcare and examined demographic characteristics associated with the derived profile membership. The data were collected from a sample of 428 Chinese who participated in an online survey. Latent profile analysis identified three distinct subgroups regarding attitudes toward robots-optimistic (36.9%), neutral (47.2%), and ambivalent (15.9%). Interestingly, although participants in the ambivalent attitude profile held more negative attitudes toward interaction with or social influence of healthcare robots, their attitudes tended to be positive when it came to emotional interactions with healthcare robots. All the respondents reported negative attitudes toward the social influence of healthcare robots. Multivariable regression analysis results showed that there were significant differences in age, education level, monthly income, experience with computers, experience with wearable devices, and whether to follow robot-related news or not. This study confirmed the heterogeneity of the Chinese public's attitudes toward robots in healthcare and highlighted the importance of emotional interaction with and social influence of healthcare robots, which might facilitate a better understanding of the needs and expectations of potential end users for robots in healthcare to make them more acceptable in different situations.
BibTeX
@article{bi2022heterogeneity,
  author = {Xuanyi Bi and Yu Gao and Erhong Sun and Yan Yan and Yimin Zhou and Xuchun Ye},
  title = {{Heterogeneity of Attitudes toward Robots in Healthcare among the Chinese Public: A Latent Profile Analysis}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph20010508},
}
Figure