Hepatotoxic metabolites in Polygoni Multiflori Radix— Comparative toxicology in mice

Shixiao Wang, Xiang Kong, Ning Chen, Pengwei Hu, Hamza Boucetta, Zhaoliang Hu, Xin Xu, Pei Zhang, Xiang Zhan, Ming Chang, Rui Cheng, Wei Wu, Min Song, Yuting Lu, Taijun HangFrontiers in Pharmacology 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the hepatotoxic components of Polygoni Multiflori Radix (PM), a traditional Chinese medicine known to cause liver injury, by comparing it to rhubarb, a similar herb that is not associated with hepatotoxicity. The research identifies a synergistic effect between TSG, EMG, and emodin as the primary drivers of PM-induced liver damage in mice, offering crucial insights for safer clinical use.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Polygoni Multiflori Radix (PM) is widely used in traditional medicine for various ailments, but it has been increasingly linked to acute liver injury. This hepatotoxicity is a significant concern, yet the specific active compounds responsible and their mechanisms remain unclear. Interestingly, rhubarb (Rhei radix et rhizoma), which shares similar anthraquinone compounds with PM, is not typically associated with liver toxicity. This discrepancy presents a critical question: what makes PM hepatotoxic while rhubarb is not, and what are the key components driving this difference? This paper aims to resolve this by conducting a comparative toxicological study, using rhubarb as a reference, to pinpoint the specific metabolites in PM that cause liver damage.

Methods

The researchers designed a sub-acute toxicity study in mice, administering various extracts and combinations of PM and rhubarb over 28 days. They used nine groups, including control, PM ethanol extract (PME), prepared PM ethanol extract (PMPE), rhubarb ethanol extract (RME), steamed rhubarb ethanol extract (RMPE), isolated TSG (a unique PM component), and combinations of PM/rhubarb extracts with TSG. Crucially, doses were standardized based on equivalent emodin and TSG levels to allow for direct comparison.

Key techniques employed included:

  • Histopathological Examination: Liver and kidney tissues were analyzed for signs of damage, inflammation, and cellular changes.
  • Biochemical Analysis: Serum and liver samples were assessed for various biomarkers of liver function (ALT, TBA, ALP, TP, ALB, GLB, CREA), oxidative stress (GSH, MDA, GST), and inflammation (TNF-α).
  • HPLC-MS/MS: This method was used to quantify the levels of seven key components (TSG, EMG, emodin, physcion, aloe-emodin, rhein, and chrysophanol) in mouse tissues, allowing for tissue distribution analysis.
  • Correlation Analysis: Pearson and canonical correlation analyses were used to investigate the relationships between component exposure, dose, and biochemical abnormalities.
  • In Vitro Cell Viability Assay (CCK-8): This was used to assess the direct toxicity of individual components (emodin, EMG, TSG) and their combinations on human liver cells (L02), including an orthogonal experimental design to study synergistic effects.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized commercially available reagents and materials for its experimental procedures.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Rhubarb as a Protective Reference: The study effectively uses rhubarb, a similar but non-hepatotoxic herb, as a benchmark to isolate the specific toxic components of PM. This comparative approach is a novel way to dissect complex herbal toxicity.
  • Synergistic Toxicity of TSG, EMG, and Emodin: The research strongly suggests that PM's hepatotoxicity isn't due to a single compound but rather the combined, synergistic effect of TSG, EMG, and emodin. This highlights the importance of considering multi-component interactions in herbal medicine.
  • EMG's Indirect Role: While emodin and TSG appear to be the primary culprits, EMG (emodin-8-O-β-D-glucoside) plays a crucial indirect role by enhancing emodin exposure in the liver, acting as a key factor in the toxic pathway.
  • Dose-Exposure Relationship is Complex: Even with equivalent emodin doses, different extracts showed varying exposure levels, indicating differences in bioavailability and metabolism. TSG's presence could influence emodin's hepatic exposure, sometimes decreasing it while increasing renal excretion.
  • In Vitro vs. In Vivo: Emodin is significantly more hepatotoxic in vitro than TSG and EMG. However, in vivo, the combination of TSG and EMG with emodin is what leads to observable liver lesions, underscoring the importance of considering the complex interplay of compounds within the biological system.

Key Results

  • PME, PMPE-TSG, and RME-TSG induced liver lesions and biochemical abnormalities. In contrast, PMPE, RME, RMPE, TSG, and RMPE-TSG showed fewer or no significant adverse effects.
  • Emodin is the most potent hepatotoxin in vitro, with an IC50 of 14.88 µg/mL, compared to TSG (248.5 µg/mL) and EMG (>100 µg/mL).
  • Combinations of emodin and TSG showed synergistic inhibitory effects on L02 cells. The Combination Index (CI) values were generally less than 0.9, indicating mild synergistic effects.
  • Tissue distribution revealed higher exposure of TSG and emodin in the liver and kidney for PM-related groups, correlating with observed toxicity.
  • Pearson correlation analysis showed positive correlations between hepatic emodin and TSG exposure and liver function abnormalities (e.g., ALT, TBA, GLB, TNF-α).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mouse Model: While informative, the study was conducted in mice, and direct translation to human responses requires further investigation.
  • Complex Interactions: The study focused on a few key components. The full spectrum of interactions among all compounds in PM and rhubarb remains to be elucidated.
  • Individual Variability: The paper mentions idiosyncratic hepatotoxicity, suggesting genetic factors play a role, which was not directly addressed in this study.

Future work could involve:

  • Investigating the specific metabolic pathways of TSG and EMG that lead to increased emodin exposure.
  • Exploring the role of other minor components in PM and rhubarb that might modulate toxicity.
  • Conducting clinical studies to validate these findings and establish safer dosage guidelines for PM.
  • Further research into the genetic factors contributing to individual susceptibility to PM-induced liver injury.

Summary updated

Abstract

<i>Polygoni Multiflori Radix</i> (PM) and <i>Rhei radix et rhizoma</i> (rhubarb) contain similar hepatocyte-toxic anthraquinones such as emodin (major free anthraquinone in PM), physcion and their glycosides. In clinical practice, PM hepatotoxicity has been widely reported, although rhubarb is not recognized as hepatotoxic. To clarify the substances basis (key components) of PM hepatotoxicity, based on the characteristic components' similarity within PM, rhubarb and their concocted forms, a comparative sub-acute toxicity study was designed in mice. Nine groups of mice with 28 days of oral administration of these herbal extracts or 2,3,5,4'-tetrahydroxystilbene-2-<i>O-β</i>-D-glucoside (TSG, major and unique characteristic component in PM)-herb combinations were set as follows: Group-1, control; Group-2, PM ethanol-extract (PME); Group-3, PM praeparata ethanol-extract (PMPE); Group-4, Rhubarb ethanol-extract (RME); Group-5, Steamed rhubarb ethanol-extract (RMPE); Group-6, TSG; Group-7, PMPE-TSG combination; Group-8, RME-TSG combination; Group-9, RMPE-TSG combination. Each experimental group received an equivalent emodin dose of 29 mg/kg except for the TSG group, and an equivalent TSG dose of 1,345 mg/kg except for the PMPE, RME and RMPE groups. The results showed that PME, PMPE-TSG and RME-TSG induced liver lesions and biochemical abnormalities of liver function compared with the control. In contrast, PMPE, RME, RMPE, TSG and RMPE-TSG caused no liver lesions and fewer biochemical abnormalities. Considering the related components, only the co-administration of high doses of TSG and emodin-8-<i>O-β</i>-D-glucoside (EMG, major anthraquinone glycoside in PM) in these groups could cause liver lesions. According to tissue distribution and correlation analysis, EMG dose was positively correlated with the high hepatic emodin and TSG exposure, and the hepatic emodin and TSG exposure were positively correlated with the biochemical abnormalities of liver function. Cell viability test <i>in vitro</i> showed emodin was more hepatotoxic than TSG and EMG, and mainly emodin and TSG of the three had synergistic hepatotoxic effects. Therefore, creatively using rhubarb as a reference, this study revealed that PM hepatotoxicity in mice mainly came from the integrative contribution of TSG, EMG and emodin.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2022hepatotoxic,
  author = {Shixiao Wang and Xiang Kong and Ning Chen and Pengwei Hu and Hamza Boucetta and Zhaoliang Hu and Xin Xu and Pei Zhang and Xiang Zhan and Ming Chang and Rui Cheng and Wei Wu and Min Song and Yuting Lu and Taijun Hang},
  title = {{Hepatotoxic metabolites in Polygoni Multiflori Radix— Comparative toxicology in mice}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Pharmacology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fphar.2022.1007284},
}
Figure