Heavy Metals Distribution and Source Identification in Contaminated Agricultural Soils: Isotopic and Multi-Model Analysis

Tingting Mu, Benyi Cao, Min Yang, Xinhong Gan, Lin Chen, Xiaohan Wang, Ming Li, Yuanyuan Lu, Jian XuAgronomy 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study tackles the challenge of pinpointing heavy metal sources in agricultural soils at a field scale, a critical step for effective remediation. By integrating multiple advanced analytical techniques, including isotopic analysis, the researchers successfully identified and quantified the contributions of various sources, particularly for mercury, to soil contamination.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Heavy metal contamination in agricultural soils is a growing concern due to its detrimental effects on crop safety, food security, and human health. While regional-scale studies have identified general sources of pollution, understanding these sources at a finer, field scale, especially in areas with mixed industrial and agricultural activities, remains a significant challenge. This lack of precise source identification hinders the development of targeted and effective pollution control and remediation strategies. The paper specifically addresses this gap by focusing on a field-scale investigation to accurately attribute heavy metal contamination to specific activities and origins.

Methods

The study employed a comprehensive, multi-pronged approach to identify heavy metal sources:

  • Statistical Receptor Models:
    • Pearson's Correlation Analysis (CA): Used to assess the linear relationships between different heavy metals and soil properties, providing initial clues about their co-occurrence and potential shared origins.
  • Principal Component Analysis (PCA): A dimensionality reduction technique used to group metals with similar behaviors and identify underlying factors contributing to their presence in the soil.
  • UNMIX and EPA PMF (Positive Matrix Factorization): These are advanced receptor models that mathematically decompose the observed elemental concentrations into a set of source profiles and their respective contributions. UNMIX was used for a broader range of metals, while PMF was specifically applied to analyze source contributions.
  • Soil Profile Analysis: Examining the vertical distribution of heavy metals within soil layers (0-100 cm) to infer whether contamination is primarily from surface deposition (anthropogenic) or deeper geological sources.
  • Mercury (Hg) Isotope Analysis: This is a key novel aspect. By analyzing the isotopic signatures (specifically mass-independent fractionation, MIF, like Δ¹⁹⁹Hg and Δ²⁰⁰Hg, and mass-dependent fractionation, MDF, like δ²⁰²Hg) of mercury in different soil fractions and depths, the researchers could distinguish between different mercury sources (e.g., atmospheric deposition, industrial emissions, natural sources) based on their unique isotopic fingerprints.

Datasets

The study utilized soil samples collected from an agricultural area in Zhejiang Province, China. This included:

  • 38 topsoil samples (0-20 cm depth): Collected using a systematic grid sampling approach to ensure representative coverage.
  • 7 soil profile samples: Collected from different depths (0-20 cm, 20-40 cm, 40-60 cm, 60-80 cm, and 80-100 cm) to analyze vertical distribution.
  • 2 sediment samples: Collected from irrigation channels at the entrance and exit of the study area to assess the role of irrigation water.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the study focused on analyzing existing soil samples from a specific field site.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hg is the Primary Culprit: Mercury emerged as the most significant contaminant, exhibiting exceptionally high concentrations, pollution indices, and ecological risk values. This highlights the urgent need for targeted mercury management.
  • Depth Matters for Source Clues: The decreasing concentration of Hg with soil depth strongly suggests an anthropogenic origin, likely from surface deposition. This contrasts with metals showing more uniform distribution, hinting at natural sources.
  • Isotopes Unravel Mercury's Story: Hg isotope analysis provided compelling evidence for exogenous Hg input, particularly in deeper soil layers, deviating from expected natural isotopic signatures. This technique was crucial for confirming the anthropogenic nature of Hg contamination.
  • Multiple Sources, Complex Interactions: The study revealed that heavy metal contamination in agricultural soils is not from a single source but a complex interplay of industrial activities (especially coal combustion), traffic emissions, and agricultural practices.
  • Receptor Models Complement Each Other: The UNMIX and PMF models, while yielding slightly different quantitative contributions, consistently pointed towards similar dominant sources, reinforcing the robustness of the findings.

Key Results

  • Average Topsoil Concentrations: Hg (2.07 mg kg⁻¹), Cd (0.13 mg kg⁻¹), As (8.56 mg kg⁻¹), Pb (42.3 mg kg⁻¹), Cr (81.1 mg kg⁻¹), Ni (37.3 mg kg⁻¹), Zn (105 mg kg⁻¹), and Cu (43.8 mg kg⁻¹).
  • Hg Enrichment: Hg concentrations were significantly higher (up to 20.8 times the background values) and showed the highest single pollution index (Pi = 9.00) and ecological risk index (Eri = 922).
  • Hg Source Contributions (UNMIX): Coal combustion (66.2%), agricultural activities (16.9%), parent material (9.81%), and industrial/traffic emissions (7.0%).
  • Hg Source Contributions (PMF): Mixed industrial sources (71.4%), traffic emissions (27.8%), and parent material (0.8%).
  • Soil Profile Trends: Hg, Pb, Cd, Zn, and Cu concentrations generally decreased with depth, indicating surface contamination.
  • Isotopic Evidence: Negative Δ¹⁹⁹Hg values in residual Hg and deeper soil profiles suggested exogenous Hg input.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Field Scale Focus: While the study successfully identified sources at a field scale, the findings might not be directly generalizable to larger regional scales without further investigation.
  • Model Uncertainties: The authors acknowledge that receptor models have inherent uncertainties, and the quantitative contributions from different sources should be interpreted with this in mind.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that safe utilization strategies and eco-friendly stabilization methods should be implemented in agricultural soils to ensure food security. Further research could focus on developing and testing these specific remediation techniques based on the identified sources. Additionally, exploring the speciation of heavy metals and their bioavailability could provide a more nuanced understanding of ecological and health risks.

Summary updated

Abstract

Heavy metal pollution in agricultural soil has been tightly associated with anthropogenic emissions. Although there are many studies that focus on a regional scale, the source identification of heavy metal contamination on a field scale around industrial areas remains unclear. The average concentrations in topsoils of Hg, Cd, As, Pb, Cr, Ni, Zn, and Cu were 2.07, 0.13, 8.56, 42.3, 81.1, 37.3, 105, and 43.8 mg kg−1, respectively. The enrichment of Hg was particularly presented on topsoils, with the highest single pollution index (Pi) (9.00) and ecological risk index (Eri) (922) values. An integrated methodology was employed in source identification of heavy metals contamination, especially for Hg, including Pearson’s and PCA analysis, soil profile morphology, mathematical modeling, and Hg isotope analysis. Results revealed that the concentrations of Hg decreased as a function of depth, suggesting Hg contamination was an anthropogenic source and can be supported by Hg isotope analysis. The negative Δ199Hg values of the residual Hg (F4-Hg) and soil profile in 80–100 cm deviate from those of the soil profiles in 0–80 cm, indicating exogenous input of Hg occurred in the study area. According to the UNMIX model, the contribution of coal combustion, agricultural activities, parent material, and industrial/traffic emissions to Hg accumulation in soils were 66.2%, 16.9%, 9.81%, and 7.0%, respectively. However, the contribution rates calculated with the PMF model of mixed industrial source, traffic emissions, and parent material were 71.4%, 27.8%, and 0.8%, respectively. This study can accurately quantify and identify the factors contributing to heavy metal contamination in agricultural soil on a field scale.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mu2025heavy,
  author = {Tingting Mu and Benyi Cao and Min Yang and Xinhong Gan and Lin Chen and Xiaohan Wang and Ming Li and Yuanyuan Lu and Jian Xu},
  title = {{Heavy Metals Distribution and Source Identification in Contaminated Agricultural Soils: Isotopic and Multi-Model Analysis}},
  booktitle = {Agronomy},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/agronomy15040812},
}
Figure