Heavy flavour production at HERA

M.e. Hayes, Michael KrämerJournal of Physics G Nuclear and Particle Physics 1999 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: This review summarizes the theoretical and experimental status of heavy-flavour production at the HERA collider as of early 1999. It highlights significant tensions between perturbative QCD predictions and experimental data from the H1 and ZEUS detectors, particularly in charm photoproduction and beauty cross-sections.

Introduction

In the late 1990s, the HERA collider served as the primary facility for probing the subatomic structure of matter through high-energy electron-proton ($ep$) collisions. Heavy quarks, specifically charm ($c$) and beauty ($b$), are ideal subjects for testing perturbative Quantum Chromodynamics (pQCD) because their large masses provide a hard scale for calculations. However, early data revealed discrepancies that challenged standard models, particularly regarding the spatial distribution of charmed mesons and the overall rate of beauty production.

Methodology and Datasets

The study evaluates experimental data collected by the H1 and ZEUS detectors during the 1996-1997 run, totaling approximately $37 \text{ pb}^{-1}$ of integrated luminosity. These results are compared against several theoretical frameworks:

  • Next-to-Leading Order (NLO) QCD: Calculations incorporating higher-order particle interactions.
  • Fragmentation Models: Functions like the Peterson model that describe the transition from quarks to detectable mesons.
  • NRQCD: An effective field theory for heavy quark bound states (quarkonium).
  • Monte Carlo Simulations: Tools such as HERWIG and PYTHIA used to model complex event topologies, including non-perturbative "string effects."

Key Insights and Results

The Forward Charm Excess

One of the most notable findings was the "forward" movement of charmed $D^*$ mesons. Experimental data showed a higher rate of $D^*$ production in the direction of the proton beam than predicted by NLO theory. This suggests that non-perturbative forces, such as color fields "dragging" the charm quark, or a more complex internal structure of the photon, may be at play.

Differential cross-sections for $D^*$ production as a function of pseudorapidity $\eta^{D^*}$ for various transverse momentum cuts, showing discrepancies between data and NLO models.

The Role of the Resolved Photon

At HERA's high energies, the photon often acts as a composite object rather than a point-like particle. This "resolved" component, where the photon fluctuates into a collection of partons, is essential for explaining heavy quark production at low momentum fractions. While NLO models capture the general shape of charm production, they often fail to describe the "long tail" of the $x_\gamma^{OBS}$ distribution, which measures the fraction of the photon's momentum involved in the hard interaction.

The $x_\gamma^{OBS}$ distribution in photoproduction, comparing experimental data with HERWIG (top) and Massive NLO (bottom) predictions.

The Beauty Cross-Section Puzzle

Preliminary measurements of beauty production cross-sections were found to be up to five times higher than Leading Order (LO) theoretical expectations. For instance, ZEUS reported a visible cross-section of $39 \pm 11^{+23}_{-16} \text{ pb}$. Matching this data required a normalization factor of 3.7 in standard HERWIG simulations, indicating a significant gap in the theoretical understanding of $b$-quark mass or fragmentation.

Quarkonium and Polarization

The mechanism for $J/\psi$ meson formation remained a subject of debate between "Color Singlet" and "Color Octet" models. The authors emphasize that measuring the polarization of decay products is the most effective way to distinguish between these competing theories.

Discussion and Future Outlook

The primary constraint on these early findings was limited statistics. The authors anticipated that future HERA upgrades would provide the higher luminosity needed to reduce error bars, particularly for beauty production. Additionally, the implementation of silicon microvertex detectors was expected to improve the identification of $b$-quarks via displaced decay vertices. Theoretically, the development of "Variable Flavour Number Schemes" (VFNS) was identified as a priority to better bridge the gap between different energy regimes in QCD.

Summary updated

Abstract

We review the theoretical and experimental status of heavy-flavour production at HERA. The results presented include some outstanding issues in charm and beauty photoproduction, charm production in DIS and quarkonium production.
BibTeX
@article{hayes1999heavy,
  author = {M.E. Hayes and Michael Krämer},
  title = {{Heavy flavour production at HERA}},
  journal = {Journal of Physics G Nuclear and Particle Physics},
  year = {1999},
  doi = {10.1088/0954-3899/25/7/332},
}
Figure