Heating Up the Market

Shuang Wu, Connor Smith, Randy RolfMacEwan 2023 · DOI

Abstract

The study was conducted for a locally based company that wished to expand their consumer base and market reach. The relationship between consumer attitudes and brand perception was examined to identify potential marketing approaches. Results were gathered through a questionnaire (n= 136), in order to model consumer profiles and analyze their affect on product perception. The resulting multivariate regression model indicated that the difference in receptiveness to Kaiso’s branding between the Black/African demographic and the Caucasian demographic was significant. The average Black/African participant perceived the product more negatively than the average Caucasian participant. The same observation applied to South Asian demographics. Consumers’ self-reported likelihood to purchase was positively correlated with an increase in consumption rate across all participant profiles. Notably, aspects that provide opportunities to improve in the peer sauce industry are associated with traditional spicy cuisine, which is a trait correlated with the desire for perceived authenticity over other product attributes.

Introduction

KAISO Pepper Sauce, an Edmonton-based startup, recently faced the challenge of scaling from a local farmers' market favorite to a mainstream household staple. This research addresses the "scaling wall" by investigating the disconnect between a product's premium, modern brand identity and the consumer's desire for "authenticity" in ethnic food categories. By exploring how demographics and psychological dispositions toward new foods—specifically neophilia versus neophobia—dictate purchase intent, this study aims to provide actionable insights for niche food brands.

Methodology

The research utilized a two-phase approach. Initial qualitative focus groups identified key product attributes valued by consumers, such as flavor balance, heat levels, local production, and dietary restrictions. These insights informed a quantitative survey ($n=136$).

Table 1: Distribution of participants across age groups.

The core analysis employed a Multivariate Multiple Regression Model estimated via Ordinary Least Squares (OLS). Multivariate Analysis of Variance (MANOVA) was used to test the significance of variables including branding perception, taste memory, and consumer attitudes against purchase decisions. This statistical framework allowed the researchers to isolate the demographic and behavioral factors driving market receptivity.

Data and Demographics

The primary dataset consists of 136 valid survey responses collected through random sampling at malls and universities, as well as convenience sampling. The sample was notably skewed toward younger participants and was ethnically diverse, providing a broad base for analyzing demographic-specific perceptions.

Table 2: Demographic breakdown of survey participants by ethnicity and age group.

Key Insights: The Authenticity Paradox

A significant finding was the "authenticity gap" among participants traditionally familiar with spicy Caribbean-style cuisines. Black/African and South Asian participants perceived KAISO’s branding more negatively than Caucasian participants. The data suggests that KAISO’s sleek, modern packaging may inadvertently signal a lack of authenticity to those who associate high-quality hot sauce with more traditional or even dated label designs.

Conversely, the study found that "neophilia"—an openness to new food experiences—is a major market driver. For neophilic individuals, perceived quality and novelty outweighed the need for traditional aesthetics, making them the most promising segment for rapid growth. Furthermore, "locally owned" status was a significantly stronger driver for purchase decisions than "organic" or "non-GMO" labels, highlighting the value of community-engaged marketing.

Results and Market Implications

The final regression model identified five statistically significant indicators for purchase likelihood: Black/African ethnicity, South Asian ethnicity, frequency of consumption, the consumer attitude index, and age.

Key findings include:

  • Drivers of Purchase: "Locally Owned" was the most influential factor (61 participants), followed by "Health" (44).
  • Usage Patterns: Hot sauce is predominantly consumed with chicken and wings, suggesting clear targets for recipe-based marketing campaigns.
  • Branding Impact: Despite the authenticity gap in certain groups, 43 participants indicated a high likelihood of purchase based solely on branding and design.

Conclusion

While modern branding appeals to new, neophilic consumers, it may alienate demographics familiar with traditional cuisine who equate specific aesthetic cues with authenticity. Future work should explore whether authenticity can be communicated through modern aesthetics via targeted storytelling and social media, rather than through label redesigns. Additionally, future studies should incorporate blind taste tests to decouple sensory experience from brand perception.

Summary updated

Abstract

The study was conducted for a locally based company that wished to expand their consumer base and market reach. The relationship between consumer attitudes and brand perception was examined to identify potential marketing approaches. Results were gathered through a questionnaire (n= 136), in order to model consumer profiles and analyze their affect on product perception. The resulting multivariate regression model indicated that the difference in receptiveness to Kaiso’s branding between the Black/African demographic and the Caucasian demographic was significant. The average Black/African participant perceived the product more negatively than the average Caucasian participant. The same observation applied to South Asian demographics. Consumers’ self-reported likelihood to purchase was positively correlated with an increase in consumption rate across all participant profiles. Notably, aspects that provide opportunities to improve in the peer sauce industry are associated with traditional spicy cuisine, which is a trait correlated with the desire for perceived authenticity over other product attributes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2023heating,
  author = {Shuang Wu and Connor Smith and Randy Rolf},
  title = {{Heating Up the Market}},
  booktitle = {MacEwan},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.31542/tge3ez60},
}
Figure