Heating Homes with Servers: Workload Scheduling for Heat Reuse in Distributed Data Centers

Marcel Antal, Andrei-Alexandru Cristea, Victor-Alexandru Padurean, Tudor Cioara, Ionut Anghel, Claudia Antal, Ioan Salomie, Nicolas SaintherantSensors 2021 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel approach to reuse waste heat from distributed data centers by installing servers in residential homes to provide heating. They developed a thermal-aware workload scheduling system that uses both thermodynamic and machine learning models to optimally allocate tasks, ensuring homes are heated while meeting data center performance demands.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Data centers are massive energy consumers, with a significant portion of that energy being converted into heat that is typically wasted. This excess heat contributes to the environmental impact of data centers and represents a missed opportunity for energy recovery. While some efforts have been made to reuse data center heat for district heating, these often face challenges related to location, heat quality, and infrastructure costs. This paper tackles this by proposing a distributed data center model where servers are placed directly within residential buildings, acting as both computational resources and primary heat sources for the homes. The core challenge is to intelligently schedule computational workloads to generate the right amount of heat at the right time to maintain a comfortable room temperature, without compromising the performance of the data center tasks.

Methods

The authors propose a two-pronged approach:

  1. Thermal-Aware Workload Scheduling: This is framed as a constraint satisfaction problem. The goal is to determine an optimal scheduling matrix that assigns tasks to servers. This scheduling must satisfy:
  2. Service Level Agreements (SLAs): Ensuring tasks meet their deadlines and resource requirements.
  3. Heat Demand: Generating enough heat to meet the desired room temperature setpoint for the residents.
  4. Server Resource Constraints: Not exceeding the CPU, RAM, and HDD capacity of each server.
  5. Heat Demand Estimation Models: To inform the scheduling, two models are developed to estimate the heat demand:
  6. Thermodynamic Model: This model uses physical laws to predict how much heat a server needs to dissipate to change the room temperature from its current state to the desired setpoint. It considers factors like server power consumption, heat capacity, airflow, and room characteristics.
  7. Machine Learning (ML) Model: This approach uses monitored data (room temperature, server temperature, power consumption) to learn the relationship between workload execution and heat generation. They experimented with several ML algorithms, including Linear Regression, Polynomial Regression, Gradient Boosting Regressor, Random Forest Regressor, Support Vector Regression, and K-Nearest Neighbors Regression, with Gradient Boosting Regressor showing the best performance.

Datasets

The authors utilized data from an operational distributed data center, specifically from "QRad" server heaters. This data included ambient room temperature, server power consumption, and server temperature, recorded at a 10-second granularity over several months. This dataset was pre-processed through filtering, smoothing, and relevant sample extraction before being used for model training and validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Decentralized Heat Reuse: Placing servers directly in homes fundamentally changes the heat reuse paradigm, eliminating the need for complex district heating infrastructure and directly addressing local heating needs.
  • Dual-Purpose Hardware: The concept of using IT equipment as a dual-purpose "computing heater" is a compelling way to improve energy efficiency and reduce the carbon footprint of both data centers and residential heating.
  • Balancing Act: The core challenge lies in balancing the competing demands of computational performance (SLAs) and thermal comfort (heating). The proposed scheduling framework directly addresses this trade-off.
  • Model Synergy: Combining thermodynamic principles with machine learning provides a robust approach. The thermodynamic model offers a physics-based understanding, while ML captures complex real-world dynamics and can adapt to specific environments.

Key Results

  • Correlation Accuracy: The thermodynamic model achieved a correlation accuracy of 11.98% between server heat/power demand and actual heat demand. The best-performing ML model, Gradient Boosting Regressor, achieved a correlation accuracy of 4.74%.
  • Reasonable Time to Setpoint: The proposed workload scheduling solution successfully distributed workloads to meet temperature setpoints within a reasonable timeframe.
  • Accurate Power Following: The server power demand accurately followed the estimated heat demand.
  • Model Performance: The Gradient Boosting Regressor was identified as the most suitable ML model for predicting heater power demand, showing less than 5% error (under 10W).
  • Simulation Validation: The simulation results demonstrated that the system could effectively manage server power to meet predicted heat demand, leading to room temperature increases that matched setpoints.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Complexity: The paper acknowledges that the thermodynamic function ($f_{\theta}$) can be complex, making direct optimization challenging. This led to the subproblem approach.
  • Generalizability: While validated on an operational distributed DC, the models' performance might vary with different server types, room characteristics, and environmental conditions.
  • Scalability: The paper focuses on a specific setup; scaling this to a large number of distributed servers and homes would require further investigation.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that further research could explore more complex thermodynamic models, investigate different ML architectures, and conduct real-world pilot deployments to validate the system's long-term performance and user acceptance. The paper also mentions the need to consider the impact of task migration on SLAs and the potential for optimizing workload distribution for energy efficiency beyond just heat generation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Data centers consume lots of energy to execute their computational workload and generate heat that is mostly wasted. In this paper, we address this problem by considering heat reuse in the case of a distributed data center that features IT equipment (i.e., servers) installed in residential homes to be used as a primary source of heat. We propose a workload scheduling solution for distributed data centers based on a constraint satisfaction model to optimally allocate workload on servers to reach and maintain the desired home temperature setpoint by reusing residual heat. We have defined two models to correlate the heat demand with the amount of workload to be executed by the servers: a mathematical model derived from thermodynamic laws calibrated with monitored data and a machine learning model able to predict the amount of workload to be executed by a server to reach a desired ambient temperature setpoint. The proposed solution was validated using the monitored data of an operational distributed data center. The server heat and power demand mathematical model achieve a correlation accuracy of 11.98% while in the case of machine learning models, the best correlation accuracy of 4.74% is obtained for a Gradient Boosting Regressor algorithm. Also, our solution manages to distribute the workload so that the temperature setpoint is met in a reasonable time, while the server power demand is accurately following the heat demand.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{antal2021heating,
  author = {Marcel Antal and Andrei-Alexandru Cristea and Victor-Alexandru Padurean and Tudor Cioara and Ionut Anghel and Claudia Antal and Ioan Salomie and Nicolas Saintherant},
  title = {{Heating Homes with Servers: Workload Scheduling for Heat Reuse in Distributed Data Centers}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=m95CIPrfUj},
}

Loading related content...

Figure