Heat transfer performance assessment for forced convection in a tube partially filled with a porous medium

Chen Yang, Akira Nakayama, Wei LiuInternational Journal of Thermal Sciences 2011 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how to best enhance heat transfer in a tube by inserting porous materials. The authors found that the assumption of local thermal equilibrium is sufficient when the porous material is in the core, but not when it lines the tube wall. Ultimately, the optimal placement depends on the pumping power available, with the core placement being better at low power and the wall lining being better at high power.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Enhancing heat transfer is crucial for many engineering applications, from heat exchangers to electronics cooling. One promising method is to insert porous materials into fluid flow channels, as these materials can significantly increase the surface area available for heat exchange. However, understanding how to best utilize these porous materials is complex. This paper tackles the question of where to place a porous medium within a tube – either as a core insert or as a lining on the tube wall – to achieve the most effective heat transfer enhancement. A key challenge in modeling these systems is the assumption of "local thermal equilibrium" (LTE), which simplifies calculations but may not always be accurate, especially when there are significant differences in thermal conductivity between the fluid and the porous solid, or when heat generation is uneven. This study aims to clarify when LTE is a valid assumption and to compare the heat transfer performance of the two porous medium placement strategies.

Methods

The researchers employed a detailed mathematical modeling approach to analyze forced convection heat transfer in tubes with porous media. They developed two sets of energy equations: one based on the "local thermal non-equilibrium" (LTNE) assumption, which treats the fluid and solid phases of the porous medium as having separate temperatures, and another based on the "local thermal equilibrium" (LTE) assumption, where both phases are assumed to be at the same temperature. They analyzed two configurations: a tube with a porous medium core and a tube with a porous medium layer lining the wall. For velocity profiles, they used a plug flow approximation, which simplifies the flow near the wall, and compared it with the more complex Darcy-Brinkman model. They derived analytical solutions for temperature profiles and calculated the Nusselt number (a measure of heat transfer efficiency) for both LTNE and LTE models in both configurations. Finally, they compared the performance of the two configurations under equal pumping power to assess their effectiveness.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical modeling and analytical solutions rather than experimental data or pre-existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • LTE is not always sufficient: The study highlights that the LTE assumption is only valid for porous media in the core of a tube. When the porous medium lines the tube wall, LTNE analysis is essential for accurate heat transfer predictions. This is because the direct contact with the heated wall creates a larger temperature gradient between the wall and the fluid, making separate temperature considerations for each phase crucial.
  • Placement matters for pumping power: The optimal placement of the porous medium depends heavily on the available pumping power. At low pumping power, a porous medium core offers better heat transfer. However, as pumping power increases, the porous medium lining the wall becomes more effective. This suggests a trade-off between heat transfer enhancement and the energy required to drive the flow.
  • Porous medium filling ratio is key: In both configurations, increasing the amount of porous medium generally leads to higher heat transfer. However, the rate of increase differs: it's gradual for a core insert but steep for a wall lining, especially as the filling ratio approaches unity.

Key Results

  • LTNE is crucial for wall-lined porous media: The study demonstrates that the LTE analysis overestimates the Nusselt number for the case of a porous medium lining the tube wall, especially for smaller porous filling ratios. This indicates that LTNE is necessary for accurate predictions in this configuration.
  • Core placement is simpler to model: For a porous medium core, the LTE assumption provides results that are "hardly discernible" from LTNE, suggesting it's a reasonable simplification for this configuration.
  • Performance comparison: At low pumping power, the Nusselt number for the porous core configuration is higher. Conversely, at high pumping power, the porous wall-lined configuration yields a higher Nusselt number. This is illustrated in Figure 10, which shows the Nusselt number versus dimensionless pumping power.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplified velocity profile: The study uses a plug flow approximation for the velocity profile, which simplifies calculations but might not capture all nuances of flow behavior, especially in complex porous structures. The authors acknowledge that the Darcy-Brinkman model provides a more detailed velocity profile.
  • Neglected contact resistance: The effect of contact resistance between the heating wall and the porous medium is neglected for simplification. The authors note that experimental investigations suggest this can significantly impact heat transfer performance.
  • Specific porous material and fluid: The study uses correlations for aluminum foam and air, and future work could explore other porous materials and fluids.
  • Further optimization: While the study compares two placements, further research could explore more complex arrangements or optimized porous structures. The authors suggest that for given operating conditions, careful examination is needed to choose the best placement.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{yang2011heat,
  author = {Chen Yang and Akira Nakayama and Wei Liu},
  title = {{Heat transfer performance assessment for forced convection in a tube partially filled with a porous medium}},
  journal = {International Journal of Thermal Sciences},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1016/j.ijthermalsci.2011.10.023},
}
Figure