Heat Transfer and Friction Characteristics of the Microfluidic Heat Sink with Variously-Shaped Ribs for Chip Cooling

Gui-Lian Wang, Da-Wei Yang, Yan Wang, Di Niu, Xiao-Lin Zhao, Guifu DingSensors 2015 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper investigates how different rib shapes (rectangular, triangular, semicircular) in microfluidic heat sinks affect heat transfer and fluid friction. The findings show that while ribs significantly improve cooling performance, they also increase pressure drop, with triangular ribs offering the best heat transfer enhancement but also the highest friction penalty.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As electronic chips become more powerful and compact, their heat dissipation requirements are escalating. Traditional cooling methods struggle to keep pace, leading to overheating and reduced device lifespan. Microfluidic heat sinks, which use tiny channels to circulate coolant directly over the heat source, offer a promising solution. However, to further enhance their cooling capacity, researchers are exploring ways to improve heat transfer within these microchannels. One common approach is to introduce "ribs" or turbulators on the channel walls. These ribs disrupt the smooth flow of the coolant, promoting mixing and increasing heat transfer. However, this enhancement comes at a cost: increased resistance to flow, known as pressure drop. The challenge, therefore, is to find rib designs that maximize heat transfer while minimizing the penalty of increased pressure drop. This paper specifically addresses the need to understand how the shape of these ribs influences both heat transfer and friction characteristics, aiming to guide the design of more efficient microfluidic cooling systems.

Methods

The researchers employed a dual approach: experimental investigation and numerical simulation.

Experimental Setup: * Fabrication: Microfluidic heat sinks were fabricated using silicon (Si) wafers. The process involved photolithography, inductively-coupled plasma-reactive ion etching (ICP-RIE) to create the microchannels, and sputtering/electroplating for heater and bonding layers. Three types of ribbed microchannels (rectangular, triangular, semicircular) and a smooth microchannel were created. * Testing: De-ionized water was used as the working fluid. The temperature of the water was precisely controlled, and its flow rate was managed by a pump and verified by weighing. Heat was applied via a nickel thin-film heater. Temperature measurements at the inlet and outlet, as well as on the heat sink surface (using an infrared camera), were taken. Pressure drop across the microchannels was measured using piezometers.

Numerical Simulation: * Software: The finite-volume-based computational fluid dynamics (CFD) software package, FLUENT, was used. * Model: A 3D conjugate heat transfer simulation was performed. Due to symmetry, a single-branch microchannel was used as the computational domain. * Assumptions: The simulations assumed steady, incompressible, laminar flow with constant fluid and solid properties. Gravity, radiation, and viscous dissipation were considered negligible. * Governing Equations: Standard continuity, momentum, and energy equations were solved. * Boundary Conditions: Uniform velocity and constant temperature were applied at the inlet, a pressure outlet at the exit, a uniform heat flux on the top surface, and symmetry conditions on the lateral surfaces. * Grid Independence: A grid independence test was conducted to ensure the accuracy of the simulation results.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental measurements and numerical simulations performed by the authors.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ribs Enhance Heat Transfer, But at a Cost: The fundamental finding is that introducing ribs into microchannels significantly improves heat transfer compared to smooth channels. However, this comes with a substantial increase in pressure drop, meaning more pumping power is required.
  • Rib Shape Matters Significantly: The shape of the ribs is not just a minor detail; it has a pronounced effect on both heat transfer and friction. This highlights the importance of optimizing rib geometry for specific applications.
  • Triangular Ribs: The Heat Transfer Champion (with a caveat): Triangular ribs demonstrated the highest Nusselt number (a measure of heat transfer efficiency), indicating superior cooling performance. However, they also resulted in the highest friction factor, meaning the greatest resistance to flow.
  • Recirculation Zones are Key: The presence of ribs creates recirculation zones behind them. This phenomenon is crucial for enhancing heat transfer by mixing cooler bulk fluid with hotter fluid near the walls. The extent and nature of these recirculation zones vary with rib shape.
  • Thermo-Hydraulic Performance Trade-off: When considering both heat transfer enhancement and pressure drop penalty (thermo-hydraulic performance), the ribbed microchannels are not always superior to smooth channels, especially at higher Reynolds numbers (Re > 600). This suggests that ribbed designs are most beneficial under specific operating conditions.

Key Results

  • Heat Transfer Enhancement: Compared to smooth microchannels, the maximum average Nusselt number enhancement was found to be 1.65-times for rectangular ribs, 1.99-times for triangular ribs, and 1.85-times for semicircular ribs.
  • Friction Factor Increase: The apparent friction factor increased significantly with ribs. For rectangular ribs, it increased by 0.96-4.28 times; for triangular ribs, by 0.63-6.67 times; and for semicircular ribs, by 0.76-3.99 times, relative to smooth channels.
  • Optimal Rib Shape: Triangular ribs provided the highest heat transfer enhancement.
  • Thermo-Hydraulic Performance: The thermal enhancement factor (η) generally increased with Reynolds number initially and then decreased. For Re > 600, the ribbed microchannels showed lower thermo-hydraulic performance than smooth channels. The triangular ribbed microchannel had the highest enhancement factor, while the rectangular ribbed microchannel had the lowest. The semicircular ribbed microchannel exhibited the best thermo-hydraulic performance in the range of 500 < Re < 1000.
  • Experimental vs. Numerical: The experimental results for Nusselt number and friction factor showed good agreement with the numerical simulation results.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations: * Operating Conditions: The study focused on specific operating conditions (heat flux of 50 W/cm², Reynolds numbers from 100-1000). The performance of ribbed microchannels might differ at other heat fluxes or flow rates. * Thermo-Hydraulic Performance at High Re: The paper notes that for Re > 600, the ribbed microchannels are not superior to smooth channels in thermo-hydraulic performance. This implies that for applications requiring high flow rates, the increased pressure drop might outweigh the heat transfer benefits.

Future Work: * The authors suggest that further research could explore other rib shapes, arrangements (e.g., alternated opposed ribs), and combinations of features to optimize heat transfer and minimize pressure drop. * Investigating the effect of different working fluids or nanofluids in conjunction with these ribbed structures could also be a promising avenue. * Extending the study to higher Reynolds numbers or turbulent flow regimes would provide a more comprehensive understanding of their performance.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2015heat,
  author = {Gui-Lian Wang and Da-Wei Yang and Yan Wang and Di Niu and Xiao-Lin Zhao and Guifu Ding},
  title = {{Heat Transfer and Friction Characteristics of the Microfluidic Heat Sink with Variously-Shaped Ribs for Chip Cooling}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2015},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=mvg9Au3eUaw},
}
Figure