Heat Shock Protein Inhibitors Show Synergistic Antibacterial Effects with Photodynamic Therapy on Caries-Related Streptococci In Vitro and In Vivo

Zichen Zhang, Yaoting Ji, Danfeng Liu, Shuhui Zhou, Zijun Wang, Rourong Chen, Ting Li, Boxuan Zhao, Hantao Yao, Minquan DumSphere 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study introduces a novel strategy for combating dental caries by combining photodynamic therapy (PDT) with heat shock protein (HSP) inhibitors. This synergistic approach significantly enhances the antibacterial and anti-biofilm effects against key cariogenic bacteria, both in lab settings and in a rat model, offering a promising new avenue for caries prevention and treatment.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Dental caries, a prevalent oral disease, is driven by cariogenic biofilms, primarily composed of Streptococcus species. While photodynamic therapy (PDT) shows promise as an antibacterial treatment, it can inadvertently trigger a heat shock response in bacteria. This response involves the upregulation of heat shock proteins (HSPs), which act as cellular protectors, potentially conferring resistance to PDT and diminishing its effectiveness. This creates a critical need for strategies that can overcome this bacterial defense mechanism to achieve more robust and lasting antibacterial outcomes.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • In Vitro Antibacterial Assays: They tested the efficacy of chlorin e6 (Ce6)-based PDT, alone and in combination with HSP inhibitors (apoptozole and nonactin), against planktonic cultures of Streptococcus mutans, S. sobrinus, and S. sanguinis. This involved determining lethal doses (LDs) via CFU counting and observing colony formation on agar plates.
  • Gene Expression Analysis: Quantitative real-time PCR (qRT-PCR) was used to measure the expression levels of key HSP-encoding genes (grol and dnak) in response to Ce6-PDT.
  • Biofilm Inhibition Assays: The study evaluated the impact of the combined therapy on both monomicrobial and multispecies biofilms. Techniques included crystal violet staining to quantify biofilm biomass, live/dead bacterial staining with confocal laser scanning microscopy (CLSM) to assess cell viability, and fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) for visualizing bacterial populations within multispecies biofilms. Field-emission scanning electron microscopy (FE-SEM) was used to examine biofilm structure.
  • In Vivo Caries Model: A rat model was established to assess the anticaries efficacy of the combined treatment. This involved monitoring bacterial colonization on tooth surfaces using CFU counts and plate imaging, and evaluating caries lesion severity using Keyes' scoring and micro-CT imaging.
  • Biological Safety Assessment: The safety of the treatment was evaluated by monitoring rat weight, and through histological examination of major organs (heart, liver, spleen, kidney, lung) and blood biochemistry analysis.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized standard bacterial strains and established in vitro and in vivo models for caries research.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • HSPs as a Resistance Mechanism: The study clearly demonstrates that PDT can induce the expression of HSPs in cariogenic streptococci, suggesting this is a key mechanism by which bacteria can resist PDT.
  • Synergy is Key: Combining HSP inhibitors with PDT significantly boosts antibacterial efficacy, particularly against S. mutans and S. sobrinus, and is more effective than PDT alone.
  • Biofilm Disruption: The synergistic approach is highly effective in inhibiting both the formation and structural integrity of cariogenic biofilms, a critical factor in caries development.
  • In Vivo Efficacy: The promising in vitro results translate to significant anticaries effects in a rat model, reducing bacterial load and the severity of tooth decay.
  • Targeted Approach: The study highlights the potential for a more refined therapeutic strategy by targeting bacterial defense mechanisms.

Key Results

  • Planktonic Bacteria: Ce6-PDT alone showed bactericidal effects, but the addition of HSP inhibitors significantly enhanced this effect, leading to fewer residual bacteria. For example, in S. mutans, the combination showed a greater reduction in bacterial counts compared to PDT alone.
  • Gene Expression: Ce6-PDT significantly upregulated grol and dnak gene expression in S. mutans (up to 50-fold for grol) and S. sobrinus (up to 20-fold for grol), confirming the heat shock response.
  • Biofilm Inhibition: The combination therapy dramatically reduced biofilm biomass in both monomicrobial and multispecies biofilms. In some cases, nearly complete inhibition of biofilm formation was observed with the combined treatment. Live/dead staining confirmed a significant reduction in viable bacteria within biofilms treated with the synergistic approach.
  • In Vivo Caries Reduction: In the rat model, the Ce6-PDT + HSP inhibitor group showed significantly reduced streptococcal colonization on tooth surfaces and a substantial decrease in the severity and extent of carious lesions compared to control groups and PDT alone.
  • Biological Safety: The study found no significant adverse effects on rat weight, organ histology, or blood biochemistry, indicating satisfactory biological safety for the combined treatment.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest future directions:

  • Fixed Irradiation Energy: The study used a fixed total energy of irradiation, which is a moderate dose. Further research is needed to determine if more optimal irradiation conditions exist for this therapy.
  • Gram-Negative Bacteria: The study focused on Gram-positive streptococci. Future investigations should explore the efficacy of this approach against Gram-negative bacteria and assess potential imbalances in the oral microbiome.
  • Specific HSPs: While grol and dnak were investigated, it's possible that other essential HSPs or mechanisms contribute to S. sanguinis's resistance, explaining its less pronounced response to the combined therapy. Further exploration into these specific pathways is warranted.
  • Clinical Translation: While promising, further development is needed for clinical application, including optimizing drug delivery and treatment protocols.

Summary updated

Abstract

Caries are chronic infections in which the cariogenic biofilm plays a critical role in disease occurrence and progression. Photodynamic therapy (PDT) is a new effective treatment that is receiving wide attention in the antibacterial field, but it can lead to the upregulation of heat shock proteins (HSPs), which enhances bacterial resistance. Herein, we incorporated HSP inhibitors with PDT to evaluate the effect on Streptococcus mutans, Streptococcus sobrinus, and Streptococcus sanguinis under planktonic conditions and on cariogenic biofilms. Additionally, a model of caries was established in 2-week-old rats, and anticaries properties were evaluated by Keyes' scoring. Importantly, the combination of HSP inhibitors and PDT had outstanding efficiency in inhibiting the growth of tested Streptococcus strains and the formation of either monomicrobial or multispecies biofilms <i>in vitro</i>. In addition, the quantity of colonized streptococci and the severity of carious lesions were also distinctly suppressed in vivo. Overall, the synergistic application of HSP inhibitors and PDT has promising potential in the prevention and treatment of dental caries. <b>IMPORTANCE</b> Effective therapies for the prevention and control of caries are urgently needed. Cariogenic streptococci play a key role in the occurrence and progression of caries. Recently, photodynamic therapy has been demonstrated to have good antibacterial efficiency, but it can cause a heat shock response in bacteria, which may weaken its practical effects. We indicate here an effective therapeutic strategy of combining heat shock protein inhibitors and photodynamic therapy, which shows excellent inhibition toward three dominant streptococci related to caries and suppression of carious progression in a rat model. Further development for clinical application is promising.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2023heat,
  author = {Zichen Zhang and Yaoting Ji and Danfeng Liu and Shuhui Zhou and Zijun Wang and Rourong Chen and Ting Li and Boxuan Zhao and Hantao Yao and Minquan Du},
  title = {{Heat Shock Protein Inhibitors Show Synergistic Antibacterial Effects with Photodynamic Therapy on Caries-Related Streptococci <i>In Vitro</i> and <i>In Vivo</i>}},
  booktitle = {mSphere},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1128/msphere.00679-22},
}
Figure