Heat and Drought Have Exacerbated the Midday Depression Observed in a Subtropical Fir Forest by a Geostationary Satellite

Qianqian Xie, Kexin Chen, Tong Li, Jia Liu, Yuqiu Wang, Xiaolu ZhouForests 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that extreme heat and drought events, particularly when occurring together, significantly increase the frequency of midday depression in subtropical fir forests. By analyzing high-resolution satellite data and flux tower measurements, the research highlights how these climatic stressors force trees to reduce photosynthesis during the hottest parts of the day, impacting carbon uptake and forest resilience.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Forest ecosystems, especially those in subtropical regions like China, are increasingly threatened by climate change, specifically by more frequent and intense heatwaves and droughts. A key physiological response of trees to these stresses is "midday depression," where photosynthesis rates drop during the hottest part of the day. This phenomenon, driven by stomatal closure to conserve water and protect against heat damage, reduces a forest's overall carbon sequestration capacity. While midday depression is a known response, its fine-timescale dynamics and how they are exacerbated by compound heat and drought events have not been thoroughly analyzed. This gap in understanding can lead to underestimations of climate change impacts on forest productivity and carbon cycling, hindering effective forest management and the accuracy of Earth system models.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach combining satellite remote sensing with ground-based flux tower data. They utilized high-resolution (10-minute interval) photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) data from the Himawari 8 meteorological satellite. This data, along with meteorological data from the ERA5-land dataset (temperature, relative humidity), was used to estimate Gross Primary Productivity (GPP) using a model adapted from Landsberg and Waring. To ensure accuracy, these satellite-derived GPP estimates were rigorously validated against half-hourly GPP measurements from an eddy covariance flux tower located at the study site. Midday depression was identified and quantified using three circadian metrics: the daily center of mass of GPP (CGPP), the GPP peak hour (Hourpeak), and the ratio of GPP in the morning to the afternoon (Ratio M/A). Climatic events (heat, drought, and compound heat-drought) were defined based on temperature percentiles and precipitation thresholds. The relationship between these events and the frequency of midday depression was then analyzed using linear regression.

Datasets

  • Himawari 8 Meteorological Satellite Data: Provided photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) data at a 10-minute interval with a 500m spatial resolution.
  • ERA5-land Dataset: Offered hourly meteorological data (temperature, relative humidity, potential evapotranspiration) at a 0.1° spatial resolution, which was then interpolated to a half-hourly resolution.
  • Flux Tower Data: Provided ground-truth measurements of ecosystem-scale carbon fluxes (GPP) at a half-hourly interval from the Huitong Chinese fir forest site.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • High-Resolution Data is Crucial: The study demonstrates the power of using fine-timescale (10-minute) satellite data to capture the nuances of diurnal photosynthetic responses, which coarser resolution data might miss.
  • Midday Depression as a Stress Indicator: The frequency and intensity of midday depression serve as a sensitive indicator of environmental stress on forest ecosystems.
  • Compound Events are Worse: The synergistic effect of heat and drought is more detrimental than either stressor alone, leading to a significantly higher probability of midday depression.
  • Adaptive Strategy: Midday depression is not just a passive response but an active, adaptive strategy by trees to survive extreme conditions, albeit at the cost of reduced carbon uptake.

Key Results

  • Increased Midday Depression in 2022: The year 2022 saw the highest number of midday depression occurrences (126 times), coinciding with the highest average temperature (29.1 °C) during the study period.
  • Seasonal Peaks: Midday depression was most frequent during summer and autumn, with 48 and 34 occurrences, respectively.
  • Impact of Climatic Events: Compound drought and heat events induced midday depression with a probability of 74.3%, followed by heat events (66.0%) and drought events (47.5%).
  • Strong Correlation with Heat: Heat events showed the strongest correlation with midday depression (R² = 0.92), indicating heat stress as a primary driver.
  • Model Validation: The GPP estimation model using satellite data showed satisfactory fitting performance with flux tower measurements (R² = 0.605 for satellite data, R² = 0.631 for flux tower data).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Flux Tower Network: The study acknowledges that the scarcity of flux towers in the subtropical fir forest region limits the ability to precisely delineate regional flux variations at a landscape scale, potentially leading to discrepancies in midday depression patterns across broader areas.
  • Model Simplifications: The current GPP model does not incorporate factors like soil nutrients and specific tree species, nor does it fully account for latent and sensible heat effects. This can lead to inaccuracies in reflecting carbon flux dynamics and instantaneous changes.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that advancements in observation techniques and platforms will yield more precise data, improving the accuracy of GPP measurements and models. Future work could also focus on incorporating more comprehensive factors into GPP models to better capture complex ecosystem responses.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recently, increasing heat and drought events have threatened the resilience of Chinese fir forests. Trees primarily respond to these threats by downregulating photosynthesis including through stomatal limitation that causes a drop in productivity at noon (known as the midday depression). However, the effects of these events on midday and afternoon GPP inhibition are rarely analyzed on a fine timescale. This may result in negligence of critical responses. Here, we investigated the impact of climatic events on the midday depression of photosynthesis at a subtropical fir forest in Huitong from 2016 to 2022 using data from the Himawari 8 meteorological satellite and flux tower. Our results indicated that the highest number of midday depression occurred in 2022 (126 times) with the highest average temperature (29.1 °C). A higher incidence of midday depression occurred in summer and autumn, with 48 and 34 occurrences, respectively. Compound drought, heat, and drought events induced increases in midday depression at 74.3%, 66.0%, and 47.5%. Thus, trees are more likely to adopt midday depression as an adaptive strategy during compound drought and heat events. This study can inform forest management and lead to improvements in Earth system models.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xie2024heat,
  author = {Qianqian Xie and Kexin Chen and Tong Li and Jia Liu and Yuqiu Wang and Xiaolu Zhou},
  title = {{Heat and Drought Have Exacerbated the Midday Depression Observed in a Subtropical Fir Forest by a Geostationary Satellite}},
  booktitle = {Forests},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/f15091572},
}
Figure