Health shocks and changes in preventive behaviors: Results from the China Health and Retirement Longitudinal Study

Peng Zhang, Hongli Jiang, Wen ChenFrontiers in Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

Experiencing a "health shock" – a sudden deterioration in health due to illness or accident – acts as a powerful "teachable moment" for individuals in China to adopt healthier preventive behaviors. This study found that these shocks significantly reduce smoking and drinking, and increase the utilization of preventive healthcare services, particularly among older adults.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China faces a growing burden of chronic non-communicable diseases (NCDs), exacerbated by a population that often lacks preventive health behaviors. While health shocks are theorized to be a catalyst for behavioral change, there's a need to understand their specific impact on various preventive behaviors in the Chinese context, especially among the aging population. This paper aims to quantify how different types of health shocks influence personal health practices (smoking, drinking, exercise) and preventive care utilization (physical examinations) in China.

Methods

The researchers employed a sophisticated multilevel propensity score match difference-in-difference (multilevel PSM-DID) model. This approach is designed to simulate a counterfactual scenario, comparing individuals who experienced a health shock (treatment group) with those who did not (control group), while accounting for unobserved time-invariant characteristics.

Here's a breakdown of the methodology:

  • Propensity Score Matching (PSM): To ensure the treatment and control groups were comparable at baseline, PSM was used. This method matches individuals based on a set of observable characteristics (age, gender, education, etc.) to create a balanced sample. Kernel matching with logit regression was identified as the best method.
  • Difference-in-Difference (DID): After matching, the DID approach was applied. This compares the change in preventive behaviors before and after the health shock in the treatment group against the change in the control group over the same period. This helps isolate the effect of the health shock itself.
  • Multilevel Modeling: Recognizing that individuals are nested within communities and observed over time, a multilevel random intercept model was used. This accounts for potential correlations within these levels, leading to more accurate standard error estimates.
  • Health Shock Definition: Health shocks were defined as the self-reported diagnosis of any of five major chronic diseases: cancer, stroke, heart disease, diabetes, and hypertension, occurring between 2015 and 2018. These were further categorized into "major" (cancer, stroke, heart disease) and "minor" (diabetes, hypertension) shocks.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the China Health and Retirement Longitudinal Study (CHARLS). Specifically, the latest two waves of data from 2015 and 2018 were used. This dataset is a nationally representative survey of individuals aged 45 and older in China, providing rich information on demographics, health status, and behaviors. The choice of these waves was driven by the inclusion of more detailed physical examination items after 2015, allowing for a finer distinction between basic and auxiliary examinations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Teachable Moment" is Real: The study strongly supports the idea that a health shock creates a critical window of opportunity for individuals to re-evaluate and improve their health behaviors.
  • Heterogeneity Matters: Not all health shocks are equal. Major health shocks (like cancer or stroke) have a profound impact on reducing harmful behaviors, but may not necessarily lead to increased engagement in other preventive activities. Minor shocks, while less severe, can drive broader behavioral shifts.
  • Preventive Care is Underutilized, but Shocks Help: The study highlights that preventive care, particularly auxiliary inspections (lab tests), sees a significant uptake after health shocks, suggesting that individuals become more proactive in seeking medical advice and screenings.
  • Hypertension as a Broad Motivator: Interestingly, a hypertension diagnosis appears to be a particularly strong catalyst for a wide range of positive behavioral changes, including smoking cessation, reduced drinking, increased exercise, and greater utilization of physical examinations.

Key Results

  • Overall Impact of Health Shocks (HS):
    • Significantly decreased smoking (OR = 0.59).
  • Significantly decreased drinking (OR = 0.62).
  • Increased utilization of auxiliary inspections in physical examinations (OR = 1.19).
  • Major vs. Minor Health Shocks:
    • Major HS: Significantly reduced smoking (OR = 0.37) and drinking (OR = 0.56). Had less impact on exercise or general physical examination.
  • Minor HS: Significantly reduced smoking (OR = 0.74) and drinking (OR = 0.69). Also significantly increased exercise (OR = 1.32), physical examination (OR = 1.18), and auxiliary inspection (OR = 1.30).
  • Specific Disease Impacts:
    • Cancer diagnosis dramatically reduced smoking (OR = 0.03) but had no significant effect on other behaviors.
  • Stroke and heart disease diagnoses significantly reduced smoking and drinking.
  • Diabetes diagnosis was associated with reduced drinking, more exercise, and increased physical examination.
  • Hypertension diagnosis showed the most extensive impact, reducing smoking and drinking, and increasing exercise, physical examination, and auxiliary inspection.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Observation Period: The study's observation window is limited to two waves (2015-2018) due to data availability, which restricts the ability to conduct preliminary analyses and observe long-term behavioral maintenance.
  • Self-Reported Data: Preventive behaviors are self-reported, which can introduce recall bias and a tendency to overreport positive behaviors.
  • Short-Term Effects: The study primarily captures the immediate impact of health shocks. Future research should investigate the sustainability of these behavioral changes over longer periods.
  • Policy Implications: The findings suggest that healthcare providers should leverage the "teachable moment" following a health shock. Utilizing the 5A's brief intervention model (Ask, Advise, Assess, Assist, Arrange) could be highly effective in guiding individuals towards sustained positive health behaviors, reducing disease progression, and improving overall lifespan.

Summary updated

Abstract

After HS, there is a teachable moment to promote positive changes in preventive behaviors. Guided by the 5A's brief intervention model (Ask, Advise, Assess, Assist, Arrange), tailored interventions should be targeted at these populations to reduce the risk of the progression and complications of existing diseases, prevent the related comorbidity, and prolong the expected life-span.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2022health,
  author = {Peng Zhang and Hongli Jiang and Wen Chen},
  title = {{Health shocks and changes in preventive behaviors: Results from the China Health and Retirement Longitudinal Study}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fpubh.2022.954700},
}
Figure