Health Risk of Heavy Metals in Drinking Water Sources of Water-Carrying Lakes Affected by Retreating Polder: A Case Study of Luoma Lake

Jindong Wang, Xiaolong Zhu, Yicong Dai, Minyue Xu, Dongmei Wang, Yingcai Han, Wenguang Liang, Yifan Shi, Fanhao Song, Yao Li, Yiming Zhen, Qiuheng ZhuWater 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates heavy metal pollution in Luoma Lake, a crucial water source affected by both water diversion and polder reclamation. It reveals that while overall heavy metal risks are generally low, arsenic poses a significant carcinogenic risk, especially through drinking water, highlighting the need for targeted management strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Ensuring the safety of drinking water sources is paramount, and heavy metal contamination is a persistent threat. While research has explored heavy metal risks in traditional lakes, the impact on "water-carrying lakes" – those integrated into large-scale water diversion projects and subject to land reclamation (like polder retreat) – remains less understood. These lakes experience altered hydrodynamics and complex interactions that can influence pollutant distribution and risk. This paper addresses this gap by examining how water diversion and polder reclamation affect heavy metal pollution and associated health risks in Luoma Lake, a key component of China's South-to-North Water Diversion Project.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to assess heavy metal pollution and health risks:

  • Spatial and Temporal Sampling: Water samples were collected from 11 points across Luoma Lake during both the wet (July) and dry (December) seasons to capture seasonal variations and regional differences.
  • Heavy Metal Analysis: Concentrations of key heavy metals (Mn, Ni, Cu, Zn, As, Pb) were determined using Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (ICP-MS).
  • Water Quality Parameters: Standard water quality indicators (e.g., DO, pH, turbidity, nutrient levels) were measured to understand environmental influences.
  • Pollution Indices:
    • Single Factor Pollution Index (SFPI): Assessed the pollution level of individual heavy metals against Chinese drinking water standards.
  • Heavy Metal Pollution Index (HPI): Provided a comprehensive evaluation of overall heavy metal contamination, categorized into low, moderate, and high pollution levels.
  • Health Risk Assessment: Utilized models from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to calculate both carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic health risks for adults and children through two primary pathways: drinking water and dermal absorption.

Datasets

The study utilized water samples collected from Luoma Lake in Jiangsu Province, China, during July and December of 2023. These samples were analyzed for heavy metal concentrations and various water quality parameters. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the focus was on analyzing existing environmental data within the specific context of Luoma Lake.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Seasonal Dynamics are Crucial: Heavy metal concentrations, particularly Mn and Zn, significantly decrease during the dry season, suggesting that reduced surface runoff and precipitation in this period allow natural purification processes to become more effective.
  • Polder Reclamation Works: The retreating polder initiative in the northern part of Luoma Lake appears to be effective in reducing heavy metal pollution and variability, demonstrating the positive impact of ecological restoration efforts.
  • Human Activities Drive Variability: The "control area" (non-retreating polder) exhibits higher seasonal variability and elevated heavy metal levels (especially Zn, Ni, Cu, As), likely linked to ongoing aquaculture activities and associated feed inputs.
  • Arsenic is the Primary Concern: While most heavy metals pose negligible health risks, arsenic (As) stands out as a significant carcinogenic threat, particularly through drinking water consumption, with risks exceeding recommended levels.
  • Drinking Water is the Main Exposure Route: Health risks associated with heavy metals are generally higher via drinking water compared to dermal exposure, underscoring the importance of water quality for public health.

Key Results

  • Concentration Reductions: Heavy metal concentrations generally decreased from the wet to the dry season, with Mn and Zn showing substantial reductions of 89.3% and 56.2%, respectively.
  • HPI Improvements: The overall Heavy Metal Pollution Index (HPI) decreased by 13.16% in the retreating polder area compared to the control area, indicating improved water quality.
  • Pollution Levels: Most regions exhibited low pollution levels (HPI < 19), with the retreating polder and control areas showing moderate pollution (19 < HPI ≤ 38) during the wet season.
  • Health Risks:
    • Non-carcinogenic risks for Mn, Ni, Cu, Zn, and Pb were generally low (10⁻¹³ to 10⁻⁹), considered negligible.
  • Carcinogenic risk from arsenic (As) via drinking water reached 10⁻⁵ a⁻¹, exceeding recommended thresholds.
  • Health risks were generally higher for children than adults via drinking water, and higher for adults than children via dermal exposure.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Depth Variation Ignored: The study focused on surface water, neglecting potential variations in heavy metal distribution at different water depths, which could influence migration and deposition.
  • Short-Term Data: The analysis was based on data from two sampling periods, limiting the ability to discern long-term trends in heavy metal contamination.
  • Limited Exploration of Key Risk Factors: While arsenic was identified as a primary concern, further in-depth investigation into its environmental behavior and the factors influencing its distribution under varying hydrodynamic conditions is needed.

Future work should focus on addressing these limitations, particularly by incorporating multi-depth sampling, extending the monitoring period, and conducting more detailed investigations into the environmental fate and transport of arsenic to ensure drinking water safety.

Summary updated

Abstract

Heavy metal pollution is a critical issue affecting the safety of drinking water sources. However, the impact of human activities on heavy metal risk levels in water-carrying lakes remains unclear. This study aims to explore the risk mechanisms of heavy metals in Luoma Lake, an important water-carrying lake for the South-to-North Water Diversion Project. We explored the spatial and temporal differences in the distribution of heavy metals in Lake Luoma using methods such as the heavy metal pollution index (HPI) and assessed the risk variations using a health assessment model. The results indicated that heavy metal concentrations in water-carrying lakes generally decreased during the dry season, with Mn and Zn levels decreasing by 89.3% and 56.2%, respectively. The comprehensive score of HPI decreased by 13.16% following the retreating polder compared to the control area (Non-retreating polder area). Furthermore, the HPI at the drinking water intake was lower, which is closely associated with the elevated dissolved oxygen (DO) and oxidation–reduction potential (ORP) resulting from water diversion. The annual average health risk across the entire lake was not significant, with higher levels observed in the control area. The annual non-carcinogenic risk levels of Mn, Ni, Cu, Zn, and Pb range from 10−13 to 10−9, which are considered negligible risk levels. Notably, the carcinogenic risk posed by arsenic (As) through the drinking pathway reached 10−5 a−1, exceeding the maximum levels recommended by certain organizations. These findings provide a critical foundation for managing heavy metals in water-carrying drinking water sources.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2024health,
  author = {Jindong Wang and Xiaolong Zhu and Yicong Dai and Minyue Xu and Dongmei Wang and Yingcai Han and Wenguang Liang and Yifan Shi and Fanhao Song and Yao Li and Yiming Zhen and Qiuheng Zhu},
  title = {{Health Risk of Heavy Metals in Drinking Water Sources of Water-Carrying Lakes Affected by Retreating Polder: A Case Study of Luoma Lake}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/w16182699},
}
Figure