Have Your Cake and Eat It? Price Discount Programs under the Membership Free Shipping Policy in Online Retailing

Zhipeng Tang, Guowei Hua, Tai Chiu Edwin Cheng, Xiaowei Li, Jingxin DongJ. Theor. Appl. Electron. Commer. res 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Online retailers offering free shipping through membership programs often face increased operational costs due to frequent, small orders. This paper proposes and analyzes two discount strategies—limited-time and threshold discounts—to incentivize members to consolidate orders, leading to increased retailer profits and consumer welfare, achieving a "have your cake and eat it too" scenario.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The explosive growth of e-commerce has led online retailers to adopt free shipping policies to attract and retain customers. Two prominent strategies are Threshold Free Shipping (TFS), where free shipping is offered above a certain order value, and Membership Free Shipping (MFS), where subscribers pay a fee for free shipping on all orders. While MFS is effective at attracting members, it paradoxically encourages smaller, more frequent orders, significantly increasing shipping costs for retailers. For instance, Amazon's shipping revenue in 2016 was dwarfed by its shipping costs. This paper addresses the challenge of mitigating these increased operational costs associated with MFS by exploring how price discount programs can incentivize consumers to consolidate their purchases, thereby improving retailer profitability without sacrificing consumer benefits.

Methods

The authors employ analytical modeling to explore the impact of two price discount policies—limited-time discounts and threshold discounts—under an MFS framework. They develop mathematical models to analyze consumer shopping behavior, considering consumer heterogeneity (low-sensitivity vs. highly sensitive consumers) and different order structures. The models aim to determine optimal discount percentages and durations that maximize retailer profits and enhance consumer welfare. They compare these strategies against a baseline scenario without discounts and also consider scenarios where consumers not only consolidate orders but also make additional purchases.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical modeling and numerical simulations based on parameters derived from real-world e-commerce platforms like JD Group, Taobao, and Tmall, rather than direct dataset analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Have Your Cake and Eat It Too" Scenario: The core finding is that implementing well-designed price discount programs under MFS can lead to a win-win situation. Retailers can reduce operational costs (delivery) and potentially increase profits, while consumers benefit from discounts and consolidated shopping experiences.
  • Order Consolidation is Key: Both limited-time and threshold discounts effectively incentivize consumers to consolidate multiple small orders into larger ones, directly addressing the high-frequency, low-value order problem of MFS.
  • Profitability Without Sales Increase: Surprisingly, retailers can increase profits even without a direct increase in overall sales volume, primarily through reduced delivery costs achieved by order consolidation.
  • Consumer Heterogeneity Matters: The effectiveness of discount strategies is influenced by consumer sensitivity to discounts. Highly sensitive consumers are more likely to alter their shopping behavior to take advantage of discounts.
  • Delivery Cost as a Driver: Higher delivery costs make limited-time discounts more attractive for retailers, as the savings from consolidated orders become more significant.
  • Time vs. Threshold: Limited-time discounts are more effective when delivery costs are high or average order values are low, as they encourage immediate consolidation. Threshold discounts, on the other hand, are limited by purchase quantity and are more applicable to retailers with a wide range of products.

Key Results

The study derives optimal discount percentages and durations for both limited-time and threshold discount policies. For example, Proposition 1 provides the optimal discount percentage ($h_{ld}^*$) and duration ($a^*$) for limited-time discounts, and Proposition 5 offers similar optimal values ($h_{td}^*$ and $t_{td}^*$) for threshold discounts. Numerical simulations (Figures 5 and 6) illustrate that both discount policies can lead to increased retailer profits, with the magnitude of the increase depending on factors like delivery cost and average small order value. Specifically, higher delivery costs and lower average small order values generally lead to greater profit increases.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Simplified Order Consolidation: The study assumes orders are transferred or combined as a whole. Future work could explore scenarios where consumers transfer or combine only specific items within orders.
  • Focus on Order Structure: The current models primarily focus on order quantity and average purchase amount. Future research could incorporate the impact of fluctuating consumable prices and other uncertainties on discounting strategies.
  • Fixed Discount Threshold: The threshold discount model treats the discount threshold as fixed. Future work could treat this threshold as a decision variable.

The authors suggest exploring the impact of other consumer shopping behaviors and the dynamic nature of pricing and discounts in future research.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{tang2024have,
  author = {Zhipeng Tang and Guowei Hua and Tai Chiu Edwin Cheng and Xiaowei Li and Jingxin Dong},
  title = {{Have Your Cake and Eat It? Price Discount Programs under the Membership Free Shipping Policy in Online Retailing}},
  journal = {J. Theor. Appl. Electron. Commer. res},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/jtaer19010012},
}
Figure