Hashtags Are (Not) Judgemental: The Untold Story of Lok Sabha Elections 2019

Saurabh Gupta, Asmit Kumar Singh, Arun Balaji Buduru, Ponnurangam KumaraguruBigMM 2019 · DOI

Introduction

Social media has evolved into a primary "political playground," yet the sheer volume of data generated during national elections presents a significant analytical challenge. Traditional studies often focus on full tweet text, a process that is computationally expensive and frequently obscured by noise. Researchers from IIIT-Delhi proposed a more streamlined approach: analyzing the 2019 Indian General Elections through the lens of hashtags alone. By examining nearly 25 million hashtags, the study sought to determine if these short metadata tags could accurately reflect ground-level events and predict electoral outcomes.

Methodology

The research utilized a multi-stage pipeline to process a massive dataset of 45.1 million raw tweets (8.22 million after cleaning). The methodology included:

  1. Event Mapping: Cross-referencing trending hashtags with real-world news timelines.
  2. Topic Modeling (LDA): Identifying 20 distinct themes, such as "Modi Praise" or "Promotions," by treating hashtags within a single tweet as a coherent unit.
  3. Semantic Similarity (Skip-gram): Using Word2Vec to group official candidate tags (e.g., #raga) with unofficial or derogatory ones (e.g., #pappu), providing a holistic view of a candidate's digital footprint.
  4. Influence Metric: The paper’s primary contribution, which moves beyond simple popularity. Influence is calculated by subtracting the count of negative hashtags from the count of positive hashtags for a specific candidate.

Key Insights: Popularity vs. Influence

A central finding of the study is that "Popularity is a Trap." A candidate may possess a high total hashtag count, but if a majority of those mentions are insults or criticisms, they are not truly "winning" the social media battle. For instance, while Rahul Gandhi maintained high hashtag volume in the Amethi constituency, a significant portion of those tags were negative.

A word cloud visualizing the dominant hashtags and political themes that defined the 2019 election discourse on Twitter.

Semantic analysis further revealed a distinct branding effect: #modi was frequently linked to terms like #surgicalstrike, whereas #raga was semantically associated with derogatory terms. By shifting the focus to the Influence metric—measuring net positive sentiment—the researchers found a data point that consistently aligned with real-world results.

Results and Predictive Power

The study found that hashtag usage is generally concise; approximately 45% of tweets contain only one or two hashtags, with an average of 3.02 per tweet. This distribution remained relatively consistent across all seven phases of the election.

The distribution of hashtags per tweet across the seven phases of the 2019 Indian General Election.

Most importantly, the Influence metric demonstrated remarkable predictive power. In three high-profile "battles" analyzed—Smriti Irani vs. Rahul Gandhi, Gautam Gambhir vs. Atishi Marlena, and Sadhvi Pragya vs. Digvijay Singh—the metric correctly identified the winner in every instance. In the Amethi contest, although Rahul Gandhi had higher total volume, Smriti Irani’s positive hashtag proportion exceeded 70%, mirroring her eventual victory.

Conclusion and Limitations

While the study proves that hashtags are sufficient to reconstruct political timelines and predict key contests, limitations remain. The reliance on manual labeling for sentiment is difficult to scale, and the data is restricted to Twitter, which may not capture the sentiments of rural voters or users on platforms like WhatsApp. Future work aims to automate sentiment classification to apply this Influence metric across all 543 constituencies.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{gupta2019hashtags,
  author = {Saurabh Gupta and Asmit Kumar Singh and Arun Balaji Buduru and Ponnurangam Kumaraguru},
  title = {{Hashtags Are (Not) Judgemental: The Untold Story of Lok Sabha Elections 2019}},
  booktitle = {BigMM},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1109/bigmm50055.2020.00038},
}
Figure