Has Electronic Commerce Growth Narrowed the Urban–Rural Income Gap? The Intermediary Effect of the Technological Innovation

Dan WangSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates whether the rapid growth of e-commerce in China has helped to reduce the significant income gap between urban and rural areas. The study finds that e-commerce growth does significantly narrow this gap, acting as a crucial tool for adjusting income distribution, though it doesn't directly do so through technological innovation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China, despite its impressive economic growth, faces a persistent and substantial income disparity between its urban and rural populations. This urban-rural divide is a major bottleneck for sustainable economic development and social stability. While e-commerce has been widely studied for its economic impacts, its specific role in mitigating this income inequality has received less attention. This paper aims to fill that gap by empirically examining how the expansion of e-commerce in China affects the urban-rural income gap.

Methods

The study employs a quantitative approach using provincial panel data from China. The core methodology involves regression analysis to assess the relationship between e-commerce growth and the urban-rural income gap.

  • Benchmark Model: A standard econometric model is used to estimate the impact of e-commerce growth on the Theil index (a measure of income inequality) while controlling for other relevant factors like urbanization rate, industrial structure, human capital, and dependency ratios.
  • Instrumental Variable (IV) Approach: To address potential endogeneity issues (where e-commerce growth and the income gap might influence each other), the researchers use an instrumental variable method. They select the mileage of grade roads and the number of post offices in 1991 as instrumental variables for current e-commerce growth. This is based on the premise that historical infrastructure development influences current e-commerce adoption but has no direct impact on the current income gap.
  • Robustness Tests: The study conducts several robustness checks, including using alternative measures for e-commerce growth (online retail sales/GDP, Taobao Town ratio) and employing different regression techniques (e.g., SYS-GMM) to ensure the findings are reliable.
  • Mechanism Testing: The paper also explores a potential mediating role of technological innovation, examining whether e-commerce growth influences technological innovation, which in turn affects the income gap.

Datasets

The study utilizes provincial panel data from China for the period 2002-2017. The data sources include:

  • China Statistical Yearbook: Provides data on various socio-economic indicators at the provincial level.
  • The Ali Institute: Used for data related to e-commerce, specifically the number of Taobao towns and towns, and per capita express delivery volume.

Provinces with incomplete data (Xinjiang, Tibet, Yunnan, Chongqing) and regions like Hong Kong, Macao, and Taiwan were excluded from the analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • E-commerce as an Equalizer: The most striking insight is that e-commerce growth is not just an economic phenomenon but a powerful tool for social equity, actively narrowing the urban-rural income gap.
  • Beyond Direct Impact: While e-commerce growth is beneficial, its direct impact on the income gap is not mediated by technological innovation. This suggests that the benefits of e-commerce reach rural areas through other channels, perhaps more directly related to market access and income generation.
  • Infrastructure Matters: The use of historical infrastructure (roads, post offices) as instrumental variables highlights the foundational role of physical infrastructure in enabling the digital economy and its subsequent impact on income distribution.
  • Policy Implications: The findings strongly suggest that policies promoting rural e-commerce development are crucial for achieving balanced regional growth and common prosperity in China.

Key Results

  • Significant Reduction of Income Gap: The study consistently finds that an increase in e-commerce growth (measured by per capita express volume) leads to a significant reduction in the urban-rural income gap. For instance, a 1% increase in e-commerce growth was associated with a reduction of 0.08–0.54% in the urban-rural income gap in robustness tests.
  • Instrumental Variable Confirmation: After accounting for potential endogeneity using instrumental variables, the negative relationship between e-commerce growth and the urban-rural income gap remains statistically significant, reinforcing the causal effect.
  • Technological Innovation's Limited Mediating Role: While e-commerce growth does positively influence technological innovation (measured by patent applications), this innovation effect does not significantly mediate the reduction of the urban-rural income gap. In some regressions, the technological innovation effect even slightly weakened the positive impact of e-commerce.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Limitations: The study acknowledges limitations due to the exclusion of certain provinces (Xinjiang, Tibet, Yunnan, Chongqing) and regions (Hong Kong, Macao, Taiwan) due to data availability. This restricts the generalizability of findings to the entire Chinese context.
  • Mediating Role Nuance: The finding that technological innovation does not act as a significant mediator is interesting. The authors suggest that the radiation effect of technological innovation might be more concentrated in urban areas, thus weakening its impact on rural income disparity. Future research could explore this further.
  • Policy Focus: The authors recommend that Chinese policymakers focus on improving rural infrastructure, fostering e-commerce businesses in rural areas, and encouraging technological innovation within the e-commerce sector to further reduce the urban-rural income gap and promote common prosperity.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the internet era, the development of e-commerce has had an important impact on all aspects of society. Many previous studies focused on the social and economic effects of the development of e-commerce. However, previous studies paid little attention to the impact of e-commerce development on the urban–rural income gap. Here, the influence of electronic commerce growth on the urban–rural income gap is investigated based on Chinese provincial panel data. The result reveals that electronic commerce growth measured by per capita express volume (pair value) can effectively explain the urban–rural income gap, i.e., the income gap between cities and the countryside is reduced with the rise of the electronic commerce growth level after a series of possible factors for the urban–rural income gap (e.g., urbanization rate, industrial proportion, dependency ratio, and human capital) are controlled. In the abovementioned conclusions, the influence of electronic commerce growth on the income gap between cities and the countryside still takes on significance even after the use of the post office number and the mileage of grade roads in 1991 as the instrumental variables of the current electronic commerce growth and the robustness test. The growth of electronic commerce is a vital new approach for adjusting the urban–rural income distribution pattern. The study further reveals that electronic commerce growth does not directly affect the urban–rural income gap by affecting technological innovation. The research results of this study provide a reference for electronic commerce growth and the income distribution of cities and the countryside.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2023has,
  author = {Dan Wang},
  title = {{Has Electronic Commerce Growth Narrowed the Urban–Rural Income Gap? The Intermediary Effect of the Technological Innovation}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su15086339},
}
Figure