Abstract
Fluorescence endoscopy technology utilizes a light source of a specific wavelength to excite the fluorescence signals of biological tissues. This capability is extremely valuable for the early detection and precise diagnosis of pathological changes. Identifying a suitable experimental approach and metric for objectively and quantitatively assessing the imaging quality of fluorescence endoscopy is imperative to enhance the image evaluation criteria of fluorescence imaging technology. In this study, we propose a new set of standards for fluorescence endoscopy technology to evaluate the optical performance and image quality of fluorescence imaging objectively and quantitatively. This comprehensive set of standards encompasses fluorescence test models and imaging quality assessment protocols to ensure that the performance of fluorescence endoscopy systems meets the required standards. In addition, it aims to enhance the accuracy and uniformity of the results by standardizing testing procedures. The formulation of pivotal metrics and testing methodologies is anticipated to facilitate direct quantitative comparisons of the performance of fluorescence endoscopy devices. This advancement is expected to foster the harmonization of clinical and preclinical evaluations using fluorescence endoscopy imaging systems, thereby improving diagnostic precision and efficiency.
Introduction
Fluorescence endoscopy has become a transformative tool in modern surgery. By utilizing near-infrared (NIR) light to excite fluorescent dyes like Indocyanine Green (ICG), surgeons can visualize critical structures—such as tumors, lymph nodes, and blood vessels—that remain hidden under standard white-light illumination.
Despite its clinical utility, the industry currently lacks unified technical standards. This lack of standardization makes it difficult for clinicians to compare devices from different manufacturers and for developers to ensure rigorous quality control. Common issues include variations in sensitivity, resolution discrepancies, and spatial "lag" or misalignment between white-light and fluorescence image overlays (fusion accuracy). This paper addresses these gaps by proposing a harmonized evaluation system centered on a specialized physical phantom and standardized metrics.
Methodology: The Fluorescence Test Phantom
The cornerstone of this research is the development of a custom-engineered fluorescence test phantom made from black polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE). This material was chosen for its durability and optical properties. The phantom is designed with specific functional zones to evaluate various performance dimensions:
- Sensitivity and Dynamic Range: A matrix of 16 wells is filled with varying concentrations of ICG (ranging from 0.153 µg/mL to 4.883 µg/mL) to determine the lowest detectable signal and the system's ability to handle high-contrast scenes.
- Resolution: Fork-like patterns and grooves allow for the measurement of the system's ability to resolve fine spatial details in both white-light and fluorescence modes.
- Detection Depth: Slots of varying depths, when covered with a 10% Intralipid fat emulsion (which mimics the scattering properties of human tissue), test how deep the endoscope can "see" through biological layers.
- Fusion Accuracy: L-shaped markers are used to quantify the spatial and temporal alignment between the fluorescence "glow" and the standard color image—a critical factor for surgical precision.
The study also formalizes mathematical frameworks for metrics such as Signal-to-Background Ratio (SBR) and Focal Plane Uniformity, moving the industry toward objective decibel (dB) and line-pair counts rather than subjective visual assessments.
Key Results and Validation
The proposed standards were validated using a commercial NIRF thoracoscopic system. The testing yielded specific, quantitative benchmarks:
- Resolution: The system demonstrated a fluorescence resolution of 1400 lines, compared to 2200 lines for standard white light.
- Sensitivity: The minimum detectable concentration (CL) was confirmed at 0.153 µg/mL.
- Dynamic Range: The system achieved 30.08 dB, indicating robust performance across varying signal intensities.
- Penetration Depth: Signals were successfully detected at depths of at least 5.5 mm through tissue-mimicking fluid.
- Fusion Accuracy: Spatial error was minimal (7 pixels on the x-axis, 5 on the y-axis), with a temporal delay of less than 100 ms, ensuring real-time surgical reliability.
Discussion and Future Outlook
By standardizing these metrics, the researchers provide a framework that ensures fluorescence endoscopy systems are both accurate and comparable. One of the most significant contributions is the formalization of "fusion accuracy," as even a few millimeters of offset in a surgical display could lead to critical errors.
However, the authors note that a static PTFE block is an idealized environment. Real-world surgery involves dynamic challenges like blood, surgical smoke, and organ movement. Future work will focus on developing more complex phantoms to simulate these conditions and updating standards for emerging NIR-II imaging technologies, which offer even deeper tissue penetration. Ultimately, these laboratory standards are intended to be integrated into routine clinical practice and hospital procurement protocols to improve diagnostic precision and patient safety.
Summary updated