Abstract
Pythagoras school believed that the 'number' was the essence of the world. The harmoniousness of the 'number' was the source of the world's harmoniousness. In fact, the harmoniousness of the 'number' is a kind of right and changeless relationship that embodying in factors of quantity or quality of things. So the harmoniousness of Pythagoras school is kind of sensory and formal principles, such as symmetry, balance, harmony etc which are building by the rate of the 'number' to all appearance; In fact, this harmoniousness is a kind of absolute and invariable rules of the cosmos. So the harmoniousness of Pythagoras school is not only a simple question of form, but also it is an important philosophical and aesthetical question refers to the relationships. Although someone of Pythagoras school believed later that harmoniousness was a result of oppositions and difference. In fact, according to Pythagoras school, the oppositions are some fixed and absolute rates without any possibility of changing. Therefore the Pythagoras school's harmoniousness is not only a question of opposition.
Introduction: Defining the Pythagorean Concept of Harmony
This research explores the foundational Pythagorean belief that "Number" constitutes the essence of the universe. Within this framework, "harmony" is not merely an aesthetic or musical descriptor but the mathematical expression of right, invariable relationships between numbers. For the Pythagoreans, harmony served as a rigorous philosophical principle of cosmic order and "oneness" derived from fixed ratios.
Historically, early Greek philosophy transitioned from a materialist arche (the origin of all things, such as water or air) to an abstract, mathematical one. This paper clarifies how the Pythagorean school utilized the concept of "Number" to bridge the gap between physical reality and abstract order, defining harmony as the "right relationship" governing everything from celestial mechanics to the health of the human soul.
Methodology
The study employs a hermeneutic approach to philosophical and historical analysis. By examining classical fragments and historical accounts—drawing on sources such as Aristotle, Plato, and subsequent commentators—the authors reconstruct the school's internal logic. The analysis categorizes Pythagorean arguments into specific justifications for why "Number" serves as the ultimate origin and how "Harmony" functions as its governing law.
Key Insights: The Transcendence of Number and Ratio
The Primacy of Number
Unlike the Ionians who sought physical elements, the Pythagoreans argued that "Number" is more fundamental due to its abstract and universal nature. While an object might lack a specific physical property, it cannot exist without a numerical "rule" or quantity.
Harmony as "Right Ratio"
The term harmonia originally referred to the act of joining things together. The Pythagoreans quantified this "joining" as a specific mathematical ratio. Consequently, beauty and order are viewed not as subjective perceptions but as the result of "right and changeless relationships" between quantities.
The Biological Application: The Soul as Tuning
A significant application of this theory is found in biology. The school conceptualized the human soul as a "harmony" or "tuning" of physical opposites (e.g., hot/cold, wet/dry). Health, therefore, is the maintenance of the correct ratio between these elements, analogous to a well-tuned musical instrument.
Static vs. Dynamic Harmony
The paper distinguishes Pythagorean harmony from the later "unity of opposites" proposed by Heraclitus. Pythagorean harmony is "static," relying on fixed, absolute rates. In contrast, Heraclitian harmony is dynamic, characterized by an ever-changing struggle between opposing forces.
Conclusion: The Dual Nature of Harmony
The Pythagorean definition of harmony is a dual-layered proposition:
- Sensory Manifestation: Externally, it appears as formal beauty—symmetry, balance, and coordination—perceived through the senses.
- Essential Principle: Internally, it represents an absolute, invariable law of the cosmos. It is the orderly principle that unifies a diverse and chaotic world into a coherent whole.
Ultimately, the Pythagorean school elevated harmony from a musical term to a significant philosophical and aesthetic category, shaping the trajectory of Western science and metaphysics.
Limitations and Future Directions
A primary limitation of the Pythagorean system is the difficulty of explaining qualitative properties through quantitative ratios. While ratios can describe the "form" of an object, they struggle to account for subjective sensory experiences like color or taste in a universally verifiable manner. Furthermore, the Pythagorean view is inherently static. Future research may explore the transition from this fixed view to the dynamic and dialectical models that emerged later in Greek thought.
Summary updated