Hardware efficient quantum algorithms for vibrational structure calculations

Pauline J. Ollitrault, Alberto Baiardi, Markus Reiher, Ivano TavernelliChemical 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new framework for calculating molecular vibrational energies on near-term quantum computers. They propose a novel "Compact Heuristic for Chemistry" (CHC) circuit that offers a good balance between accuracy, circuit depth, and computational cost, making it a promising approach for simulating molecular vibrations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Calculating the vibrational structure of molecules is crucial for understanding their properties and predicting spectroscopic behavior. However, accurately simulating these anharmonic vibrations is computationally expensive for classical computers, especially for larger molecules. While quantum computers offer the potential for significant speedups, current hardware limitations (noise, limited coherence times) make it challenging to implement complex quantum algorithms. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing quantum algorithms and circuits that are "hardware-efficient," meaning they are designed to work effectively on the noisy, intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices available today. Specifically, they address the challenge of representing and simulating the bosonic nature of molecular vibrations and developing efficient quantum circuits for both ground and excited state calculations.

Methods

The authors propose a general framework for vibrational structure calculations on quantum computers. Key aspects include:

  • Second Quantization Formalism: They adapt the second quantization formalism to represent the vibrational Hamiltonian, allowing for flexible basis sets and anharmonic potentials. This approach is more general than previous methods that relied on harmonic oscillator bases.
  • Wave Function Parametrization: They explore two main strategies for preparing the vibrational wave function on a quantum computer:
  • Unitary Vibrational Coupled Cluster (UVCC): This is a direct quantum analogue of a well-established classical method. While accurate, it tends to require deep circuits.
  • Compact Heuristic for Chemistry (CHC): This is a novel, more compact heuristic circuit designed to approximate UVCC. It aims to reduce circuit depth and the number of CNOT gates, making it more suitable for NISQ devices.
  • Quantum Eigensolver (VQE): The Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) algorithm is used to find the ground state energy by minimizing the energy expectation value of the Hamiltonian with respect to the parameters of the quantum circuit.
  • Quantum Equation of Motion (qEOM): For excited states, they extend the quantum Equation of Motion (qEOM) algorithm, which is used to calculate excitation energies.
  • Penalty Term for Symmetry: To ensure that the heuristic circuits respect the physical symmetries of the vibrational Hamiltonian, they introduce a penalty term in the Hamiltonian that discourages unphysical occupations of vibrational modes.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The authors use theoretical models and simulations of molecular systems (CO2, H2CO, HCOOH) rather than experimental datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • CHC as an Optimal Compromise: The paper highlights that the CHC Ansatz offers a compelling trade-off between the accuracy of UVCC and the shallow circuit depth of heuristic approaches. It provides a practical path towards simulating molecular vibrations on current quantum hardware.
  • Beyond Harmonic Bases: The framework's ability to handle generic modal bases (not just harmonic oscillator eigenfunctions) is crucial for accurately describing anharmonic systems, which are common in molecular vibrations.
  • Hardware Efficiency is Key: The focus on developing "hardware-efficient" circuits like CHC is essential for making quantum computation of molecular vibrations feasible in the near term, given the limitations of current quantum hardware.
  • qEOM for Excited States: Extending the qEOM algorithm to vibrational systems is a significant step towards simulating vibrational spectra, which are vital for experimental characterization.

Key Results

  • CO2 Simulations: The study demonstrates the performance of UVCC and CHC for calculating the ground-state vibrational energies of CO2. CHC shows comparable accuracy to UVCC with significantly fewer CNOT gates.
  • Resource Estimation: Table 1 provides a detailed comparison of quantum resource requirements (CNOT gates, parameters) for UVCC and CHC for molecules like CO2, H2CO, and HCOOH. CHC consistently requires orders of magnitude fewer CNOT gates.
  • Excited State Energies: Table 2 shows that for CO2, the qEOM algorithm with CHC can accurately calculate low-lying vibrational excitation energies, with deviations less than 1 cm⁻¹ in some cases.
  • Noise Resilience: Simulations with a noise model indicate that CHC can achieve better fidelities than UVCC in the presence of noise, likely due to its shallower circuit depth.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Heuristic Nature of CHC: While CHC offers a good compromise, it does not perfectly preserve the symmetries of the vibrational Hamiltonian. This can lead to unphysical configurations, especially for strongly anharmonic systems. The authors suggest projecting onto the correct symmetry subspace and using VSCF-obtained modal bases to improve accuracy in such cases.
  • Modal Mapping: The current algorithm maps each modal to a separate qubit, which can lead to a large portion of the qubit Hilbert space being unused. Future work could explore more compact mappings.
  • Scaling for Larger Systems: While CHC is more efficient, simulating very large molecules will still require significant quantum resources. The authors suggest that adapting CHC to more compact mappings could enable calculations for molecules with more than three atoms.
  • Extension to Three- and Four-Body Terms: The current work focuses on up to two-body excitations. Future work could explore including higher-order terms in the Hamiltonian and wave function for more complex systems.
  • Tensor Factorization: The authors mention that tensor factorization techniques, successful for fermionic systems, could be explored for vibrational systems to reduce measurement overhead and circuit depth.

Summary updated

Abstract

We introduce a framework for the calculation of ground and excited state energies of bosonic systems suitable for near-term quantum devices and apply it to molecular vibrational anharmonic Hamiltonians. Our method supports generic reference modal bases and Hamiltonian representations, including the ones that are routinely used in classical vibrational structure calculations. We test different parametrizations of the vibrational wavefunction, which can be encoded in quantum hardware, based either on heuristic circuits or on the bosonic Unitary Coupled Cluster <i>Ansatz</i>. In particular, we define a novel compact heuristic circuit and demonstrate that it provides a good compromise in terms of circuit depth, optimization costs, and accuracy. We evaluate the requirements, number of qubits and circuit depth, for the calculation of vibrational energies on quantum hardware and compare them with state-of-the-art classical vibrational structure algorithms for molecules with up to seven atoms.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ollitrault2020hardware,
  author = {Pauline J. Ollitrault and Alberto Baiardi and Markus Reiher and Ivano Tavernelli},
  title = {{Hardware efficient quantum algorithms for vibrational structure calculations}},
  booktitle = {Chemical},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1039/d0sc01908a},
}
Figure