Handover Protocol Learning for LEO Satellite Networks: Access Delay and Collision Minimization

Ju-Hyung Lee, Chanyoung Park, Soohyun Park, Andreas F. MolischarXiv 2023 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces DHO, a novel deep reinforcement learning (DRL) protocol for Low-Earth Orbit (LEO) satellite networks that significantly reduces handover (HO) access delay and collision rates. By intelligently skipping the traditional "Measurement Report" step and leveraging predictive capabilities, DHO offers a more efficient and practical solution for the unique challenges of LEO satellite communications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

LEO satellite networks, with their vast constellations and global coverage, are becoming crucial for broadband internet access, especially in remote areas. However, the rapid movement of satellites and the sheer number of users create significant challenges for network handovers (when a device switches from one satellite to another). Traditional handover protocols, designed for terrestrial networks, struggle with the long propagation delays inherent in satellite communications. These delays can lead to outdated information, increased access delays, and a higher chance of collisions (multiple devices trying to connect simultaneously), all of which degrade network performance. This paper specifically targets the handover process in regenerative-type LEO satellites, which can make autonomous decisions, and aims to optimize this process for efficiency and reliability.

Methods

The core of this paper is the DHO (Deep Handover) protocol, which utilizes Deep Reinforcement Learning (DRL). Instead of relying on the conventional handover process that includes a "Measurement Report" (MR) step, DHO skips this step. This is achieved by training a DRL agent (acting as the serving satellite) to predict the user equipment's (UE) network signal conditions and make proactive handover decisions.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • DRL Framework: The paper employs the IMPALA (Importance Weighted Actor-Learner Architecture) algorithm for training the DRL agent. IMPALA is chosen for its scalability, ability to handle large state and action spaces, and its off-policy learning capabilities, which are beneficial for complex, dynamic environments like LEO satellite networks.
  • Simplified HO Procedure: DHO eliminates the MR phase, which is a major contributor to propagation delay. The serving satellite agent directly decides on HO requests and target satellite selection.
  • MDP Modeling: The problem is framed as a Markov Decision Process (MDP), where the state includes the time index, previous actions, and accessed UE information. The action space involves deciding whether to initiate a HO request and to which target satellite.
  • Reward Function: The reward function is designed to penalize both access delay and collision rate, encouraging the agent to find a balance between these two critical performance metrics.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention using pre-existing datasets for training. Instead, it relies on a simulated network environment that models LEO satellite networks, ground UEs, and their interactions. The performance of DHO is evaluated through simulations under various scenarios, comparing it against conventional and heuristic methods.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Skipping the MR is Key: The most significant insight is that eliminating the Measurement Report (MR) step, a bottleneck due to propagation delay, drastically improves handover performance in LEO satellite networks.
  • DRL for Proactive Decisions: DRL is shown to be highly effective in enabling satellites to make proactive, real-time handover decisions based on learned patterns, rather than reactive responses to delayed measurements.
  • Local Observability is Sufficient: The DHO protocol demonstrates that effective handover decisions can be made using only locally observable information, which is crucial for distributed and scalable implementations in LEO satellite networks.
  • Trade-off Management: The DRL framework allows for explicit management of the trade-off between access delay and collision rate through the reward function, enabling customization for different application requirements (e.g., URLLC vs. MMTC).

Key Results

  • Significant Delay Reduction: DHO achieved up to 6.86x lower access delay compared to conventional HO protocols and 4.18x lower compared to heuristic methods in various scenarios.
  • Reduced Collision Rates: DHO also demonstrated lower collision rates, particularly in scenarios with sufficient resources.
  • Adaptability: The protocol showed flexibility in adapting its behavior based on resource availability (e.g., number of RBs), opting for more HO requests when resources are abundant and fewer when scarce.
  • Efficient Training: The IMPALA algorithm enabled stable training and convergence, even with complex state and action spaces.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Transfer Learning for New Conditions: The authors acknowledge that while DHO can adapt through continuous training, using transfer learning techniques would allow an agent trained under specific conditions to adapt more quickly to new network scenarios with fewer additional training episodes. This is identified as a focus for future research.
  • Scalability with More UEs: While IMPALA is robust, the paper notes that increasing the number of UEs significantly impacts training time. Future work could explore further distributed training or optimized UE management to improve scalability.
  • Distributed Multi-Agent DRL: The paper hints at the potential for a distributed multi-agent DRL approach in future work, given that the DHO protocol relies on locally observable information.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study presents a novel deep reinforcement learning (DRL)-based handover (HO) protocol, called DHO, specifically designed to address the persistent challenge of long propagation delays in low-Earth orbit (LEO) satellite networks' HO procedures. DHO skips the Measurement Report (MR) in the HO procedure by leveraging its predictive capabilities after being trained with a pre-determined LEO satellite orbital pattern. This simplification eliminates the propagation delay incurred during the MR phase, while still providing effective HO decisions. The proposed DHO outperforms the legacy HO protocol across diverse network conditions in terms of access delay, collision rate, and handover success rate, demonstrating the practical applicability of DHO in real-world networks. Furthermore, the study examines the trade-off between access delay and collision rate and also evaluates the training performance and convergence of DHO using various DRL algorithms.
BibTeX
@misc{lee2023handover,
  author = {Ju-Hyung Lee and Chanyoung Park and Soohyun Park and Andreas F. Molisch},
  title = {{Handover Protocol Learning for LEO Satellite Networks: Access Delay and Collision Minimization}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2310.20215},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20215},
}
Figure