Halperin states can produce any filling fractions

En-Jui KuoarXiv 2020 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract This study investigates bilayer Fractional Quantum Hall (FQH) states, specifically Halperin states, to determine the relationship between filling fractions and topological phases. We prove that for any positive rational filling fraction $\nu$, there exist infinitely many distinct topological states, represented by unique $K$ matrices. This result implies an infinite degeneracy of topological phases for any given observable filling fraction, a finding that holds across various charge vectors.

Introduction

In the study of the Fractional Quantum Hall Effect (FQHE), the filling fraction ($\nu$)—the ratio of electrons to magnetic flux quanta—is a fundamental observable. The $K$ matrix approach provides an effective field theory framework to describe these states. For bilayer systems, Halperin states are characterized by a $2 \times 2$ $K$ matrix: $$K = \begin{pmatrix} m & l \\ l & n \end{pmatrix}$$ A long-standing question in condensed matter physics is whether any rational number can serve as a filling fraction for these states and how many distinct topological phases can correspond to a single $\nu$.

Mathematical Framework

The filling fraction $\nu$ for a system with charge vector $t = (t_1, t_2)$ and $K$ matrix components $m, n, l$ is given by: $$\nu = t^T K^{-1} t = \frac{-2lt_2t_1 + nt_1^2 + mt_2^2}{mn - l^2}$$ The stability of the state requires the determinant to be positive: $\det(K) = mn - l^2 > 0$. The author treats this relationship as a Quadratic Diophantine Equation, seeking integer solutions for $m, n, l$. This mapping highlights that determining the existence of a topological state is equivalent to solving Hilbert’s tenth problem for specific quadratic forms—a task that is generally undecidable but solvable within this physical context.

Infinite Solutions for Filling Fractions

The central result of this work is the proof that for any rational $\nu > 0$, there are infinite integer solutions for the $K$ matrix. This suggests that the "topological zoo" of these states is far more expansive than previously assumed.

Partial solution list for various filling fractions $\nu$, showing the corresponding $K$ matrix components $(m, n, l)$ and the determinant $mn - l^2$.

As shown in the table above, even for simple fractions like $2/3$, multiple valid $K$ matrices exist. The paper uses techniques from number theory, such as mapping stability conditions to Pythagorean triples and utilizing quadratic residues, to prove that these solutions are indeed infinite in number.

The Role of Inter-layer Interaction

A key insight is the necessity of the off-diagonal term $l$, which represents inter-layer interactions. The author demonstrates that if $l$ is restricted to a finite set of values, the system can only produce a finite set of filling fractions. To reach any arbitrary rational $\nu$, $l$ must be allowed to vary freely.

Results and Discussion

The paper distinguishes between Bosonic states (where diagonal elements in $K$ are even) and Fermionic states (where they are odd). While Bosonic states can generate any rational fraction, Fermionic states are more constrained.

Furthermore, the determinant of the $K$ matrix, which relates to the number of non-equivalent quasiparticle excitations, can grow arbitrarily large for a fixed $\nu$. This confirms that a single observable filling fraction can correspond to an infinite variety of distinct topological phases of matter, making $\nu$ a "noisy" label for the underlying physics.

Conclusion

By mapping physical stability conditions to classical number theory problems, this work establishes that bilayer Halperin states can produce any rational filling fraction with infinite topological degeneracy. While the physical realizability and energetic stability of these infinite states remain subjects for future experimental and numerical investigation, the mathematical foundation for an infinite landscape of topological phases is now rigorously established.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study bilayer Fractional Quantum Hall State also known as Halperin state. We prove that for any filling fractions (positive rational numbers), there are infinite solutions that imply that infinite topological states are corresponding to any given filling fraction. Our results can apply to any charge vectors.
BibTeX
@misc{kuo2020halperin,
  author = {En-Jui Kuo},
  title = {{Halperin states can produce any filling fractions}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2004.09035},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2004.09035},
}
Figure