Half-Duplex and Full-Duplex AF and DF Relaying With Energy-Harvesting in Log-Normal Fading

Khaled Maaiuf Rabie, Bamidele Adebisi, Mohamed-Slim AlouiniIEEE Trans. Green Commun. Netw 2017 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper analyzes the performance of wireless relaying systems that harvest energy from the transmitted signals, specifically focusing on indoor environments characterized by log-normal fading. It provides a comprehensive comparison of half-duplex (HD) and full-duplex (FD) relaying, along with different energy harvesting techniques, offering valuable insights for designing efficient and reliable future wireless networks.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Wireless communication systems, especially those relying on battery-powered devices, face a critical challenge in maintaining connectivity and operability due to limited energy. Energy harvesting (EH) and wireless power transfer (WPT) offer promising solutions by allowing devices to scavenge energy from ambient radio-frequency (RF) signals. While much research has focused on outdoor environments (often modeled with Rayleigh fading), indoor environments present unique challenges due to signal attenuation caused by obstacles and human bodies. Log-normal fading is a more appropriate model for these indoor conditions. This paper addresses the performance analysis of cooperative relaying systems in these log-normal fading indoor channels, considering various relaying protocols (decode-and-forward (DF) and amplify-and-forward (AF)) and energy harvesting schemes (time-switching, power-splitting, and an ideal lower bound).

Methods

The core of this paper lies in deriving accurate analytical expressions for the ergodic outage probability. This metric quantifies the probability that the instantaneous channel capacity falls below a certain threshold, indicating a failure in reliable communication. The authors meticulously derive these expressions for numerous system configurations:

  • Half-Duplex (HD) Relaying:
    • Decode-and-Forward (DF) Protocol: Analyzed with Time-Switching Relaying (TSR), Power-Splitting Relaying (PSR), and Ideal Relaying Receiver (IRR) EH schemes.
  • Amplify-and-Forward (AF) Protocol: Also analyzed with TSR, PSR, and IRR EH schemes.
  • Full-Duplex (FD) Relaying:
    • Analyzed with DF and AF protocols, primarily focusing on the TSR EH scheme.

The derivations involve complex mathematical manipulations of log-normal random variables, utilizing probability density functions (PDFs), cumulative distribution functions (CDFs), and the Gaussian Q-function. Monte Carlo simulations are employed to validate the accuracy of the derived analytical expressions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper relies on theoretical analysis and simulations based on defined system parameters and channel models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Log-normal fading matters indoors: The paper highlights that log-normal fading, which better captures indoor channel characteristics like shadowing, significantly impacts system performance compared to outdoor models.
  • DF vs. AF trade-offs: While DF relaying generally offers slightly better performance when the relay's processing energy cost is ignored, AF relaying becomes more attractive when this cost is considered, potentially leading to a more efficient solution.
  • FD's potential, with a caveat: Full-duplex relaying can significantly outperform half-duplex systems by utilizing the spectrum more efficiently, but this advantage is highly dependent on the level of loop-back interference. High interference can negate FD's benefits.
  • EH parameter optimization is crucial: The performance of TSR and PSR schemes is sensitive to the EH time factor ($\tau$) and power-splitting factor ($p$). Suboptimal choices can lead to significant performance degradation, emphasizing the need for careful optimization.
  • Channel variance impact: Increasing the variance of the log-normal channel consistently degrades the performance across all relaying and EH protocols.

Key Results

  • Analytical expressions derived: The paper provides accurate analytical expressions for the ergodic outage probability for various HD and FD relaying systems with different EH schemes operating over log-normal fading channels.
  • Performance comparison:
    • In HD systems, DF relaying performs slightly better than AF relaying when the DF relay's processing energy cost is neglected.
  • FD relaying generally outperforms HD relaying, especially when loop-back interference is low.
  • Increasing log-normal channel variance degrades performance for all systems.
  • Impact of EH parameters: Suboptimal values of $\tau$ and $p$ (close to 0 or 1) lead to significant performance degradation.
  • IRR as a lower bound: The Ideal Relaying Receiver (IRR) scheme serves as a performance benchmark, consistently outperforming TSR and PSR.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Processing Energy Cost: The paper acknowledges that the assumption of zero processing energy cost at the DF relay is unrealistic and dedicates a section to analyzing its impact, showing that it can make AF relaying competitive or even superior to DF relaying.
  • Loop-back Interference: The performance of FD relaying is highly sensitive to loop-back interference. While the paper analyzes this, further research into advanced interference cancellation techniques for FD systems could be beneficial.
  • Direct Link: The current analysis assumes no direct link between the source and destination. The authors suggest that investigating scenarios with a direct link would be a valuable direction for future research.
  • Channel Estimation: The paper assumes perfect channel state information availability. Future work could explore the impact of imperfect channel estimation on system performance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Energy-harvesting (EH) and wireless power transfer in cooperative relaying networks have recently attracted a considerable amount of research attention. Most of the existing work on this topic however focuses on Rayleigh fading channels, which represent outdoor environments. In contrast, this paper is dedicated to analyzing the performance of dual-hop relaying systems with EH over indoor channels characterized by log-normal fading. Both half-duplex (HD) and full-duplex (FD) relaying mechanisms are studied in this work with decode-and-forward (DF) and amplify-and-forward (AF) relaying protocols. In addition, three EH schemes are investigated, namely, time-switching relaying, power-splitting relaying and ideal relaying receiver which serves as a lower bound. The system performance is evaluated in terms of the ergodic outage probability for which we derive accurate analytical expressions. Monte Carlo simulations are provided throughout to validate the accuracy of our analysis. Results reveal that, in both HD and FD scenarios, AF relaying performs only slightly worse than DF relaying which can make the former a more efficient solution when the processing energy cost at the DF relay is taken into account. It is also shown that FD relaying systems can generally outperform HD relaying schemes as long as the loop-back interference in FD is relatively small. Furthermore, increasing the variance of the log-normal channel has shown to deteriorate the performance in all the relaying and EH protocols considered.
BibTeX
@article{rabie2017half,
  author = {Khaled Maaiuf Rabie and Bamidele Adebisi and Mohamed-Slim Alouini},
  title = {{Half-Duplex and Full-Duplex AF and DF Relaying With Energy-Harvesting in Log-Normal Fading}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Green Commun. Netw.},
  year = {2017},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=Zl7tQlTg4_G},
}
Figure