H-Shaped Radial Phononic Crystal for High-Quality Factor on Lamb Wave Resonators

Weitao He, Lixia Li, Zhixue Tong, Haixia Liu, Qian Yang, Tianhang Gao2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel H-shaped radial phononic crystal (H-RPC) structure to significantly improve the quality factor (Q) of Lamb wave resonators (LWRs) by suppressing anchor loss. The H-RPC creates an ultra-wideband gap, effectively reflecting unwanted acoustic energy and leading to a remarkable increase in Q and a substantial reduction in insertion loss.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Miniaturized, high-performance resonators are crucial for modern wireless communication systems (like 5G) and sensor networks. Lamb wave resonators (LWRs) are a promising candidate due to their high operating frequency, high electromechanical coupling, and low power consumption. However, a major limitation hindering their performance is "anchor loss," where acoustic energy leaks from the resonator into its supporting structure, significantly reducing the resonator's quality factor (Q). This loss directly impacts filter performance and sensor resolution. Previous attempts to mitigate anchor loss have involved acoustic reflectors or specific resonator designs, but this paper tackles the problem by integrating phononic crystals (PCs) – periodic structures designed to manipulate wave propagation – into the anchor region of LWRs. Specifically, they address the need for a PC structure that can create a broad band gap to effectively block acoustic energy across a wide frequency range, even with short support tethers.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of theoretical analysis and finite element method (FEM) simulations using COMSOL Multiphysics.

  • Phononic Crystal Design: They proposed a novel "H-shaped radial phononic crystal" (H-RPC) structure. This structure is based on rotating a unit cell with an H-shaped cross-section radially, creating a periodic arrangement along the cylindrical coordinate system.
  • Complex Band Curve Analysis: The theoretical method involved transforming the elastic wave equations into a cylindrical coordinate system and applying the Bloch theorem. This allowed for the calculation of the complex band curve, which reveals the existence and characteristics of band gaps (frequency ranges where wave propagation is forbidden). The imaginary part of the wave vector in the band curve is crucial for quantifying the attenuation within the band gap.
  • Frequency Response Simulation: FEM simulations were used to model the frequency response of the H-RPC structure and the LWR. This involved applying displacement excitations and measuring the output, allowing for the evaluation of the stopband effect and attenuation levels. Perfect matching layers (PMLs) were used to absorb outgoing waves and prevent reflections.
  • LWR Integration and Analysis: The H-RPC structure was integrated into the anchor region of a simplified 1/4 LWR model. Simulations were then performed to analyze the impact of the H-RPC on key resonator performance metrics:
  • Anchor Quality Factor (Qanc): Calculated using the resonant angular frequency.
  • Loaded Quality Factor (Q): Determined from the admittance (Y11) and insertion loss curves.
  • Electromechanical Coupling Coefficient (k²eff): Calculated from the resonance and anti-resonance frequencies.
  • Insertion Loss: Directly simulated from the frequency response.
  • Figure of Merit (FOM): Calculated using a standard definition involving Q and k²eff.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on simulated data derived from material properties of silicon, aluminum, and aluminum nitride.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • H-RPC for Ultra-Wideband Gaps: The H-shaped radial phononic crystal design is particularly effective at creating an "ultra-wideband gap" with a relative bandwidth of up to 80.2% in the UHF range. This is a significant improvement over previous PC designs.
  • Radial Arrangement Advantage: The radial arrangement of the H-RPC is shown to be more suitable for suppressing anchor loss in LWRs compared to traditional linear or 2D arrangements, especially for short support tethers.
  • Geometric Parameter Sensitivity: The study highlights that the H-RPC's band gap characteristics are sensitive to geometric parameters. Specifically, the ratio of the middle support beam height to the total height ($h_1/h$) strongly influences the center frequency and bandwidth, while the ratio of the side wall width to the lattice constant ($a_1/a$) primarily affects the bandwidth.
  • Dramatic Q Improvement: The integration of the H-RPC structure leads to an astonishing increase in the anchor quality factor ($Q_{anc}$), by over 500,000% in some cases, effectively minimizing energy leakage.
  • Significant Insertion Loss Reduction: The H-RPC also substantially reduces insertion loss in the LWR, by over 93%, making the resonator more efficient for signal transmission.
  • Minimal Impact on Coupling Coefficient: Importantly, the H-RPC structure has a negligible effect on the electromechanical coupling coefficient ($k^2_{eff}$), preserving the resonator's ability to convert electrical to mechanical energy.
  • Optimal Spacing: There appears to be an optimal spacing (R) between the H-RPC and the support tether for maximizing performance, with R = 10 µm yielding the best overall Figure of Merit (FOM).

Key Results

  • Ultra-Wideband Gap: The H-RPC structure achieves an ultra-wideband gap with a relative bandwidth of 80.2% in the UHF range.
  • Anchor Quality Factor ($Q_{anc}$): When the H-RPC is applied with R = 0 µm, $Q_{anc}$ increases from $1.59 \times 10^4$ for a conventional LWR to $8.04 \times 10^7$, a 505,560.4% improvement.
  • Loaded Quality Factor (Q): The loaded Q of the LWR is increased by up to 249.9% (from 2773 to 9704) with the addition of the H-RPC.
  • Insertion Loss: Insertion loss is reduced by up to 93.10% (from 10.43 dB to 0.72 dB).
  • Electromechanical Coupling Coefficient ($k^2_{eff}$): Remains largely unaffected, staying between 0.17% and 0.18%.
  • Figure of Merit (FOM): The FOM is improved by up to 2.4 times, reaching a maximum of 17.0 at R = 10 µm.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simulation-Based: The study is primarily based on finite element simulations. While comprehensive, the authors acknowledge that further experimental validation is required to fully confirm the modeled results.
  • Material Properties: The simulations rely on specific material parameters for silicon, aluminum, and aluminum nitride. Variations in actual material properties could influence the performance.
  • Geometric Parameter Optimization: While the study analyzes the influence of key geometric parameters, a more exhaustive optimization sweep could potentially uncover even better designs.
  • Future Experimental Work: The authors explicitly state that future experimental work is needed to validate their findings, which is a standard and crucial next step in MEMS research. This would involve fabricating and testing the proposed H-RPC integrated LWRs.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{he2023h,
  author = {Weitao He and Lixia Li and Zhixue Tong and Haixia Liu and Qian Yang and Tianhang Gao},
  title = {{H-Shaped Radial Phononic Crystal for High-Quality Factor on Lamb Wave Resonators}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/s23042357},
}
Figure