GW170817A as a hierarchical black hole merger

V. Gayathri, I. Bartos, Zoltán Haiman, S. Klimenko, Bence Kocsis, Szabolcs Márka, Yi YangOxford 2020

TL;DR

This paper investigates the origin of the gravitational-wave event GW170817A, proposing it's likely a "hierarchical merger" where black holes that have already merged come together again. This is supported by its unusually high mass and spin, which are characteristic of mergers occurring in the dynamic environments of active galactic nuclei (AGN) disks.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The discovery of numerous binary black hole mergers through gravitational waves has opened a new window into the universe, but the astrophysical origins of these mergers remain a mystery. While some mergers likely arise from isolated binary star systems (first-generation, or "1g" mergers), another possibility is that black holes, potentially already products of previous mergers, encounter each other in dense environments and merge again. These "hierarchical mergers" are predicted to produce black holes with higher masses and spins than those formed from single stars. The paper aims to determine if the specific event GW170817A, with its intriguing mass and spin parameters, fits the profile of a hierarchical merger, particularly one occurring within an AGN disk.

Methods

The researchers employ a Bayesian model comparison framework to assess the likelihood of GW170817A originating from different scenarios. They compare three models:

  1. LIGO-Virgo observation-based distribution (1g): This model represents the expected properties of black hole mergers based on the observed population from the first two LIGO-Virgo observing runs (O1 and O2), assuming they are first-generation mergers.
  2. Hierarchical mergers in dynamical encounters (2g): This model simulates mergers where a black hole from a 1g merger encounters another black hole in a dense environment, like a globular cluster.
  3. Hierarchical mergers in AGN disks (AGN): This model specifically considers hierarchical mergers occurring within the accretion disks of active galactic nuclei, where black holes are expected to align their orbits and migrate towards the central supermassive black hole.

They calculate Bayes factors to quantify the evidence for each model given the observed data for GW170817A.

Datasets

The primary dataset used is the reconstructed parameters (masses, spins, and distance) of the gravitational-wave candidate GW170817A, as reported by Zackay et al. (2019). This is compared against the statistical distributions of previously detected LIGO-Virgo binary black hole mergers from the O1 and O2 observing runs (Abbott et al., 2019b). The paper also references theoretical population models for hierarchical mergers in AGN disks (Yang et al., 2019) and dynamical encounters (Healy et al., 2014).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hierarchical mergers as a source of heavy black holes: The paper reinforces the idea that hierarchical mergers are a plausible mechanism for producing black holes exceeding the ~50 solar mass limit expected from single stellar evolution.
  • AGN disks as "black hole assembly lines": The study highlights how the dynamic environment within AGN disks can facilitate repeated mergers, effectively acting as a factory for producing heavier and higher-spin black holes.
  • Spin alignment as a unique signature: The alignment of black hole spins within AGN disks provides a distinct observational signature that can differentiate these hierarchical mergers from those occurring in other dense environments.
  • GW170817A as a potential first direct evidence: The analysis suggests that GW170817A, with its specific mass and spin, is a strong candidate for being the first observed example of a hierarchical merger, particularly one originating from an AGN disk.

Key Results

The study found that:

  • The AGN hierarchical merger model provides a significantly better explanation for GW170817A than the standard 1g merger model, with a Bayes factor ($K_{AGN}^{1g}$) of approximately $2 \times 10^4$. This translates to an odds ratio ($O_{AGN}^{1g}$) of $10^3 - 10^4$, strongly favoring the AGN scenario.
  • The 2g hierarchical merger model (dynamical encounters) also provides a better explanation than the 1g model, with a Bayes factor ($K_{2g}^{1g}$) greater than or equal to 100.
  • Comparing the two hierarchical scenarios, the AGN model is slightly less favored than the 2g dynamical merger model, with an odds ratio ($O_{AGN}^{2g}$) between 0.4 and 2. However, the paper notes that the AGN model's predicted parameters (chirp mass ~45 $M_\odot$, effective spin ~0.4) are remarkably close to the reconstructed parameters of GW170817A (chirp mass ~40 $M_\odot$, effective spin ~0.5).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Uncertainty in GW170817A's astrophysical nature: The authors acknowledge that GW170817A is a candidate event and its astrophysical nature is not as certain as some other LIGO-Virgo discoveries.
  • Rate density uncertainties: The precise rate densities of hierarchical mergers, especially in AGN disks, are still uncertain, which impacts the final odds ratio calculations. The paper uses estimates but notes that different population-based models could slightly alter the likelihood of the 1g model.
  • Limited scope of 2g model: The 2g model considered only second-generation mergers and did not account for potential correlations between black hole masses or merger probabilities dependent on mass, which might be relevant in dense environments like globular clusters.
  • Future Work: The authors emphasize the need for a comprehensive study of all detected events to make a more definitive statement about the overall binary black hole population. They also suggest that with more observations, hierarchical black hole mergers may emerge as a clearly identified population. The paper also briefly mentions that accretion onto black holes can mimic some of the properties of hierarchical mergers, suggesting this as another avenue for future investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Despite the rapidly growing number of stellar-mass binary black hole mergers discovered through gravitational waves, the origin of these binaries is still not known. In galactic centers, black holes can be brought to each others' proximity by dynamical processes, resulting in mergers. It is also possible that black holes formed in previous mergers encounter new black holes, resulting in so-called hierarchical mergers. Hierarchical events carry signatures such as higher-than-usual black hole mass and spin. Here we show that the recently reported gravitational-wave candidate, GW170817A, could be the result of such a hierarchical merger. In particular, its chirp mass ~40 M⊙ and effective spin of χeff ~ 0.5 are the typically expected values from hierarchical mergers within the disks of active galactic nuclei. We find that the reconstructed parameters of GW170817A strongly favor a hierarchical merger origin over having been produced by an isolated binary origin (with an odds ratio of > 103).
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gayathri2020gw,
  author = {V. Gayathri and I. Bartos and Zoltán Haiman and S. Klimenko and Bence Kocsis and Szabolcs Márka and Yi Yang},
  title = {{GW170817A as a hierarchical black hole merger}},
  booktitle = {Oxford},
  year = {2020},
}
Figure