Gut microbiota density influences host physiology and is shaped by host and microbial factors

Eduardo J. Contijoch, Graham J. Britton, Chao Yang, Ilaria Mogno, Zhihua Li, Ruby Ng, Sean R. Llewellyn, Sheela Hira, Crystal N. Johnson, Keren M. Rabinowitz, Revital Barkan, Iris Dotan, Robert Hirten, Shih-Chen Fu, Yuying Luo, Nancy Yang, Tramy Luong, Philippe Ronel Labrias, Sérgio A. Lira, Inga Peter, Ari Grinspan, José C. Clemente, Roman Kosoy, Seunghee Kim‐Schulze, Xiaochen Qin, Anabella Castillo, Amanda Hurley, Ashish Atreja, Jason Rogers, Farah Fasihuddin, Merjona Saliaj, Amy Nolan, Pamela Reyes-Mercedes, Carina A. Rodriguez, Sarah Aly, Kenneth Santa-Cruz, Lauren Peters, Mayte Suárez‐Fariñas, Ruiqi Huang, Ke Hao, Jun Zhu, Bin Zhang, Bojan Losic, Haritz Irizar, Won-Min Song, Antonio Di Narzo, Wenhui Wang, Benjamin L. Cohen, Christopher J. DiMaio, David A. Greenwald, Steven H. Itzkowitz, Aimee L. Lucas, James F. Marion, Elana Maser, Ryan C. Ungaro, Steven Naymagon, Joshua Novak, Brijen J. Shah, Thomas Ullman, Peter Rubin, James George, Peter Legnani, Shannon Telesco, Joshua R. Friedman, Carrie Brodmerkel, Scott E. Plevy, Judy H. Cho, Jean‐Frédéric Colombel, Eric E. Schadt, Carmen Argmann, Marla C. Dubinsky, Andrew Kasarskis, Bruce E. Sands, Jeremiah J. FaitheLife 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the sheer number of microbes in our gut (microbiota density) is a critical factor influencing host health, not just the types of microbes present. They demonstrate that this density is shaped by both the host's "carrying capacity" and the microbes' "fitness," and that manipulating density can impact host physiology, offering new avenues for therapeutic interventions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For years, microbiome research has largely focused on who is in the gut (community composition) rather than how many are there (microbiota density). However, the authors argue that the number of microbes interacting with the host is likely as important, if not more so, for influencing host physiology. They aim to understand what factors determine gut microbiota density across different species and conditions, and how this density impacts host health, particularly in the context of disease and therapeutic interventions.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • DNA-based microbiota density estimation: They quantified gut microbiota density by measuring the total microbial DNA extracted from fecal samples per milligram of sample. This method is scalable and integrates well with standard sequencing workflows.
  • Mammalian species survey: Fecal samples from 16 different mammalian species were analyzed to understand natural variation in microbiota density and its correlation with host factors.
  • Gnotobiotic mouse models: Germ-free mice were colonized with microbiotas from different mammals or from human donors to dissect the roles of host carrying capacity versus microbial fitness in determining density.
  • Pharmacological interventions: Mice were treated with various drugs (antibiotics, laxatives, etc.) to assess their impact on microbiota density and subsequent host physiological changes.
  • Human cohort studies: Fecal samples from healthy individuals and patients with Inflammatory Bowel Disease (IBD) and recurrent Clostridium difficile infection (rCDI) were analyzed.
  • Fecal Microbiota Transplantation (FMT) studies: The impact of FMT on microbiota density and fitness was investigated in both human rCDI patients and in a gnotobiotic mouse model.
  • 16S rRNA gene sequencing and Shotgun metagenomics: These techniques were used to analyze microbial community composition and absolute abundances.

Datasets

The study utilized several datasets:

  • Mammalian fecal samples: Collected from 16 different mammalian species.
  • Human fecal samples: From healthy controls, patients with Crohn's disease (CD), ulcerative colitis (UC), and those who underwent ileal pouch-anal anastomosis (IPAA).
  • rCDI patient samples: From individuals with recurrent Clostridium difficile infection before and after FMT.
  • Gnotobiotic mouse models: Colonized with various microbial communities.
  • Publicly available datasets: For comparative analyses.

Raw sequencing files (fastq) for 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing and shotgun metagenomic sequencing are stored in the public Sequence Read Archive (SRA) under project number PRJNA413199.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Density is King (or at least a Major Player): The sheer number of microbes, not just their types, significantly influences host physiology.
  • Host & Microbe Tug-of-War: Microbiota density is a dynamic interplay between the host's "carrying capacity" (e.g., gut architecture, diet) and the "fitness" of the microbes to thrive in that environment.
  • Carnivores Have Less Dense Gut Ecosystems: Animals with simpler digestive systems, like carnivores, tend to have lower gut microbiota densities, suggesting gut architecture is a key determinant of carrying capacity.
  • Density Manipulation Affects Health: Altering microbiota density in mice with antibiotics or other drugs had downstream effects on host adiposity and immune function.
  • IBD and Low Density: Patients with IBD consistently show reduced gut microbiota density, which may contribute to disease progression or susceptibility to pathogens.
  • FMT Restores Fitness: Fecal microbiota transplantation successfully restores both microbiota density and "fitness" in patients with recurrent C. difficile infection, suggesting a mechanistic link.

Key Results

  • Mammalian Variation: Microbiota density varied by over 200-fold across 16 mammalian species, with carnivores showing significantly lower densities.
  • Antibiotic Impact: Nine out of 14 tested antibiotics significantly decreased gut microbiota density in mice.
  • IBD Correlation: Individuals with IBD (CD, UC, IPAA) had significantly lower microbiota densities compared to healthy controls.
  • FMT Efficacy: FMT in rCDI patients led to a significant increase in microbiota density and restoration of microbial community fitness.
  • Physiological Links: In mice, antibiotic-induced changes in microbiota density correlated with changes in cecum size, adiposity, fecal IgA, and colonic lamina propria FoxP3+CD4+ regulatory T cells.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Fungal Microbiome: The study acknowledges limitations in fully characterizing the fungal microbiome due to sparse genomic databases and potential biases in DNA extraction methods. Future work could explore the role of fungi more deeply.
  • Live/Dead Bacteria: While the DNA-based density metric is practical, it doesn't distinguish between live and dead bacteria. However, the authors found this did not significantly impact their major conclusions.
  • Causality: While correlations are strong, establishing definitive causal links between microbiota density and specific health outcomes requires further investigation.
  • Therapeutic Targets: The authors suggest that understanding the factors governing host carrying capacity and microbial fitness could lead to more targeted therapeutic strategies for various diseases, potentially involving prophylactic interventions to boost colonization resistance. Routine monitoring of microbiota density could also help identify individuals who might benefit from such interventions.

Summary updated

Abstract

This article has been through an editorial process in which the authors decide how to respond to the issues raised during peer review. The Reviewing Editor's assessment is that all the issues have been addressed (see decision letter).
BibTeX
@inproceedings{contijoch2019gut,
  author = {Eduardo J. Contijoch and Graham J. Britton and Chao Yang and Ilaria Mogno and Zhihua Li and Ruby Ng and Sean R. Llewellyn and Sheela Hira and Crystal N. Johnson and Keren M. Rabinowitz and Revital Barkan and Iris Dotan and Robert Hirten and Shih-Chen Fu and Yuying Luo and Nancy Yang and Tramy Luong and Philippe Ronel Labrias and Sérgio A. Lira and Inga Peter and Ari Grinspan and José C. Clemente and Roman Kosoy and Seunghee Kim‐Schulze and Xiaochen Qin and Anabella Castillo and Amanda Hurley and Ashish Atreja and Jason Rogers and Farah Fasihuddin and Merjona Saliaj and Amy Nolan and Pamela Reyes-Mercedes and Carina A. Rodriguez and Sarah Aly and Kenneth Santa-Cruz and Lauren Peters and Mayte Suárez‐Fariñas and Ruiqi Huang and Ke Hao and Jun Zhu and Bin Zhang and Bojan Losic and Haritz Irizar and Won-Min Song and Antonio Di Narzo and Wenhui Wang and Benjamin L. Cohen and Christopher J. DiMaio and David A. Greenwald and Steven H. Itzkowitz and Aimee L. Lucas and James F. Marion and Elana Maser and Ryan C. Ungaro and Steven Naymagon and Joshua Novak and Brijen J. Shah and Thomas Ullman and Peter Rubin and James George and Peter Legnani and Shannon Telesco and Joshua R. Friedman and Carrie Brodmerkel and Scott E. Plevy and Judy H. Cho and Jean‐Frédéric Colombel and Eric E. Schadt and Carmen Argmann and Marla C. Dubinsky and Andrew Kasarskis and Bruce E. Sands and Jeremiah J. Faith},
  title = {{Gut microbiota density influences host physiology and is shaped by host and microbial factors}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.40553},
}
Figure