Guidelines and definitions for research on epithelial-mesenchymal transition

Jing Yang, Parker B. Antin, Geert Berx, Cédric Blanpain, Thomas Brabletz, Marianne Bronner‐Fraser, Kyra Campbell, Amparo Cano, Jordi Casanova, Gerhard Christofori, Shoukat Dedhar, Rik Derynck, Heide L. Ford, Jonas Fuxe, Antonio Garcı́a de Herreros, Gregory J. Goodall, Anna‐Katerina Hadjantonakis, Ruby Yun‐Ju Huang, Chaya Kalcheim, Raghu Kalluri, Yibin Kang, Yeesim Khew‐Goodall, Herbert Levine, Jinsong Liu, Gregory D. Longmore, Sendurai A. Mani, Joan Massagué, Roberto Mayor, David R. McClay, Keith E. Mostov, Donald F. Newgreen, M Nieto, Alain Puisieux, Raymond B. Runyan, Pierre Savagner, Ben Z. Stanger, Mark Stemmler, Yoshiko Takahashi, Masatoshi Takeichi, Eric Théveneau, Jean Paul Thiery, Erik W. Thompson, Robert A. Weinberg, Elizabeth Williams, Jianhua Xing, Binhua P. Zhou, Quan Z. Sheng2020

TL;DR

The field of epithelial-mesenchymal transition (EMT) is rapidly expanding but suffers from a lack of standardized terminology and definitions, leading to confusion and misinterpretation of research. This consensus statement, developed by the EMT International Association (TEMTIA), provides much-needed guidelines and definitions to unify the field, fostering better communication and accelerating progress in understanding EMT's roles in development, disease, and cancer.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The epithelial-mesenchymal transition (EMT) is a fundamental cellular process where epithelial cells transform into mesenchymal cells, gaining migratory and invasive capabilities. This transformation is crucial for various physiological processes like embryonic development and wound healing, but it's also implicated in pathological conditions such as cancer metastasis and fibrosis.

However, the sheer volume of research (over 5,700 publications in 2019 alone) and the diverse contexts in which EMT is studied have led to a proliferation of definitions and terminology. This has created significant confusion, making it difficult for researchers to compare findings across studies, interpret data consistently, and collaborate effectively. The problem is that without a shared language and clear definitions, the field risks stagnation due to miscommunication and a lack of consensus on what constitutes EMT and its various manifestations.

Methods

This paper is not a typical research paper detailing experimental methods or data analysis. Instead, it's a Consensus Statement developed through a 2-year-long discussion among members of the EMT International Association (TEMTIA). The "method" here is essentially a community-driven consensus-building process. The authors synthesized existing knowledge, identified areas of ambiguity, and proposed standardized definitions and guidelines based on extensive deliberation and expert consensus.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. This paper is a review and consensus document, not an empirical study that relies on specific datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • EMT is a Spectrum, Not a Binary Switch: The paper strongly emphasizes that EMT is not an all-or-nothing event. Cells can exist in a range of "intermediate states" (partial EMTs) that retain some epithelial and some mesenchymal characteristics. This plasticity is key to understanding EMT's diverse roles.
  • Unified Terminology is Crucial: The core message is the urgent need for a common language. Terms like "epithelial-mesenchymal plasticity" (EMP) are proposed to better capture the dynamic and reversible nature of these transitions, moving beyond simplistic definitions.
  • Beyond Molecular Markers: While molecular markers are important, they are insufficient on their own to define EMT. The paper stresses the need to consider changes in cellular properties (morphology, behavior, junctions) alongside molecular readouts.
  • Context Matters: EMT manifests differently in various biological contexts (development, cancer, fibrosis). Definitions and interpretations must account for this context-dependent nature.
  • EMT-TFs are Key, But Not Sole Determinants: EMT-associated transcription factors (EMT-TFs) are central players, but their activity is influenced by complex regulatory networks, including post-transcriptional modifications and interactions with other signaling pathways.

Key Results

This paper's "results" are the proposed definitions and guidelines themselves. The key outcomes are:

  • Standardized Definitions: Clear definitions for EMT, MET (mesenchymal-epithelial transition), EndoMT (endothelial-mesenchymal transition), and epithelial-mesenchymal plasticity (EMP).
  • Guidelines for Assessment: Recommendations on how to assess EMT status, emphasizing the need for a combinatorial approach using cellular properties and multiple molecular markers, rather than relying on a single marker.
  • Identification of Core EMT-TFs: A table listing key EMT-TFs (Snail, Slug, Zeb1, Zeb2, Twist1) and their roles in development, cancer, and fibrosis, highlighting their conserved importance.
  • Emphasis on Plasticity: A strong argument for recognizing and studying the diverse intermediate states of EMT, rather than focusing solely on the fully epithelial or fully mesenchymal endpoints.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Acknowledged Complexity: The authors acknowledge that despite these guidelines, the full complexity and plasticity of EMT are still not completely understood. The exact nature of the "spectrum" of intermediate states (discrete vs. continuous) remains an open question.
  • Translational Challenges: A significant future direction is translating this understanding of EMT heterogeneity and plasticity into clinical practice, particularly for developing targeted therapies for cancer metastasis and therapy resistance.
  • Technological Advancements: Future research will benefit from technological innovations like single-cell live imaging, lineage tracing, and advanced gene expression analysis to better capture EMT at the cellular level.
  • Mathematical Modeling: The paper suggests that mathematical modeling, combined with experimental analysis, will be crucial for gaining a mechanistic understanding of EMT plasticity.
  • Cross-Disciplinary Collaboration: The authors advocate for continued collaboration between diverse fields (systems biology, biophysics, stem cell biology, pathology) to unravel the intricacies of EMT.

Summary updated

Abstract

Epithelial-mesenchymal transition (EMT) encompasses dynamic changes in cellular organization from epithelial to mesenchymal phenotypes, which leads to functional changes in cell migration and invasion. EMT occurs in a diverse range of physiological and pathological conditions and is driven by a conserved set of inducing signals, transcriptional regulators and downstream effectors. With over 5,700 publications indexed by Web of Science in 2019 alone, research on EMT is expanding rapidly. This growing interest warrants the need for a consensus among researchers when referring to and undertaking research on EMT. This Consensus Statement, mediated by 'the EMT International Association' (TEMTIA), is the outcome of a 2-year-long discussion among EMT researchers and aims to both clarify the nomenclature and provide definitions and guidelines for EMT research in future publications. We trust that these guidelines will help to reduce misunderstanding and misinterpretation of research data generated in various experimental models and to promote cross-disciplinary collaboration to identify and address key open questions in this research field. While recognizing the importance of maintaining diversity in experimental approaches and conceptual frameworks, we emphasize that lasting contributions of EMT research to increasing our understanding of developmental processes and combatting cancer and other diseases depend on the adoption of a unified terminology to describe EMT.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2020guidelines,
  author = {Jing Yang and Parker B. Antin and Geert Berx and Cédric Blanpain and Thomas Brabletz and Marianne Bronner‐Fraser and Kyra Campbell and Amparo Cano and Jordi Casanova and Gerhard Christofori and Shoukat Dedhar and Rik Derynck and Heide L. Ford and Jonas Fuxe and Antonio Garcı́a de Herreros and Gregory J. Goodall and Anna‐Katerina Hadjantonakis and Ruby Yun‐Ju Huang and Chaya Kalcheim and Raghu Kalluri and Yibin Kang and Yeesim Khew‐Goodall and Herbert Levine and Jinsong Liu and Gregory D. Longmore and Sendurai A. Mani and Joan Massagué and Roberto Mayor and David R. McClay and Keith E. Mostov and Donald F. Newgreen and M Nieto and Alain Puisieux and Raymond B. Runyan and Pierre Savagner and Ben Z. Stanger and Mark Stemmler and Yoshiko Takahashi and Masatoshi Takeichi and Eric Théveneau and Jean Paul Thiery and Erik W. Thompson and Robert A. Weinberg and Elizabeth Williams and Jianhua Xing and Binhua P. Zhou and Quan Z. Sheng},
  title = {{Guidelines and definitions for research on epithelial-mesenchymal transition}},
  booktitle = {LA},
  year = {2020},
}
Figure