Growing length and time scales in glass-forming liquids

Smarajit Karmakar, Chandan Dasgupta, Srikanth SastryProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2009 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The glass transition, where liquids transform into amorphous solids at low temperatures, remains a central challenge in condensed matter physics. Explaining the dramatic increase in relaxation times ($\tau$) upon supercooling is essential for understanding this transition. While theories like the Adam-Gibbs (AG) relation suggest a link between relaxation and growing structural length scales, the exact role of these scales remains debated. In this study, we employ finite-size scaling (FSS) in computer simulations of a realistic glass-former to evaluate the length scale ($\xi$) associated with spatially heterogeneous dynamics. We find that while $\xi$ grows as temperature decreases, relaxation times do not exhibit standard finite-size scaling with this length. Instead, $\tau$ is consistently determined by configurational entropy ($S_c$) across all system sizes and temperatures, supporting the Adam-Gibbs relation. These findings challenge theoretical models, such as Random First Order Transition (RFOT) theory, which suggest $S_c$ is irrelevant at temperatures significantly above the mode-coupling theory critical temperature.

Introduction

As a liquid is cooled toward its glass transition, its viscosity and relaxation time do not merely increase—they explode, often growing by 10 to 15 orders of magnitude over a narrow temperature range. This phenomenon suggests the emergence of a growing length scale, where particles must move cooperatively in increasingly large groups to allow the system to rearrange.

Two primary frameworks attempt to explain this: the Adam-Gibbs theory, which focuses on "cooperatively rearranging regions" (CRR) linked to configurational entropy, and theories of "dynamical heterogeneity," which focus on the spatial correlations of particle mobility. This research seeks to disentangle these concepts by using finite-size scaling to precisely measure these length scales and their relationship to the liquid's dramatic slowdown.

Methodology

The researchers performed Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations on a binary Lennard-Jones mixture (80:20 ratio), a standard model for metallic glasses like $Ni_{80}P_{20}$. The core of the study relies on Finite-Size Scaling (FSS), a technique typically used to study critical phenomena in magnets. By varying the system size from $N = 50$ to $1600$ particles, the authors could observe how dynamical properties change as the simulation box size approaches the intrinsic correlation length of the liquid.

Key metrics included:

  • Overlap Function $Q(t)$: Tracking particle displacement over time.
  • Dynamic Susceptibility $\chi_4(t)$: Measuring fluctuations in particle overlap to identify the peak relaxation time.
  • Binder Cumulant: A statistical tool used to achieve data collapse and extract the correlation length $\xi$.
  • Configurational Entropy ($S_c$): Derived by subtracting vibrational contributions from the total system entropy.

Key Insights

The Growth of Dynamical Heterogeneity

The study successfully identified a dynamical length scale, $\xi$, that increases as temperature drops. By using the Binder cumulant, the authors achieved a clean data collapse, confirming that $\xi$ is a robust measure of dynamical fluctuations. Between temperatures of $T=0.70$ and $0.45$, $\xi$ was observed to grow from approximately 2.11 to 6.23.

The "Slower is Smaller" Paradox

In most physical systems near a critical point, smaller systems relax faster because they are less constrained by long-range correlations. However, this study revealed a counterintuitive "slower is smaller" effect: as the system size $N$ decreased, the relaxation time $\tau$ actually increased. This suggests that the constraints of a small box hinder the cooperative rearrangements necessary for the liquid to flow.

The Primacy of the Adam-Gibbs Relation

The most significant finding was the universal applicability of the Adam-Gibbs relation. The authors demonstrated that $\log \tau$ is proportional to $1/TS_c$ across all studied temperatures and, crucially, all system sizes. While the dynamical length scale $\xi$ and the relaxation time $\tau$ both grow as the liquid cools, they do not scale together with system size in a way that suggests $\xi$ is the sole driver of the slowdown. Instead, the thermodynamic quantity $S_c$ appears to be the more fundamental predictor of dynamics.

Theoretical Implications

These results pose a significant challenge to Random First Order Transition (RFOT) theory and other spin-glass-based models. Such theories typically predict that configurational entropy should not be the primary driver of dynamics at temperatures significantly above the "Mode Coupling" temperature ($T_c$). Furthermore, the observed relationship between the relaxation time and the length scale ($\tau \sim \exp(\xi^\zeta)$) yielded an exponent $\zeta \approx 0.7$. Reconciling this with RFOT would require unphysical parameters, such as a surface tension exponent $\theta > 2$ in three dimensions.

Conclusion

By applying finite-size scaling to glass-forming liquids, this research clarifies the roles of different length scales in the glass transition. While dynamical heterogeneity is a real and measurable phenomenon with a growing length scale $\xi$, it is the configurational entropy that remains the most robust predictor of the massive increase in relaxation times. This suggests that a complete theory of the glass transition must bridge the gap between these thermodynamic and dynamical descriptions, accounting for why the Adam-Gibbs relation holds even in small, finite systems where standard scaling laws fail.

Summary updated

Abstract

The glass transition, whereby liquids transform into amorphous solids at low temperatures, is a subject of intense research despite decades of investigation. Explaining the enormous increase in relaxation times of a liquid upon supercooling is essential for understanding the glass transition. Although many theories, such as the Adam-Gibbs theory, have sought to relate growing relaxation times to length scales associated with spatial correlations in liquid structure or motion of molecules, the role of length scales in glassy dynamics is not well established. Recent studies of spatially correlated rearrangements of molecules leading to structural relaxation, termed "spatially heterogeneous dynamics," provide fresh impetus in this direction. A powerful approach to extract length scales in critical phenomena is finite-size scaling, wherein a system is studied for sizes traversing the length scales of interest. We perform finite-size scaling for a realistic glass-former, using computer simulations, to evaluate the length scale associated with spatially heterogeneous dynamics, which grows as temperature decreases. However, relaxation times that also grow with decreasing temperature do not exhibit standard finite-size scaling with this length. We show that relaxation times are instead determined, for all studied system sizes and temperatures, by configurational entropy, in accordance with the Adam-Gibbs relation, but in disagreement with theoretical expectations based on spin-glass models that configurational entropy is not relevant at temperatures substantially above the critical temperature of mode-coupling theory. Our results provide new insights into the dynamics of glass-forming liquids and pose serious challenges to existing theoretical descriptions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{karmakar2009growing,
  author = {Smarajit Karmakar and Chandan Dasgupta and Srikanth Sastry},
  title = {{Growing length and time scales in glass-forming liquids}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.0811082106},
}
Figure