Ground-state phase diagram of the three-band Hubbard model in various parametrizations from density matrix embedding theory

Zhi‐Hao Cui, Chong Sun, Ushnish Ray, Bo-Xiao Zheng, Qiming Sun, Garnet Kin‐Lic ChanarXiv 2020 · arXiv

Abstract

We compute the ground-state phase diagram of the three-band Hubbard model in various published parametrizations using density matrix embedding theory (DMET). We study the atomic-scale nature of the antiferromagnetic (AF) and superconducting (SC) orders, explicitly including the oxygen degrees of freedom. While all parametrizations display AF and SC phases, the decay of AF order with doping is significantly slower than observed experimentally, and coexistence of these orders occurs across all parameter sets. Our work highlights the importance of oxygen degrees of freedom and the need for re-evaluating current model parametrizations.

Introduction

The mechanism behind high-temperature superconductivity in cuprates remains a central challenge in condensed matter physics. A key debate centers on whether the simplified one-band Hubbard model is sufficient or if the three-band Hubbard model (Emery model), which explicitly includes oxygen $p$-orbitals, is necessary to capture the essential physics of the $CuO_2$ planes. The three-band model is more realistic but presents a vast and difficult-to-solve parameter space.

Methodology: Density Matrix Embedding Theory

To address this, we utilize Density Matrix Embedding Theory (DMET), a powerful numerical method that embeds a small, highly correlated cluster (here, a $2 \times 2$ unit of $CuO_2$) within a self-consistently determined environment. The local physics of the cluster is solved using the Density Matrix Renormalization Group (DMRG), allowing for a precise treatment of both copper and oxygen degrees of freedom. This approach enables the simultaneous investigation of antiferromagnetic (AFM) and superconducting (SC) orders.

The Ground-State Phase Diagram

Our calculations across various standard parameter sets reveal a consistent but problematic phase diagram. In all cases, AFM and SC orders coexist over a broad range of doping.

Phase diagrams for minimal and full three-band Hubbard models showing AFM and SC order parameters versus doping.

As shown in the figure above, the AFM order parameter $m_{AFM}$ decays linearly with doping but persists to much higher concentrations ($x \approx 0.3$ in minimal models) than seen in experiments, where magnetism typically vanishes by $x \approx 0.05-0.10$. Similarly, the SC order parameter $m_{SC}$ peaks at higher doping levels (~30-35%) than the experimental optimal doping of ~16%.

Sensitivity to Model Parameters

A significant insight from this study is the sensitivity of the magnetic phase to specific Hamiltonian parameters. We find that the AFM order is highly dependent on the charge-transfer gap ($\Delta_{pd}$), the energy difference between the oxygen $p$ and copper $d$ levels.

Antiferromagnetic order parameter $m_{AFM}$ as a function of doping $x$ and charge-transfer gap $\Delta_{pd}$.

The 3D visualization demonstrates that increasing $\Delta_{pd}$ significantly stabilizes the AFM phase, confirming that these systems behave as charge-transfer insulators. Interestingly, the magnetic order is relatively insensitive to the on-site repulsion $U_d$, suggesting that the charge-transfer physics is the primary driver of the phase boundaries. Furthermore, the asymmetry between hole-doping ($x > 0$) and electron-doping ($x < 0$) is evident, with electron-doping showing a more complex magnetic landscape.

Atomic-Scale Insights and Conclusions

Beyond the phase boundaries, DMET reveals "hidden" atomic-scale symmetries. We observed a local $p_{x(y)}$-symmetry modulation of the pair density on the Cu-O bonds within the larger $d_{x^2-y^2}$-wave SC order. This underscores the active role of oxygen in the superconducting state.

However, the quantitative mismatch between our theoretical phase diagrams and experimental data suggests that current standard parametrizations of the three-band Hubbard model may be incomplete. Future work must explore larger clusters to account for long-range orders like stripes and consider re-parameterizing the model to better reflect the experimental reality of cuprate superconductors.

Summary updated

Abstract

We compute the ground-state phase diagram of the three-band Hubbard model in various published parametrizations using density matrix embedding theory. We study the atomic-scale nature of the antiferromagnetic (AF) and superconducting (SC) orders, explicitly including the oxygen degrees of freedom. In the case of the AF order, as expected, the local magnetic moment localizes entirely at the copper sites and decays with doping, while in the SC phase we observe a local $p_{x (y)}$ [or $d_{xz (yz)}$]-symmetry modulation of the pair density on the Cu-O bonds within the larger scale $d_{x^2 - y^2}$-wave SC pairing order between Cu-Cu and O-O. While all parametrizations of the model display AF and SC phases, the decay of AF order with doping is too slow compared to the experimental phase diagram, and further, coexistence of AF and SC orders occurs in all parameter sets. Our work highlights the importance of the oxygen degrees of freedom in the study of atomic-scale SC orders, as well as the necessity of re-evaluating current parametrizations of the three-band Hubbard model.
BibTeX
@misc{cui2020ground,
  author = {Zhi‐Hao Cui and Chong Sun and Ushnish Ray and Bo-Xiao Zheng and Qiming Sun and Garnet Kin‐Lic Chan},
  title = {{Ground-state phase diagram of the three-band Hubbard model in various parametrizations from density matrix embedding theory}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2001.04951},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2001.04951},
}
Figure