Grooving and Absorption on Substrates to Reduce the Bulk Acoustic Wave for Surface Acoustic Wave Micro-Force Sensors

Yang Feng, Haoda Yu, Wenbo Liu, Keyong Hu, Shuifa Sun, Zhen Yang, Ben WangMicromachines 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles a key accuracy limitation in Surface Acoustic Wave (SAW) micro-force sensors by developing novel methods to suppress unwanted Bulk Acoustic Waves (BAW). By incorporating acoustic absorbers and strategically grooving the piezoelectric substrate, they significantly reduced signal sidelobes, leading to a more precise and reliable force sensor.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Surface Acoustic Wave (SAW) sensors are fantastic for measuring various physical quantities, including force, due to their high sensitivity, rapid response, and small size. However, a persistent challenge in achieving high measurement accuracy for SAW micro-force sensors is the interference from Bulk Acoustic Waves (BAW). When the interdigital transducers (IDTs) on the sensor generate SAW signals, they also inadvertently excite BAW signals. These BAW signals can travel through the substrate and be picked up by the receiving transducer, creating spurious signals (sidelobes) that distort the sensor's frequency response and ultimately reduce its measurement precision. This paper aims to mitigate this BAW interference to improve the accuracy of SAW micro-force sensors.

Methods

The researchers propose two primary methods to suppress BAW interference:

  1. Acoustic Absorbers: They applied acoustic absorbing materials (like silicone rubber) to the edges of the piezoelectric substrate. This acts to dampen and absorb the BAW reflections that would otherwise bounce off the substrate's edges and interfere with the SAW signal.
  2. Grooving the Piezoelectric Substrate: They introduced precisely machined grooves on the rear surface of the piezoelectric substrate. These grooves are designed to disrupt the propagation path of BAW signals, effectively redirecting or attenuating them before they can reach the output transducer.

They also investigated the influence of anisotropy on wave propagation and performed phase-matching analysis between IDTs and bulk waves to understand the BAW generation mechanism. Three types of sensors were fabricated and tested: one without any BAW suppression, one with acoustic absorbers, and one with both acoustic absorbers and substrate grooving.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental measurements from fabricated sensor prototypes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • BAW is a significant source of error: The paper clearly demonstrates that BAW generation is an inherent issue with IDT excitation in SAW devices and directly contributes to unwanted sidelobes, impacting sensor accuracy.
  • Dual-pronged attack on BAW: Combining acoustic absorbers with substrate grooving proves to be a highly effective strategy. The absorbers handle reflections at the edges, while the grooves disrupt the bulk wave propagation within the substrate itself.
  • Grooving as a precise control mechanism: The grooving technique allows for targeted manipulation of BAW propagation, effectively repositioning the point of maximum BAW reflection and diminishing its impact.
  • ST-X Quartz is a suitable material: The choice of ST-X quartz as the piezoelectric substrate is justified by its well-established cuts for SAW propagation and its relative lack of nonlinear effects compared to other materials like PZT or PMN-PT.

Key Results

The developed SAW micro-force sensor with both acoustic absorbers and grooved piezoelectric substrate demonstrated significant improvements:

  • Sidelobe Reduction: The sidelobe rejection was dramatically improved from 27.07 dB (without suppression) to 3.32 dB. This is a substantial reduction in spurious signal interference.
  • Performance Metrics: The tested sensor exhibited excellent performance characteristics:
  • Center frequency: 59.83 MHz
    • Fractional bandwidth: 1.33%
    • Force measurement range: 0-1000 mN
    • Linearity: 1.02%
    • Hysteresis: 0.59%
    • Repeatability: 1.11%
    • Accuracy: 1.34%

Limitations and Future Work

  • Fabrication Complexity: While effective, the grooving process adds a layer of fabrication complexity and cost to the sensor manufacturing.
  • Material Dependence: The effectiveness of the proposed methods is tied to the properties of the piezoelectric substrate material (ST-X Quartz in this study). Further research might explore these techniques with other materials.
  • Optimization of Grooves: The paper presents a specific grooving pattern. Further optimization of groove dimensions, depth, and placement could potentially lead to even greater BAW suppression.
  • Broader Applications: While focused on micro-force sensors, the principles of BAW suppression using absorbers and grooving could be applicable to other SAW device applications where spurious signals are a concern.

Summary updated

Abstract

Improving measurement accuracy is the core issue with surface acoustic wave (SAW) micro-force sensors. An electrode transducer can stimulate not only the SAW but also the bulk acoustic wave (BAW). A portion of the BAW can be picked up by the receiving transducer, leading to an unwanted or spurious signal. This can harm the device's frequency response characteristics, thereby potentially reducing the precision of the micro-force sensor's measurements. This paper examines the influence of anisotropy on wave propagation, and it also performs a phase-matching analysis between interdigital transducers (IDTs) and bulk waves. Two solutions are shown to reduce the influence of BAW for SAW micro sensors, which are arranged with acoustic absorbers at the ends of the substrate and in grooving in the piezoelectric substrate. Three different types of sensors were manufactured, and the test results showed that the sidelobes of the SAW micro-force sensor could be effectively inhibited (3.32 dB), thereby enhancing the sensitivity and performance of sensor detection. The SAW micro-force sensor manufactured using the new process was tested and the following results were obtained: the center frequency was 59.83 MHz, the fractional bandwidth was 1.33%, the range was 0-1000 mN, the linearity was 1.02%, the hysteresis was 0.59%, the repeatability was 1.11%, and the accuracy was 1.34%.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{feng2024grooving,
  author = {Yang Feng and Haoda Yu and Wenbo Liu and Keyong Hu and Shuifa Sun and Zhen Yang and Ben Wang},
  title = {{Grooving and Absorption on Substrates to Reduce the Bulk Acoustic Wave for Surface Acoustic Wave Micro-Force Sensors}},
  booktitle = {Micromachines},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/mi15050637},
}

Loading related content...

Figure