Grey Galaxies’ as an endpoint of the Kerr-AdS superradiant instability

Seok Kim, Suman Kundu, Eunwoo Lee, Jaeha Lee, Shiraz Minwalla, Chintan PatelJournal of High Energy Physics 2023

TL;DR

This paper proposes a new class of solutions called "Grey Galaxies" as the endpoint of a superradiant instability in Kerr-AdS black holes. These "galaxies" consist of a black hole surrounded by a thermal gas, offering a new perspective on the behavior of quantum gravity in certain regimes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses a long-standing puzzle in theoretical physics: what happens to a Kerr-AdS black hole when it becomes unstable due to superradiance? This instability, observed in black holes with a specific range of masses and angular velocities, suggests that these black holes are not the final state. The authors propose that instead of a simple collapse, the instability leads to a more complex, coarse-grained configuration that they term "Grey Galaxies." Understanding this endpoint is crucial for connecting the quantum field theory side of the AdS/CFT correspondence with its gravitational dual description, particularly for understanding the spectrum of operators in quantum field theories.

Methods

The authors construct their "Grey Galaxy" solutions by combining a Kerr-AdS black hole with a thermal gas. They employ a "coarse-grained" approach, treating the gas as a thermodynamic entity. Key techniques include:

  • Constructing new solutions: They build solutions to Einstein's equations that represent the black hole-gas system.
  • Thermodynamic analysis: They analyze the thermodynamics of both the gas and the combined system in canonical and microcanonical ensembles.
  • Back-reaction calculations: They study how the presence of the gas affects the spacetime metric.
  • Boundary stress tensor analysis: They examine the stress tensor at the boundary of AdS space, which is dual to the field theory stress tensor, to identify features of their solutions.
  • Comparison with existing solutions: They compare their Grey Galaxies to other known solutions like black resonators and numerical simulations of black hole evolution.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Grey Galaxies" as an endpoint: The paper conjectures that the superradiant instability of Kerr-AdS black holes doesn't lead to a simple collapse but rather to a "Grey Galaxy" configuration.
  • Black hole + thermal gas: These galaxies are a novel combination of a black hole at critical angular velocity ($ω=1$) surrounded by a large, flat disk of thermal gas.
  • Gas properties: The gas is characterized by a low energy density and large radius, with its energy and angular momentum being equal.
  • Delta function stress tensor: The boundary stress tensor of Grey Galaxies features a delta function localized at the equator of the boundary sphere, signaling a phase transition.
  • Revolving Black Holes (RBHs): A secondary class of solutions, RBHs, are also constructed but are found to be entropically subdominant to Grey Galaxies and not the true endpoint.
  • Supersymmetric implications: The authors suggest that supersymmetric versions of these solutions could provide insights into the spectrum of supersymmetric states in theories like N=4 Yang-Mills.

Key Results

  • The paper constructs a new class of solutions, "Grey Galaxies," in $d=3$ dimensions, which are proposed as the endpoint of the superradiant instability of Kerr-AdS black holes.
  • These Grey Galaxies are characterized by a black hole with $ω=1$ and a surrounding thermal gas.
  • The boundary stress tensor of Grey Galaxies exhibits a delta function localized at the equator, indicating a distinct phase.
  • "Revolving Black Holes" (RBHs) are also constructed but are found to be entropically subdominant to Grey Galaxies.
  • The paper provides a detailed analysis of the thermodynamics and metric back-reaction of these solutions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Qualitative agreement with simulations: While the paper's findings are in broad agreement with some numerical simulations of black hole evolution, they do not concretely verify the conjecture.
  • Higher dimensions: The paper primarily focuses on $d=3$ and $d=4$ dimensions, with generalizations to higher dimensions suggested but not fully explored.
  • Supersymmetric analogues: The paper speculates on the existence and implications of supersymmetric versions of these solutions, suggesting this as a fruitful area for future research.
  • Decay of RBHs: The paper suggests that RBHs might eventually decay into Grey Galaxies, but the precise mechanism and dynamics are not fully understood.
  • Field theory interpretation: A deeper understanding of the Grey Galaxy phenomenon directly from the field theory side is suggested as an important future direction.

Summary updated

Abstract

A bstract Kerr-AdS d +1 black holes for d ≥ 3 suffer from classical superradiant instabilities over a range of masses above extremality. We conjecture that these instabilities settle down into Grey Galaxies (GGs) — a new class of coarse-grained solutions to Einstein’s equations which we construct in d = 3. Grey Galaxies are made up of a black hole with critical angular velocity ω = 1 in the ‘centre’ of AdS, surrounded by a large flat disk of thermal bulk gas that revolves around the centre of AdS at the speed of light. The gas carries a finite fraction of the total energy, as its parametrically low energy density and large radius are inversely related. GGs exist at masses that extend all the way down to the unitarity bound. Their thermodynamics is that of a weakly interacting mix of Kerr-AdS black holes and the bulk gas. Their boundary stress tensor is the sum of a smooth ‘black hole’ contribution and a peaked gas contribution that is delta function localized around the equator of the boundary sphere in the large N limit. We also construct another class of solutions with the same charges; ‘Revolving Black Holes (RBHs)’. RBHs are macroscopically charged SO( d, 2) descendants of AdS-Kerr solutions, and consist of ω = 1 black holes revolving around the centre of AdS at a fixed radial location but in a quantum wave function in the angular directions. RBH solutions are marginally entropically subdominant to GG solutions and do not constitute the endpoint of the superradiant instability. Nonetheless, we argue that supersymmetric versions of these solutions have interesting implications for the spectrum of supersymmetric states in, e.g. $$ \mathcal{N} $$ <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML"> <mml:mi>N</mml:mi> </mml:math> = 4 Yang-Mills theory.
BibTeX
@article{kim2023grey,
  author = {Seok Kim and Suman Kundu and Eunwoo Lee and Jaeha Lee and Shiraz Minwalla and Chintan Patel},
  title = {{Grey Galaxies’ as an endpoint of the Kerr-AdS superradiant instability}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2023},
}
Figure