Green Phosphorene as a Promising Biosensor for Detection of Furan and p-Xylene as Biomarkers of Disease: A DFT Study

Aref Aasi, Erfan Aasi, Sadegh Mehdi Aghaei, Balaji PanchapakesanSensors 2022 · OpenReview

TL;DR

Researchers have explored Green Phosphorene (GP) as a novel material for detecting furan and p-xylene, key biomarkers for prostate cancer found in urine. Their DFT study reveals that pristine GP exhibits strong chemical adsorption and a rapid recovery time, making it a promising candidate for developing highly sensitive and reusable biosensors for early disease detection.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Prostate cancer, a significant health concern, can be effectively treated if detected early. Current diagnostic methods often rely on invasive procedures or late-stage detection. The paper addresses the need for non-invasive, highly sensitive, and early detection methods for prostate cancer. Specifically, it focuses on the potential of analyzing volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in urine, as certain VOCs like furan and p-xylene are known biomarkers for this disease. The challenge lies in developing a sensor material that can reliably and selectively detect these specific VOCs at low concentrations in a complex matrix like urine, which also contains water and other interfering molecules.

Methods

The study employs Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations, a first-principles computational method, to investigate the interactions between Green Phosphorene (GP) and target molecules. Specifically, the Atomistix ToolKit (ATK) package with the Non-Equilibrium Green's Function (NEGF) was used. The Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof (PBE) functional was utilized for approximating the exchange-correlation functional, and the Grimme (DFT-D2) algorithm was incorporated to account for Van der Waals and long-range interactions.

The researchers systematically studied:

  • Adsorption energies (Ead): To quantify the strength of the interaction between the GP surface and the molecules. Negative values indicate exothermic and favorable adsorption.
  • Charge transfer (Q): Using Mulliken population analysis to understand how electrons are exchanged between the molecule and the GP, indicating the nature of the interaction (physisorption vs. chemisorption).
  • Electronic band structure and Density of States (DOS): To analyze how the adsorption of molecules affects the electronic properties of the GP, which is crucial for sensing applications.
  • Recovery time (τ): Calculated using transition state theory and the Van't Hoff-Arrhenius equation, this parameter is critical for determining the sensor's reusability and response speed.

The study also explored the effects of doping GP with sulfur (S) and silicon (Si) atoms to see if these modifications could enhance sensing capabilities.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical calculations and does not use experimental datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Pristine GP as a superior sensor: Contrary to expectations that doping might improve sensing, the study found that pristine Green Phosphorene (GP) is a more promising candidate for detecting furan and p-xylene than S- or Si-doped GP.
  • Chemisorption is key for detection: Furan and p-xylene exhibit strong chemical adsorption on pristine GP, characterized by significant adsorption energies and charge transfer. This strong interaction is crucial for reliable detection.
  • Weak interaction with water: Water, a major component of urine, shows a weak interaction (physisorption) with pristine GP, indicated by low adsorption energy and minimal charge transfer. This suggests that GP can selectively detect the target biomarkers without being overwhelmed by water.
  • Rapid recovery for reusability: Pristine GP demonstrates a remarkably fast recovery time (1.81 seconds at room temperature under visible light) for furan. This rapid desorption is vital for a sensor to be reusable and provide quick responses.
  • Bandgap modulation as a sensing mechanism: The adsorption of furan and p-xylene causes a noticeable change in the bandgap of pristine GP, which can be a direct indicator of the presence of these biomarkers.

Key Results

  • Adsorption Energies:
    • Pristine GP-Furan: -0.73 eV
    • Pristine GP-p-Xylene: -1.46 eV
    • Pristine GP-H2O: -0.5 eV
    • Doped GP systems showed significantly lower adsorption energies for furan and p-xylene.
  • Charge Transfer:
    • Pristine GP-Furan: -0.106 e (molecule donates electrons to GP)
    • Pristine GP-p-Xylene: -0.073 e
    • Pristine GP-H2O: -0.055 e
    • Doped GP systems showed negligible or even positive charge transfer, indicating weak interactions.
  • Recovery Time (τ) at 300K (Visible Light):
    • Pristine GP-Furan: 1.81 s
    • Pristine GP-p-Xylene: 3.3 x 10¹² s (too long for practical detection)
    • Pristine GP-H2O: 2.45 x 10⁻⁴ s
  • Bandgap Changes:
    • Pristine GP bandgap: 1.06 eV
    • After furan adsorption: 1 eV
    • After p-xylene adsorption: 0.978 eV
    • After H2O adsorption: 0.997 eV (or 1 eV)

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study is purely theoretical (DFT-based). Experimental validation is crucial to confirm these findings.
  • The recovery time for p-xylene on pristine GP is extremely long, suggesting it might not be ideal for rapid detection of this specific biomarker on its own.
  • The paper acknowledges that biological probes are typically water solutions, and the competition for adsorption sites due to water concentration needs further consideration.
  • Future Work:
    • Experimental synthesis and characterization of GP-based sensors.
  • Testing the sensor's performance with real urine samples.
  • Investigating other potential biomarkers for prostate cancer.
  • Exploring strategies to improve the detection and recovery of p-xylene, perhaps through functionalization or composite materials.
  • Further theoretical studies on the effect of other dopants or defects on GP's sensing properties.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{aasi2022green,
  author = {Aref Aasi and Erfan Aasi and Sadegh Mehdi Aghaei and Balaji Panchapakesan},
  title = {{Green Phosphorene as a Promising Biosensor for Detection of Furan and p-Xylene as Biomarkers of Disease: A DFT Study}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2022},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=2JKn6L1FnG},
}
Figure