Green My LLM: Studying the key factors affecting the energy consumption of code assistants

Tristan Coignion, Clément Quinton, Romain RouvoyarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper dives into the energy consumption of LLM-powered code assistants like GitHub Copilot, revealing that a significant portion of energy is wasted on requests that are ultimately canceled or ignored. The authors propose actionable insights for optimizing configurations to achieve substantial energy savings without compromising utility, highlighting the importance of factors like concurrent developer load, model choice, and request triggering mechanisms.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly integrated into developer workflows as code assistants, offering real-time suggestions and boosting productivity. However, the environmental impact of these tools, specifically their energy consumption, is a growing concern. While research has touched upon the energy costs of training and general LLM inference, there's a gap in understanding the energy footprint of LLM-based code assistants in practical, real-world developer interactions. This paper aims to quantify this energy consumption and identify key factors that influence it, providing guidance for both users and providers to reduce this environmental impact.

Methods

The researchers developed a simulation-based approach to study the energy consumption of code assistants. They collected telemetry data from 20 developers using GitHub Copilot during a coding task to create a dataset of development traces. This dataset was then used to replay developer interactions with a controlled inference server. They systematically varied several factors, including:

  • Number of concurrent developers: Ranging from 1 to 500.
  • Streaming requests: Emulating GitHub Copilot's default behavior (canceling previous requests) versus disabling it.
  • Manual triggering: Simulating developers manually initiating requests instead of automatic triggering.
  • Code assistant model: Testing three StarCoder family models (StarCoder, StarCoder2-7b, StarCoder2-15b).
  • Quantization methods: Evaluating EETQ, BitsAndBytes-NF4, BitsAndBytes-FP4, and no quantization.
  • Maximum concurrent requests: Varying the server's capacity.
  • Number of GPUs: Using 1, 2, or 4 GPUs.

Energy consumption was measured using perf and nvidia-smi, and latency was also recorded.

Datasets

The primary dataset introduced in this paper is ASSISTANTTRACES. This dataset consists of telemetry data collected from 20 participants using GitHub Copilot during a coding task. It includes 119,774 telemetry messages, with 9,633 generation requests. This dataset is publicly available.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Wasted Energy is Significant: A substantial portion of generation requests (over 70%) are canceled or not accepted by users, representing a significant source of wasted energy.
  • Manual Triggering Saves Energy: Manually triggering code assistant suggestions can reduce energy consumption by an average of 15% and latency by 35%.
  • Concurrent Developers Boost Efficiency: Increasing the number of concurrent developers sharing an inference server significantly reduces the per-developer energy consumption by better utilizing server resources.
  • Model Size Matters: Smaller LLMs generally lead to lower energy consumption and latency.
  • Quantization's Mixed Impact: While quantization aims to reduce model size, it can surprisingly increase latency without significantly reducing energy consumption in some cases, suggesting a need for further investigation into specific quantization methods.
  • Architecture Influences Latency: Even with similar parameter counts, different model architectures (e.g., StarCoder vs. StarCoder2) can lead to vastly different latencies.

Key Results

  • Energy Savings: Manually triggering requests can save up to 25% of energy in specific configurations. Disabling streaming reduces latency by 62% on average and power consumption by 7%.
  • Per-Developer Consumption: In a "best-case scenario" with optimized configurations, the power consumption per developer could be as low as 10-20W. However, in under-utilized scenarios (e.g., small teams with dedicated servers), this can jump to around 120W.
  • Request Breakdown: Out of 9,634 generation requests, only 30% finished generating, 11% were accepted, and 8.5% remained in the code.
  • Developer Experience: Professional developers showed a lower acceptance rate of suggestions compared to students, suggesting different interaction patterns.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Participant and Task Selection: The study used a non-representative sample of developers and a relatively simple task, which might affect the generalizability of results related to request acceptance rates. Future work could involve larger, more diverse participant groups and more complex development tasks.
  • Configuration Space: The study explored a subset of possible configurations due to computational constraints. Some optimal configurations might have been missed.
  • Manual Trigger Emulation: The emulation of manual triggering was an approximation. Future research could involve studies with real users manually triggering generations.
  • Code Quality: The study did not assess the quality or correctness of the generated code, focusing solely on energy consumption and performance. Future work should investigate the trade-off between these factors.
  • Environmental Footprint: The study focused on inference server energy consumption. Future work could expand to include hardware manufacturing, datacenter energy, and other environmental impacts.
  • Quantization Impact: The surprising finding that quantization increased latency warrants further investigation into specific quantization methods and their computational costs.
  • Model Architecture: The significant latency difference between StarCoder and StarCoder2 models needs more in-depth research to understand the architectural reasons.

Summary updated

Abstract

In recent years,Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly improved in generating high-quality code, enabling their integration into developers' Integrated Development Environments (IDEs) as code assistants. These assistants, such as GitHub Copilot, deliver real-time code suggestions and can greatly enhance developers' productivity. However, the environmental impact of these tools, in particular their energy consumption, remains a key concern. This paper investigates the energy consumption of LLM-based code assistants by simulating developer interactions with GitHub Copilot and analyzing various configuration factors. We collected a dataset of development traces from 20 developers and conducted extensive software project development simulations to measure energy usage under different scenarios. Our findings reveal that the energy consumption and performance of code assistants are influenced by various factors, such as the number of concurrent developers, model size, quantization methods, and the use of streaming. Notably, a substantial portion of generation requests made by GitHub Copilot is either canceled or rejected by developers, indicating a potential area for reducing wasted computations. Based on these findings, we share actionable insights into optimizing configurations for different use cases, demonstrating that careful adjustments can lead to significant energy savings.
BibTeX
@misc{coignion2024green,
  author = {Tristan Coignion and Clément Quinton and Romain Rouvoy},
  title = {{Green My LLM: Studying the key factors affecting the energy consumption of code assistants}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2411.11892},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2411.11892},
}
Figure