GRB 221009A: Observations with LST-1 of CTAO and Implications for Structured Jets in Long Gamma-Ray Bursts

K. Abe, S. Abe, A. Abhishek, F. Acero, Arnau Aguasca-Cabot, I. Agudo, C. Alispach, D. Ambrosino, Filippo Ambrosino, L. A. Antonelli, C. Aramo, A. Arbet Engels, Cornelia Arcaro, T. T. H. Arnesen, Katsuaki Asano, A. Baktash, Matteo Balbo, Aya Bamba, Andrés Baquero, U. Barres de Almeida, J. A. Barrio, L. Barrios Jiménez, Ivana Batković, J. Baxter, J. Becerra González, E. Bernardini, J. Bernete, A. Berti, Ia. Bezshyiko, C. Bigongiari, E. Bissaldi, O. Blanch, G. Bonnoli, P. Bordas, G. Borkowski, Giulia Brunelli, A. Bulgarelli, Mirko Bunse, Irene Burelli, L. Burmistrov, M. Cardillo, Sami Caroff, A. Carosi, R. Carraro, Marie-Sophie Carrasco, F. Cassol-Brunner, Davide Cerasole, G. Ceribella, A. Cerviño Cortínez, Yating Chai, K. Cheng, A. Chiavassa, M. Chikawa, G. Chon, L. Chytka, Gloria Maria Cicciari, A. Cifuentes, J. L. Contreras, J. Cortina, H. Costantini, M. Dalchenko, P. Da Vela, F. Dazzi, A. De Angelis, Mathieu de Bony de Lavergne, R. Del Burgo, C. Delgado Mendez, J. Delgado, M. Dellaiera, D. della Volpe, B. De Lotto, L. del Peral, Raniere de Menezes, Giovanni Domenico De Palma, C. Díaz, Ambra Di Piano, F. Di Pierro, R. Di Tria, L. Di Venere, Rune Michael Dominik, D. Dominis Prester, Alice Donini, D. Dorner, M. Doro, Laura Eisenberger, D. Elsäesser, Gabriel Emery, Juan Escudero, V. Fallah Ramazanı, F. Ferrarotto, A. Fiasson, L. Foffano, F. Frías García-Lago, Stefan Fröse, Y. Fukazawa, S. Gallozzi, R. J. Garcı́a López, S. García Soto, C. GasbarraThe Astrophysical Journal Letters 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents the first very-high-energy (VHE) gamma-ray observations of the exceptionally bright GRB 221009A using the LST-1 telescope. These observations, conducted under challenging moonlight conditions, provide crucial late-time data that help constrain theoretical models of GRB jets, strongly suggesting a structured jet rather than a simple "top-hat" model.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) are the most powerful explosions in the universe, but understanding the physics of their relativistic jets, especially their structure, has been a significant challenge. While multiwavelength observations of GRB 221009A have provided strong evidence for a structured jet (meaning the jet's properties vary with angle), these observations have been limited in the VHE gamma-ray domain at later times. This gap makes it difficult to fully constrain theoretical models that attempt to explain the complex jet structures. This paper aims to fill this gap by providing VHE observations of GRB 221009A at crucial late-time epochs, allowing for a more robust comparison with and discrimination between different structured jet models.

Methods

The researchers utilized the first Large-Sized Telescope (LST-1) of the Cherenkov Telescope Array Observatory (CTAO) for their observations. A key challenge was the observation of GRB 221009A shortly after its detection, which coincided with a full moon. This "moonlight condition" significantly increases the background noise (Night Sky Background or NSB) for VHE gamma-ray telescopes. The paper details a specialized "moonlight-adapted analysis" to handle these conditions, involving adjustments to camera calibration, image cleaning, and the use of reduced high voltage on the photomultiplier tubes. Standard data analysis techniques, including event reconstruction, energy estimation, and statistical significance calculation, were adapted for these challenging conditions. The analysis was performed using both a "source-independent" and a "source-dependent" approach to ensure robustness.

Datasets

The primary dataset consists of VHE gamma-ray data collected by the LST-1 telescope for GRB 221009A between October 10th and November 2022. This data was collected under both bright moonlight and dark conditions. The analysis also utilized Monte Carlo simulations of gamma rays and protons, and the results were compared with existing multiwavelength data from GRB 221009A, including observations from Fermi-LAT, AGILE-GRID, LHAASO, HAWC, H.E.S.S., and Swift-XRT.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Moonlight is not a showstopper: The paper demonstrates that VHE gamma-ray observations are still feasible and valuable even under bright moonlight conditions, significantly increasing the duty cycle of these telescopes for transient events.
  • Late-time VHE data is crucial: The LST-1 observations, occurring 1.33 days after the burst, fill a critical observational gap, providing the earliest VHE data for GRB 221009A after the initial prompt and early afterglow phases observed by other instruments.
  • Structured jets are strongly favored: The late-time VHE data, when compared to various theoretical models, provides strong constraints that disfavor simpler "top-hat" jet models and strongly support the existence of structured jets in long GRBs.

Key Results

  • A statistically significant excess of gamma-like events (4.1 sigma) was detected by LST-1 at 1.33 days after the burst.
  • The VHE gamma-ray flux at 1.33 days was constrained to be below a few 10⁻¹¹ erg cm⁻² s⁻¹ in the 0.3-5 TeV energy band.
  • The results disfavor models that predict VHE fluxes significantly above 10⁻¹¹ erg cm⁻² s⁻¹ at 1 day after the burst.
  • The analysis showed compatibility between the source-independent and source-dependent analysis methods, confirming the robustness of the findings.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Degeneracy: Despite the new data, the authors acknowledge that structured jet models still have a large number of parameters, leading to degeneracies that make it challenging to definitively pinpoint the exact physical parameters.
  • Systematic Uncertainties: While the moonlight analysis was successful, it inherently introduces higher systematic uncertainties compared to dark observations. The paper notes a slight difference in flux between the two analysis methods at early times, which could be attributed to these systematics.
  • Future Work: The authors emphasize the need for future high-sensitivity IACT observations of GRBs across a broad range of timescales, coupled with comprehensive multiwavelength data, to further disentangle the physics of structured jets and provide deeper insights into jet formation and propagation. They also suggest that multimessenger observations could provide further constraints.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract GRB 221009A is the brightest gamma-ray burst (GRB) observed to date. Extensive observations of its afterglow emission across the electromagnetic spectrum were performed, providing the first strong evidence of a jet with a nontrivial angular structure in a long GRB. We carried out an extensive observation campaign in very-high-energy (VHE) gamma rays with the first Large-Sized Telescope of the future Cherenkov Telescope Array Observatory starting on 2022 October 10, about 1 day after the burst. A dedicated analysis of the GRB 221009A data is performed to account for the different moonlight conditions under which data were recorded. We find an excess of gamma-like events with a statistical significance of 4.1 σ during the observations taken 1.33 days after the burst, followed by background-compatible results for the later days. The results are compared with various models of afterglows from structured jets that are consistent with the published multiwavelength data but entail significant quantitative and qualitative differences in the VHE emission after 1 day. We disfavor models that imply VHE flux at 1 day considerably above 10 −11 erg cm −2 s −1 . Our late-time VHE observations can help disentangle the degeneracy among the models and provide valuable new insight into the structure of GRB jets.
BibTeX
@article{abe2025grb,
  author = {K. Abe and S. Abe and A. Abhishek and F. Acero and Arnau Aguasca-Cabot and I. Agudo and C. Alispach and D. Ambrosino and Filippo Ambrosino and L. A. Antonelli and C. Aramo and A. Arbet Engels and Cornelia Arcaro and T. T. H. Arnesen and Katsuaki Asano and T. T. H. Arnesen and A. Baktash and Matteo Balbo and Aya Bamba and Andrés Baquero and U. Barres de Almeida and J. A. Barrio and L. Barrios Jiménez and Ivana Batković and J. Baxter and J. Becerra González and E. Bernardini and J. Bernete and A. Berti and Ia. Bezshyiko and C. Bigongiari and E. Bissaldi and O. Blanch and G. Bonnoli and P. Bordas and G. Borkowski and Giulia Brunelli and A. Bulgarelli and Mirko Bunse and Irene Burelli and L. Burmistrov and M. Cardillo and Sami Caroff and A. Carosi and R. Carraro and Marie-Sophie Carrasco and F. Cassol-Brunner and Davide Cerasole and G. Ceribella and A. Cerviño Cortínez and Yating Chai and K. Cheng and A. Chiavassa and M. Chikawa and G. Chon and L. Chytka and Gloria Maria Cicciari and A. Cifuentes and J. L. Contreras and J. Cortina and H. Costantini and M. Dalchenko and P. Da Vela and F. Dazzi and A. De Angelis and Mathieu de Bony de Lavergne and R. Del Burgo and C. Delgado Mendez and J. Delgado and M. Dellaiera and D. della Volpe and B. De Lotto and L. del Peral and Raniere de Menezes and Giovanni Domenico De Palma and C. Díaz and Ambra Di Piano and F. Di Pierro and R. Di Tria and L. Di Venere and Rune Michael Dominik and D. Dominis Prester and Alice Donini and D. Dorner and M. Doro and Laura Eisenberger and D. Elsäesser and Gabriel Emery and Juan Escudero and V. Fallah Ramazanı and F. Ferrarotto and A. Fiasson and L. Foffano and F. Frías García-Lago and Stefan Fröse and Y. Fukazawa and S. Gallozzi and R. J. Garcı́a López and S. García Soto and C. Gasbarra},
  title = {{GRB 221009A: Observations with LST-1 of CTAO and Implications for Structured Jets in Long Gamma-Ray Bursts}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal Letters},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3847/2041-8213/ade4cf},
}
Figure