GRB 050915a & the Virgo detector

F. Acernese, P Amico, M. Alshourbagy, F. Antonucci, Aoudia, S., P. Astone, S. Avino, D. Babusci, F. Barone, L. Barsotti, M. Barsuglia, Th. S. Bauer, F Beauville, S. Bigotta, S. Birindelli, M. A. Bizouard, Claude Boccara, F. Bondu, V. Boschi, C. Bozzi, S. Braccini, van den Brand, F.j., V. Brisson, Buskulic, D., E. Calloni, E. Campagna, G. Carapella, F. Cavalier, R. Cavalieri, G. Cella, E. Cesarini, E. Chassande‐Mottin, N. Christensen, Christian Corda, A. Corsi, F. Cottone, A. C. Clapson, F. Di Renzo, Coulon, J.-p., E. Cuoco, A. Dari, V. Dattilo, M. Davier, A. Di Lieto, R. De Rosa, L. Di Fiore, A. Di Virgilio, B Dujardin, Antonio Eleuteri, M. Evans, I. Ferrante, F. Fidecaro, I. Fiori, Flaminio, R., Fournier, J.-d., Bartosz Fornal, F. Frasconi, L. Gammaitoni, F. Garufi, É. Genin, A. Gennai, Yi-Ming Hu, G. Giordano, Giordano, L., R. Gouaty, Daniel Grosjean, G. M. Guidi, S. Hamdani, S Hebri, H. Heitmann, I. S. Heng, E. A. Huerta, Sami Karkar, S Kreckelbergh, P. La Penna, M. Laval, N. Leroy, M. Leonardi, B. López, M. Lorenzini, Vincent Loriette, G. Losurdo, Mackowski, J.-m., E. Majoranai, N. Man, C., M. Mantovani, Fabio Marchesoni, F. Marion, L. Milano, S. Vecchi, F. Matichard, Massimo Mazzoni, F. Menzinger, C. Moins, Julien Moreau, Morgado, N., B. MoursSPIRE 2007

TL;DR

This paper details the first search for gravitational waves (GWs) coincident with a specific gamma-ray burst (GRB) using the Virgo interferometer. The study focuses on GRB 050915a and the Virgo C7 science run, aiming to develop and test a method for detecting GWs from these powerful cosmic events and to set limits on their emission strength.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) are incredibly energetic, short-lived flashes of light originating from distant cosmic events. While their electromagnetic signals are well-studied, the underlying physical processes, especially the central engines powering them, remain somewhat mysterious. Gravitational waves (GWs), ripples in spacetime, are predicted to be emitted from the immediate vicinity of these events, particularly during the catastrophic stellar explosions or mergers that are thought to produce GRBs. However, directly detecting these GWs and correlating them with GRBs has been a significant challenge. This paper addresses the problem of developing and applying a method to search for these elusive GW signals using data from the Virgo interferometer, specifically in coincidence with a known GRB, to better understand the physics of GRB progenitors and to constrain the GW emission from such events.

Methods

The researchers employed a "triggered search" strategy, meaning they looked for GW signals within a specific time window around the known GRB event. The core of their analysis relies on a "Wavelet Detection Filter" (WDF). This filter is applied to both a "background" region of data (to establish a baseline for false alarm rates) and a "signal" region (the time window around the GRB). The WDF identifies potential GW events by looking for significant deviations in the interferometer's output, characterized by a signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). Events with an SNR above a carefully determined threshold (SNR=26, chosen to yield a false alarm rate of 5 x 10⁻⁴ Hz) are considered significant. To account for the potential delay between the GRB and its associated GW emission, the signal region was set to 180 seconds. The paper also describes a calibration procedure using software injections of various GW waveform types (sine-Gaussians, Gaussians, damped sinusoids) to characterize the detector's efficiency and to establish a conversion factor between the detected SNR and the true GW strain amplitude.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study is data from the Virgo interferometer during its 5-day long "C7" science run in September 2005. This run was chosen because it coincided with the detection of GRB 050915a by the Swift satellite. No new benchmarks were introduced; instead, the study leverages existing GRB catalogs and theoretical predictions for GW emission from GRB progenitors.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • First-time GW search for a specific GRB with Virgo: This work represents a pioneering effort to correlate GW data from Virgo with a specific GRB event, paving the way for future, more sensitive searches.
  • Prototype for future searches: The methodology developed and tested here serves as a crucial prototype for future, more sensitive GW searches that will benefit from improved Virgo detector sensitivity and advanced data analysis techniques.
  • Weak expected GW signals: The authors acknowledge that current theoretical models predict very weak GW signals from GRBs, especially for events at cosmological distances, making detection extremely challenging.
  • Focus on upper limits: Due to the expected weakness of the signal and the current sensitivity of Virgo, the primary outcome of this analysis, in the absence of a detection, is to set an upper limit on the GW emission strength from GRB 050915a.

Key Results

The analysis of the Virgo C7 data, specifically the 180-second signal region around GRB 050915a, did not yield any GW events with an SNR greater than the established threshold of 26. Consequently, the researchers were unable to directly detect a GW coincident with GRB 050915a. The paper states that the next step is to define an upper-limit strain amplitude for each type of injected burst signal, corresponding to the hrss value that would have resulted in a detected SNR of 26.

Limitations and Future Work

The main limitation acknowledged is the current sensitivity of the Virgo detector, which, at the time of the C7 run, was not sufficient to detect the expectedly weak GW signals from a GRB at cosmological distances. The authors also note the uncertainties in theoretical predictions for GW signal waveforms from GRB progenitors.

Future work will involve defining these upper limits on GW strain amplitude for various waveform types. The authors emphasize that this study is a prototype and that future analyses will benefit from improved Virgo sensitivity and potentially the combined efforts of multiple GW detectors, which would significantly enhance the ability to constrain GW emission from GRBs.

Summary updated

Abstract

GravitationalWaves (GWs) are expected to be emitted in association with Gamma-Ray Bursts (GRBs). In this context, we are analyzing data collected by the Virgo interferometer during 2005 to develop a method aimed to search for coincidences between GW bursts and GRBs. Our analysis is currently focused on Virgo C7 run and the long GRB 050915a, observed by the Swift satellite. The goal of such analysis is either to identify significant events around the GRB trigger time or, in the absence of such events, to set a limit on the strength of the associated GW emission. This study is a prototype for evaluating Virgo capability in constraining the GW output associated with a typical long GRB. Here we give an overview of the procedure we are following in our analysis.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{acernese2007grb,
  author = {F. Acernese and P Amico and M. Alshourbagy and F. Antonucci and Aoudia, S. and P. Astone and S. Avino and D. Babusci and F. Barone and F. Barone and L. Barsotti and M. Barsuglia and Th. S. Bauer and F Beauville and S. Bigotta and S. Birindelli and M. A. Bizouard and Claude Boccara and F. Bondu and V. Boschi and C. Bozzi and S. Braccini and van den Brand, F.J. and F. Bondu and V. Brisson and Buskulic, D. and E. Calloni and E. Campagna and G. Carapella and F. Cavalier and R. Cavalieri and G. Cella and E. Cesarini and E. Chassande‐Mottin and N. Christensen and Christian Corda and A. Corsi and F. Cottone and A. C. Clapson and F. Di Renzo and Coulon, J.-P. and E. Cuoco and A. Dari and V. Dattilo and M. Davier and A. Di Lieto and R. De Rosa and L. Di Fiore and A. Di Virgilio and B Dujardin and Antonio Eleuteri and M. Evans and I. Ferrante and F. Fidecaro and I. Fiori and Flaminio, R. and Fournier, J.-D. and Bartosz Fornal and F. Frasconi and L. Gammaitoni and F. Garufi and É. Genin and A. Gennai and Yi-Ming Hu and G. Giordano and Giordano, L. and R. Gouaty and Daniel Grosjean and G. M. Guidi and S. Hamdani and S Hebri and H. Heitmann and I. S. Heng and E. A. Huerta and Sami Karkar and S Kreckelbergh and P. La Penna and M. Laval and N. Leroy and M. Leonardi and B. López and M. Lorenzini and Vincent Loriette and G. Losurdo and Mackowski, J.-M. and E. Majoranai and N. Man, C. and M. Mantovani and Fabio Marchesoni and F. Marion and L. Milano and S. Vecchi and F. Matichard and Massimo Mazzoni and F. Menzinger and L. Milano and C. Moins and Julien Moreau and Morgado, N. and B. Mours},
  title = {{GRB 050915a \& the Virgo detector}},
  booktitle = {SPIRE},
  year = {2007},
}
Figure