Gravitational-wave localization alone can probe origin of stellar-mass black hole mergers

I. Bartos, Zoltán Haiman, Z. Márka, Brian D. Metzger, Nicholas C. Stone, Szabolcs MárkaNature Communications 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel method to statistically identify the origin of gravitational wave (GW) events from binary black hole (BBH) mergers by correlating their locations with known populations of active galactic nuclei (AGN). Even with limited GW localization accuracy, this approach can establish a connection to AGN hosts with a few years of data, offering a new avenue to study BBH formation channels.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The detection of gravitational waves from merging binary black holes (BBHs) has opened a new window into astrophysics. However, understanding the origin of these BBH mergers is challenging. Most BBH formation channels are not expected to produce electromagnetic counterparts, and the localization accuracy of current and near-future GW detectors is limited. This makes it difficult to pinpoint the host galaxy of a single GW event and thus infer its formation channel. The paper addresses this by proposing a statistical method to link BBH mergers to rare host populations, specifically active galactic nuclei (AGN), which are known to have abundant gas that could facilitate BBH formation and rapid mergers.

Methods

The core of the paper's method relies on statistical spatial correlation. The authors propose to compare the observed distribution of GW localizations with the known distribution of AGN. For each detected GW, a localization volume is estimated. The probability of finding a certain number of AGN within this volume is calculated under two hypotheses: (1) the GW originates from a non-AGN host, where the number of AGN follows a Poisson distribution, and (2) the GW originates from an AGN host, where one AGN is guaranteed, and additional AGN follow a Poisson distribution. By combining the likelihoods from multiple GW detections, the authors construct a likelihood ratio test to statistically determine the fraction of BBH mergers originating from AGN. Monte Carlo simulations are used to determine the number of GW detections required to reject the null hypothesis (no AGN origin) with a specified significance (3σ).

Datasets

The paper utilizes simulated datasets for GW localization volumes, drawing from the work of Chen & Holz [32] for Advanced LIGO-Virgo detectors at design sensitivity. These simulations are based on realistic BBH merger scenarios (10 M☉-10 M☉ BBH mergers). The distribution of AGN is assumed based on existing astronomical catalogs and number density estimates from literature [40, 41].

Key Insights and Ideas

  • GW localization, even if imperfect, is valuable: The paper challenges the notion that limited GW localization accuracy renders it useless for probing BBH origins. It demonstrates that statistical correlation can overcome this limitation.
  • AGN as a promising host population: AGN are identified as a particularly suitable target for this statistical probe due to their potential to host BBH mergers and their relatively rare nature, making them statistically distinguishable.
  • Statistical power of multiple events: A single GW event's localization is insufficient for definitive origin determination. However, the accumulation of multiple GW detections significantly enhances the statistical power to establish a connection to a specific host population.
  • The ~5% best-localized events are crucial: The study highlights that the most constrained GW localization volumes contribute disproportionately to the statistical power of this method.

Key Results

  • Feasibility of AGN connection: The paper establishes that with 70-300 detected BBH mergers (achievable within 0.5-2 years of Advanced LIGO-Virgo operation at design sensitivity), it's possible to statistically prove a 50-100% fractional contribution from AGN hosts at 3σ significance.
  • Sensitivity to lower fractions: Even a 25% fractional contribution from AGN can be tested with approximately 1000 events (around 5 years of observation).
  • Impact of localization accuracy: The ~5% best-localized GW events are found to be the primary drivers of these constraints.
  • Scaling relation: The number of required detections scales inversely with the fractional contribution from AGN ($N_{GW,3\sigma} \propto f_{AGN}^{-1}$).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Assumptions on AGN distribution: The current analysis assumes AGN are randomly and uniformly distributed within the local universe, which is a simplification. Future work could incorporate the known clustering of AGN to improve the analysis.
  • Spatial correlation with other sources: The paper acknowledges that other host populations might also be spatially correlated with AGN, which could complicate the interpretation. This needs to be accounted for in more detailed analyses.
  • Need for comprehensive AGN catalogs: The authors emphasize the critical need for more complete and accurate AGN catalogs out to redshift z~0.2 to fully leverage this statistical method. Existing catalogs are found to be significantly incomplete.
  • Incorporating other BBH properties: Future work could combine this spatial correlation method with analyses of BBH properties (masses, spins, etc.) and host galaxy characteristics to further enhance the search sensitivity and differentiating power.
  • Extension to other rare host populations: The methodology is presented as generally applicable to other rare host populations beyond AGN.

Summary updated

Abstract

The recent discovery of gravitational waves from stellar-mass binary black hole mergers by the Laser Interferometer Gravitational-wave Observatory opened the door to alternative probes of stellar and galactic evolution, cosmology and fundamental physics. Probing the origin of binary black hole mergers will be difficult due to the expected lack of electromagnetic emission and limited localization accuracy. Associations with rare host galaxy types-such as active galactic nuclei-can nevertheless be identified statistically through spatial correlation. Here we establish the feasibility of statistically proving the connection between binary black hole mergers and active galactic nuclei as hosts, even if only a sub-population of mergers originate from active galactic nuclei. Our results are the demonstration that the limited localization of gravitational waves, previously written off as not useful to distinguish progenitor channels, can in fact contribute key information, broadening the range of astrophysical questions probed by binary black hole observations.Binary black hole mergers have recently been observed through the detection of gravitational wave signatures. The authors demonstrate that their association with active galactic nuclei can be made through a statistical spatial correlation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bartos2017gravitational,
  author = {I. Bartos and Zoltán Haiman and Z. Márka and Brian D. Metzger and Nicholas C. Stone and Szabolcs Márka},
  title = {{Gravitational-wave localization alone can probe origin of stellar-mass black hole mergers}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-017-00851-7},
}
Figure